nafiza's review
4.0
An earth changing event known as the cataclysm, a daughter searching for the truth behind her father's disappearance, a world where superheros and villains are commonplace. It's a classic comic setup but told with a heart that I've rarely seen. A stubbornly strong black female lead jumping down the rabbit hole as she tracks down the last baddie that saw her father alive. What's not to love? The plot is simple but not boring or condescending. Art style in Sherlock Frankenstein is quality without the over polished look of the DC/Marvel tradition and features crisp coloring, wonderful shade complements. I''m not a big superhero person with my comics. I prefer darker themes, slice of life, drama....but Lemire really pulled me in with this one.
joshgauthier's review against another edition
4.0
While the story of Sherlock Frankenstein does supplement and expand the world of Black Hammer, it is also a fully developed story on its own--though familiarity with Black Hammer does benefit the reading.
I wasn't always as big a fan of the artwork this time around--though there are some excellent stylistic choices, and the change in style does fit the shift in focus. Mostly though, I enjoyed the opportunity to see more of Lemire's growing Spiral City universe. He blends classic superhero tropes with a little grittiness and a flair for the comically absurd--and the result is a world that feels both familiar and fresh in equal measure.
And within all the flash and drama of a complex world of heroes and villains, Lemire continues to display his ability to convey rich emotion and sincere, flawed, dynamic characters. "Sherlock Frankenstein" provides a look into a new part of Black Hammer's world, and I was not disappointed by what I found there.
I wasn't always as big a fan of the artwork this time around--though there are some excellent stylistic choices, and the change in style does fit the shift in focus. Mostly though, I enjoyed the opportunity to see more of Lemire's growing Spiral City universe. He blends classic superhero tropes with a little grittiness and a flair for the comically absurd--and the result is a world that feels both familiar and fresh in equal measure.
And within all the flash and drama of a complex world of heroes and villains, Lemire continues to display his ability to convey rich emotion and sincere, flawed, dynamic characters. "Sherlock Frankenstein" provides a look into a new part of Black Hammer's world, and I was not disappointed by what I found there.
lyrafay12's review against another edition
adventurous
challenging
dark
emotional
funny
hopeful
lighthearted
mysterious
reflective
medium-paced
4.5
lyrafay12's review against another edition
adventurous
challenging
emotional
funny
hopeful
inspiring
mysterious
tense
medium-paced
4.75
rocketwave's review against another edition
4.0
I really like the Black Hammer universe. David Rubin's artwork is a perfect match for this background story!
crookedtreehouse's review against another edition
5.0
While existing in the same universe, and featuring the same characters as Black Hammer, this book was almost the antithesis of the main title, in terms of pacing, character development, and art style. I loved seeing the universe through Weber's eyes. While still having the incredibly stupid golden/silver age names, the reformed supervillains presented in this issue seem to have personality and purpose in a way that the heroes of Black Hammer sorely lack.
Rubin's art is stunning. The panel layouts, and when he breaks them are inspired. Stewart's color pallete aligns more with Templesmith art than the dreary Mignola-esque colors in Black Hammer.
Everything about this book gels for me, in a way that nothing in Black Hammer does.
This is a much better introduction to Lemire's universe, as it truly feels like you are discovering the mythology along with Lucy Weber.
I recommend this to anyone looking for a modern comic book story that feels nostalgic while not feeling derivative, as well as fans of Mignola's Hellboy & BPRD series.
Rubin's art is stunning. The panel layouts, and when he breaks them are inspired. Stewart's color pallete aligns more with Templesmith art than the dreary Mignola-esque colors in Black Hammer.
Everything about this book gels for me, in a way that nothing in Black Hammer does.
This is a much better introduction to Lemire's universe, as it truly feels like you are discovering the mythology along with Lucy Weber.
I recommend this to anyone looking for a modern comic book story that feels nostalgic while not feeling derivative, as well as fans of Mignola's Hellboy & BPRD series.
themtj's review against another edition
4.0
The black hammer series is a lot of fun but there are a lot of books that rehash the same story from different vantage points. Thus is one of the better ones, better than quantum age and '45.
ketallpot's review against another edition
adventurous
dark
inspiring
sad
medium-paced
- Plot- or character-driven? A mix
- Strong character development? Yes
- Loveable characters? It's complicated
- Diverse cast of characters? Yes
- Flaws of characters a main focus? Yes
4.0
jennykeery's review against another edition
4.0
Black Hammer - Jeff Lemire's superhero universe - is shaping up to be one of my favourite comic series. This tie-in title is every bit as fun, emotive and creative as the main book - it follows Black Hammer's daughter as she investigates his disappearance. David Rubin's stunning art takes you through dimly-lit back streets and secret lairs to meet a cast of deeply weird and wonderful characters. I continue to want to read everything The Great Canadian touches.
nycterisberna's review against another edition
4.0
Lo que hace acá Rubin es magistral. Lograr que cada uno de los personajes (por secundario que sea) luzca interesante y dar vida a un villano (que no es villano) en medio del universo que crea Lemire para Black Hammer (estilo superheroes de la Golden Age). La historia sirve de introducción para la hija de Blacj Hammer que sigue en la búsqueda de los superhéroes perdidos (por ende su padre) y de presentar a unos multiversos que podrían ser muy interesantes después. Muy entretenida.