Reviews

This was much more to my liking than the previous installment. Both sucked me in though - the immersion was there - but this had the story formula I prefer. I was warned that this could be similar to the third book and would obviously feature a lot more of a certain character (hint, hint, title), so I had certain expectations going into it. However, I didn't find it that similar to the third book, nor did I think we saw an awful ton of the said character. Yeah, more than usually, but in a way, it was still the same old.

If the 8th book is truly the last in Karigan's story, then this is closer to the end than before. In terms of setting up for the finale, I did pick up on a few hints of this. Nothing massive, but it is starting to feel wearier. The characters have gone through a lot by now, and whilst I love a protagonist who suffers, I do wish Karigan could tap out now. Poor Karigan. Really hoping she gets the ending she deserves!

I'm still highly enjoying how each sequel adds further worldbuilding development alongside the story arcs. In terms of length though, it did feel a tad long for what it was. Personally I don't mind that too much, but it's not something that should necessarily be happening the closer we near the end, if the extra pages aren't going to add a ton of content. Does that make sense? I'm writing this in a rush, so maybe not.

If I had to pick a fault within the series, it would not be the page count at all. There are some slightly problematic, erm, relations? That could be seen as being portrayed in a light that's romanticising the situation. Thus far I've only been there for it because it resulted in some juicy drama, but now I'm left wondering how it will become resolved. If you've read the series, you'll know which elephant in the room I'm poking at here.

Anyway. I both dread and look forward to Winterlight, then to the big wait till the finale is released!

kbrujv's review against another edition

Go to review page

3.0

read

More...