eclectictales's review against another edition
3.0
I was approved an ARC of this book by the publishers via NetGalley in exchange for an honest review. This review in its entirety was originally posted at eclectictales.com: http://www.eclectictales.com/blog/2016/08/16/review-the-crew/
The Crew was an interesting novel about soldiers’ experiences during World War One, both on the battlefield and their personal lives away from the battlefront. Much of the novel centres on the way that these soldiers bond over the course of the war and their time working together, a camraderie that’s difficult to break even when personal conflict threatens to destroy those bonds. It can be a bit of a slow read but it does shed light on the way these relationships are forged, as well as highlighting the increasing tension between Jean and Claude, but it also drives home towards the end of the novel the tragedy of war, of the youth dying and the old and the women and everyone who were left behind lingering in their wake.
Talk about the war being a ripe setting for a personal drama! Speaking of a slow burn, and similar to The Flight, the confrontation between Jean and Claude about the same woman doesn’t come to a head until the last third of the novel. Doubts and questions about whether they are talking about the same woman does arise much earlier, and Jean comes to the truth of the matter somewhere midway, leaving tensions pretty amped up until the end when Claude finds out. Helene/Denise didn’t help matters, to be honest; like, one the one hand, it sucks being the woman left behind and both men’s treatment of her was unfair, but her characterisation sadly felt a bit two-dimensional and irrationally selfish, I was getting irritated with her (and Jean) at one point when they were recklessly playing close to exposure.
In the end, The Crew was an intriguing read about the First World War. With such events circling around the characters, the ending was rather sad but the fate of one of the characters was a bit surprising on my part. Overall I’m glad to have finally read something by Joseph Kessel, and would recommend this title to those interested in reading contemporary titles about World War One.
The Crew was an interesting novel about soldiers’ experiences during World War One, both on the battlefield and their personal lives away from the battlefront. Much of the novel centres on the way that these soldiers bond over the course of the war and their time working together, a camraderie that’s difficult to break even when personal conflict threatens to destroy those bonds. It can be a bit of a slow read but it does shed light on the way these relationships are forged, as well as highlighting the increasing tension between Jean and Claude, but it also drives home towards the end of the novel the tragedy of war, of the youth dying and the old and the women and everyone who were left behind lingering in their wake.
Talk about the war being a ripe setting for a personal drama! Speaking of a slow burn, and similar to The Flight, the confrontation between Jean and Claude about the same woman doesn’t come to a head until the last third of the novel. Doubts and questions about whether they are talking about the same woman does arise much earlier, and Jean comes to the truth of the matter somewhere midway, leaving tensions pretty amped up until the end when Claude finds out. Helene/Denise didn’t help matters, to be honest; like, one the one hand, it sucks being the woman left behind and both men’s treatment of her was unfair, but her characterisation sadly felt a bit two-dimensional and irrationally selfish, I was getting irritated with her (and Jean) at one point when they were recklessly playing close to exposure.
In the end, The Crew was an intriguing read about the First World War. With such events circling around the characters, the ending was rather sad but the fate of one of the characters was a bit surprising on my part. Overall I’m glad to have finally read something by Joseph Kessel, and would recommend this title to those interested in reading contemporary titles about World War One.
isabel_rm's review against another edition
adventurous
informative
inspiring
slow-paced
- Plot- or character-driven? Character
- Strong character development? No
- Loveable characters? Yes
- Diverse cast of characters? Yes
- Flaws of characters a main focus? Yes
4.0
This book allows a strong connection with it's characters and a real immersion into the quotidian life of an air force soldier of the 1st World War
balancinghistorybooks's review
2.0
I would have read this properly had the Netgalley copy had less mistakes in it. One to try in a physical copy, I feel.
More...