kpeninger's review
4.0
While definitely the best collection of short stories by multiple authors that I have ever read, it still had just enough stories that were of lesser quality to drop this to a four star rating overall. I applaud the effort that went into this, and it is definitely the best of its kind; I would recommend that any Holmesian read this collection. Particular standouts, for me, included "Case of the Lichfield Murder"; "Adventure of the Pawnbroker's Daughter"; "Adventure of the Defenestrated Princess"; and "Adventure of the Seventh Stain." I will be seeking out the authors of those stories to see if they have anything other pastiches available!
More...