Scan barcode
ana_bernardes's review against another edition
adventurous
funny
relaxing
fast-paced
- Plot- or character-driven? A mix
- Strong character development? No
- Loveable characters? Yes
- Diverse cast of characters? No
- Flaws of characters a main focus? It's complicated
4.0
roc_ko's review against another edition
5.0
(Reseña para la edición de editorial Del Zorzal, pero con el nefasto nuevo sistema de Goodreads hasta que actualizen las cosas puede volver el cometa Halley).
El buen Obelix se enamora y termina con el corazón roto al enterarze que la muchacha que le gusta esta compremetida, sin embargo a pesar de todo decide salir al rescate de su prometido cuando se enteran que éste a sido enrolado a la fuerza en las legiones romanas rumbo a Africa.
Uno de los puntos más altos en las sagas del guerrero Galo, aquí Asterix y Obelix se enrolan en legión con un montón de soldados de diferentes naciones. Mientras tanto Goscinny y Uderzo se nota que se lo pasaron de maravilla jugando con las diferentes formas de presentar los idiomas de los legionarios de diferentes legiones: Normandos, Egipcios, Britanicos, etc., al mismo tiempo que muestan el desgaste mental que produce en los altos mandos de Roma tener que entrenar a dos de los irreductibles galos de Armorica; Prácticamente no hay ni un solo hueco en ninguna viñeta que no contenga un chiste, dejando a "Asterix Legionario" sin ninguna duda en el podio de las mejores aventuras del personaje.
Como dato extra, esta historia fue mezclada con Asterix Gladiador en la adaptación animada al cine "Asterix vs Cesar" (Aunque tiene una variedad de títulos dependiendo el país), que sin embargo se queda bastante corta en comparación a éste tomo.
El buen Obelix se enamora y termina con el corazón roto al enterarze que la muchacha que le gusta esta compremetida, sin embargo a pesar de todo decide salir al rescate de su prometido cuando se enteran que éste a sido enrolado a la fuerza en las legiones romanas rumbo a Africa.
Uno de los puntos más altos en las sagas del guerrero Galo, aquí Asterix y Obelix se enrolan en legión con un montón de soldados de diferentes naciones. Mientras tanto Goscinny y Uderzo se nota que se lo pasaron de maravilla jugando con las diferentes formas de presentar los idiomas de los legionarios de diferentes legiones: Normandos, Egipcios, Britanicos, etc., al mismo tiempo que muestan el desgaste mental que produce en los altos mandos de Roma tener que entrenar a dos de los irreductibles galos de Armorica; Prácticamente no hay ni un solo hueco en ninguna viñeta que no contenga un chiste, dejando a "Asterix Legionario" sin ninguna duda en el podio de las mejores aventuras del personaje.
Como dato extra, esta historia fue mezclada con Asterix Gladiador en la adaptación animada al cine "Asterix vs Cesar" (Aunque tiene una variedad de títulos dependiendo el país), que sin embargo se queda bastante corta en comparación a éste tomo.
cimorene1558's review against another edition
5.0
Possibly the funniest of all the Asterix books--the cross-cultural stuff is very, very amusing, and the names alone are enough to make me applaud. Not only are these great books in their original French, but they are possibly the most brilliant translations ever done!
carlosferrero72's review against another edition
5.0
Mi favorito de toda la saga. Como Mary Poppins, es prácticamente perfecto en todo: historia, dibujo, gags, personajes… incluso en la traducción, obra del gran Jaume Perich.
vigneswara_prabhu's review against another edition
4.0
Our innocent, child like and at the same time Uber violent menhir carrying Gaul is in love, with a sweet innocent girl by the name of Panacea. Unfortunately, she is a women spoken for, and her beloved Tragicomix, was conscripted to fight for Caesar's army in Africa. So our dashing duo have set out to heal the broken heart of the not so gentle giant and to rescue this tragic suitor.
Didn't we already warn you not to make sweet little dogmatix cry? Leave the trees alone, damn it!
Also my man Cacophanix cannot catch a break.
For said purpose, they decide to enroll into the Roman Legionaries themselves. Will the pair be able to endure the grueling training regimen of the strongest army of the world? Or will the Romans learn the hard way, that these particular batch of rookies are more than they bargained for?.............. The Latter, pretty definitely the latter.
What most of this story revolves around is the boys undertaking the Roman bootcamp, all to end up in hilarious and often disastrous results for their army trainers, who all end up in tears. That's what you get for taking volunteers out of two invincible magic potion powered Gauls I tell ya.
Ah, the Romans, heralding innovations in warfare since time immemorial. But, damn that's a sweet ass desert base. I want myself a base like that in a desert map in AOE
As is customary, presenting to you, the Hurricane of puns, of which there are quite a few this time around
○ Panacea
○ Soporafix
○ Tragicomix
○ Erroneus
○ Neveratalos
○ Gastronomix
○ Selectivemploymenttax
○ Hemispheric
○ Allegoric
○ Ptenisnet
○ Nefarius purpus
○ Dubius status
○ Vitriolix (H2SO4)
A good storyline, deserving 4 out of 5
Didn't we already warn you not to make sweet little dogmatix cry? Leave the trees alone, damn it!
Also my man Cacophanix cannot catch a break.
For said purpose, they decide to enroll into the Roman Legionaries themselves. Will the pair be able to endure the grueling training regimen of the strongest
What most of this story revolves around is the boys undertaking the Roman bootcamp, all to end up in hilarious and often disastrous results for their army trainers, who all end up in tears. That's what you get for taking volunteers out of two invincible magic potion powered Gauls I tell ya.
Ah, the Romans, heralding innovations in warfare since time immemorial. But, damn that's a sweet ass desert base. I want myself a base like that in a desert map in AOE
As is customary, presenting to you, the Hurricane of puns, of which there are quite a few this time around
○ Panacea
○ Soporafix
○ Tragicomix
○ Erroneus
○ Neveratalos
○ Gastronomix
○ Selectivemploymenttax
○ Hemispheric
○ Allegoric
○ Ptenisnet
○ Nefarius purpus
○ Dubius status
○ Vitriolix (H2SO4)
A good storyline, deserving 4 out of 5
ladyfie's review against another edition
adventurous
funny
lighthearted
- Plot- or character-driven? Plot
- Strong character development? No
- Loveable characters? Yes
4.5
jadejade's review
adventurous
funny
lighthearted
fast-paced
- Plot- or character-driven? Plot
- Strong character development? No
- Loveable characters? Yes
- Diverse cast of characters? Yes
- Flaws of characters a main focus? No
5.0
Full disclosure, I grew up on this series so my opinion is necessarily biased.
I'm of the view that there is no such thing as a bad Asterix book ... but some volumes, like this one, are pretty good.
As a child, I often borrowed this one from the library. As an adult, I'm still happy to pick this one up.
I'm of the view that there is no such thing as a bad Asterix book ... but some volumes, like this one, are pretty good.
As a child, I often borrowed this one from the library. As an adult, I'm still happy to pick this one up.