kjricha's review against another edition
1.0
Great premise, but suffered from lack of style. Writing is stiff and clunky. Characters feel two dimensional. Overall, I’m sad this was such a disappointment.
whatiskatelynreading's review against another edition
dark
emotional
reflective
slow-paced
- Plot- or character-driven? A mix
- Strong character development? Yes
4.0
Content Warnings
Graphic: Grief, Death, Blood, Murder, and War
bex_knighthunterbooks's review against another edition
This story wasn't keeping my attention at all and I realised I was just listening to it for completion's sake and not really following much of the plot anymore or who the side characters were because my mind kept wandering while listening. I did enjoy the setting, and the idea of telling a Baba Yaga story but the main character felt very bland, naive and lacking in agency. This both didn't fit my expectations for a centuries old legend of baba Yaga and also wasn't very interesting to read about. There was court politicking but it felt like Yaga was just being swept along rather than actively engaging in it, to then just be rescued by her talking animals occasionally. It was a stronger story at the start when it had a clear direction with helping Anastasia (i.e. what is covered in the blurb) and learning about the goings on of Moscow (although even then I was struggling with only being told about Yaga's relationship to Anastasia and not shown or really understanding why they would be close), but then it lost direction and momentum for me after that.
Also, I am a little sad at the missed opportunity of telling a story with essentially an older woman protagonist who doesn't care what people think about her, and takes no sh*t - we have enough young-looking pretty protagonists in our stories.
Also, I am a little sad at the missed opportunity of telling a story with essentially an older woman protagonist who doesn't care what people think about her, and takes no sh*t - we have enough young-looking pretty protagonists in our stories.
morticia_59's review against another edition
adventurous
dark
emotional
mysterious
sad
tense
medium-paced
- Plot- or character-driven? A mix
- Strong character development? Yes
- Loveable characters? Yes
- Diverse cast of characters? Yes
- Flaws of characters a main focus? Yes
5.0
thatpreciousplot's review against another edition
adventurous
dark
medium-paced
- Plot- or character-driven? A mix
- Strong character development? Yes
- Loveable characters? Yes
- Diverse cast of characters? No
- Flaws of characters a main focus? It's complicated
3.75
The Witch and the Tsar is a beautiful reimagining of the tale, the myth, the legend that is 'Baba Yaga'.
The book itself takes places around the 16th century in Russia, where Yaga living in the woods in her house on chicken legs is summoned by her friend Anastasia, the wife of the Tsar of Russia who is gravely ill and fears she is being poisoned and will soon die. Yaga must bring herself out of her isolation, from the comfort of her forest, to go to her friend in her time of need.
What follows is a magical and beautifully written story of Yaga and her life and the changes in Russia around her. I won't say much more about the plot itself as I went in knowing very little and I think it added even more to my enjoyment.
The book is beautifully written, if a little slow in the middle, and the author manages to capture the magical world surround Yaga and the old gods so well. I was honestly so amazed that this is a debut novel, I cannot wait to see what else this author has to offer in future if this is anything to go by!
Overall: 3.75 stars
Thanks to the publisher and Netgalley for the ARC in exchange for an honest review.
annarella's review against another edition
5.0
Slavic mythology is very complex and there's some retelling but this one was the best I read so far. A mix of mythology, fantasy, and historical facts it kept me turning pages and I loved the world building and the characters.
The author is a good storyteller and I can't wait to read another book by this author.
Highly recommended.
Many thanks to the publisher for this arc, all opinions are mine
The author is a good storyteller and I can't wait to read another book by this author.
Highly recommended.
Many thanks to the publisher for this arc, all opinions are mine
lucyp747d4's review against another edition
adventurous
challenging
dark
emotional
mysterious
sad
tense
slow-paced
- Plot- or character-driven? Plot
- Strong character development? Yes
- Loveable characters? Yes
- Diverse cast of characters? It's complicated
- Flaws of characters a main focus? Yes
4.0
leahsbooks's review against another edition
5.0
Thank you to the author for sending me an ARC of this book in exchange for an honest review.
CONTENT WARNING: mention of death of a parent, misogyny, blood, off-page harm to animals, grief, murder, gore, mention of torture, mention of rape, war
I was absolutely heartbroken when I got denied for this on NetGalley (side-eyes NetGalley), so my next step was obviously to enter a giveaway the author was running on Instagram. I didn’t win that, but my comment about how I felt when I was denied on NG must have struck a chord, because next thing I know, she slid right into my DMs and offered me a PHYSICAL ARC, which was even better than an NG copy, since now I have this beauty on my shelves for all time. I mean, I was primed to love this book from when I had first heard about it, but after reading it? I’m on a whole new level.
Baba Yaga is a folktale that many have heard of, and it’s been resurrected time and time again, yet this story manages to keep it fresh and somehow completely unique.
While many of us have heard the old Baba Yaga tale of her having the house on chicken legs, flying through the air in her mortar and pestle, and tricking children into her house so she can shove them into her oven and eat them, decorating her house with their skulls, Gilmore completely divorces the story from those elements. She keeps the house on chicken legs, but gives us more of Yaga as a person. I loved getting to know more about Yaga, her backstory, and the ways that she connects with people, allowing me to see her on a more human level.
During this story, we learn not just who Yaga is and where she comes from, but also how she connects to the land she’s from. Throughout the story, Russia is more than just a country, it’s almost like a family member in need of protection. Many of the characters are willing to lay down their lives to protect Russia, who is always referred to as “her,” and as having a long memory. The people of Russia survive not only brutal weather and living conditions, but also fight for their lands and their way of life. Despite clearly being a fantasy book, it’s also very much a historical fiction story, taking place not long after Russia came to be a country in it’s own right, but it still isn’t a very stable place.
When Yaga is called upon by her old friend, Anastasia, for help in curing her of a mysterious illness, Yaga doesn’t feel like she can say no. Especially not knowing that Anastasia is the balancing element on her husband, the unpredictable Tsar Ivan. He is the one man keeping Russia from teetering into all-out chaos, and Yaga is going to do everything in her power to make sure she keeps her friend healthy and protect Russia.
“Rumor had it that marriage had tamed the tsar’s naturally violent ways, that his tsaritsa restrained his worst impulses. Her intelligence and faith guided him. If something were to happen to her, it would not just be her sons who suffered. It would be Russia and her people.”
Yaga is also torn by the way Christianity has supplanted the old gods. Yaga herself is the daughter of one of the old gods, and it’s frustrating to her to see the worship wither away in favor of the new god.
“My usual reaction to icons was a stab of jealousy. This god was exalted, celebrated in resplendent wealth; my gods were forgotten, prayed to in shameful, guilt-ridden secrecy. He had triumphed while my gods had lost.”
Once Yaga reaches Moscow, what she discovers is so much worse than she even expected. She comes face to face with enemies and tricks at every turn, and it kept me on the edge of my seat. She’s forced to rely on all of her magic, her smarts, and her knowledge of people for stakes that are higher than ever.
“Here was a tsar whose crown had made him into a tragedy, a suspicious and vindictive man, volatile and unpredictable. He loved today only to hate tomorrow.”
Overall, this was a subversive and feminist story that pulled me in from start to finish. Instead of Yaga being the villain, she was the hero, fighting against her traditional antihero, Koshey Bessmertney (the Deathless), but also the system that dictates only one path for women, and working with a range of people to save a Russia that they all love. I loved seeing a lesbian couple featured prominently, especially during this time period, and the romance included in the book was beautifully done, capturing my heart without overwhelming the story. If you’re going to read one Baba Yaga retelling, THIS IS IT.
CONTENT WARNING: mention of death of a parent, misogyny, blood, off-page harm to animals, grief, murder, gore, mention of torture, mention of rape, war
I was absolutely heartbroken when I got denied for this on NetGalley (side-eyes NetGalley), so my next step was obviously to enter a giveaway the author was running on Instagram. I didn’t win that, but my comment about how I felt when I was denied on NG must have struck a chord, because next thing I know, she slid right into my DMs and offered me a PHYSICAL ARC, which was even better than an NG copy, since now I have this beauty on my shelves for all time. I mean, I was primed to love this book from when I had first heard about it, but after reading it? I’m on a whole new level.
Baba Yaga is a folktale that many have heard of, and it’s been resurrected time and time again, yet this story manages to keep it fresh and somehow completely unique.
While many of us have heard the old Baba Yaga tale of her having the house on chicken legs, flying through the air in her mortar and pestle, and tricking children into her house so she can shove them into her oven and eat them, decorating her house with their skulls, Gilmore completely divorces the story from those elements. She keeps the house on chicken legs, but gives us more of Yaga as a person. I loved getting to know more about Yaga, her backstory, and the ways that she connects with people, allowing me to see her on a more human level.
During this story, we learn not just who Yaga is and where she comes from, but also how she connects to the land she’s from. Throughout the story, Russia is more than just a country, it’s almost like a family member in need of protection. Many of the characters are willing to lay down their lives to protect Russia, who is always referred to as “her,” and as having a long memory. The people of Russia survive not only brutal weather and living conditions, but also fight for their lands and their way of life. Despite clearly being a fantasy book, it’s also very much a historical fiction story, taking place not long after Russia came to be a country in it’s own right, but it still isn’t a very stable place.
When Yaga is called upon by her old friend, Anastasia, for help in curing her of a mysterious illness, Yaga doesn’t feel like she can say no. Especially not knowing that Anastasia is the balancing element on her husband, the unpredictable Tsar Ivan. He is the one man keeping Russia from teetering into all-out chaos, and Yaga is going to do everything in her power to make sure she keeps her friend healthy and protect Russia.
“Rumor had it that marriage had tamed the tsar’s naturally violent ways, that his tsaritsa restrained his worst impulses. Her intelligence and faith guided him. If something were to happen to her, it would not just be her sons who suffered. It would be Russia and her people.”
Yaga is also torn by the way Christianity has supplanted the old gods. Yaga herself is the daughter of one of the old gods, and it’s frustrating to her to see the worship wither away in favor of the new god.
“My usual reaction to icons was a stab of jealousy. This god was exalted, celebrated in resplendent wealth; my gods were forgotten, prayed to in shameful, guilt-ridden secrecy. He had triumphed while my gods had lost.”
Once Yaga reaches Moscow, what she discovers is so much worse than she even expected. She comes face to face with enemies and tricks at every turn, and it kept me on the edge of my seat. She’s forced to rely on all of her magic, her smarts, and her knowledge of people for stakes that are higher than ever.
“Here was a tsar whose crown had made him into a tragedy, a suspicious and vindictive man, volatile and unpredictable. He loved today only to hate tomorrow.”
Overall, this was a subversive and feminist story that pulled me in from start to finish. Instead of Yaga being the villain, she was the hero, fighting against her traditional antihero, Koshey Bessmertney (the Deathless), but also the system that dictates only one path for women, and working with a range of people to save a Russia that they all love. I loved seeing a lesbian couple featured prominently, especially during this time period, and the romance included in the book was beautifully done, capturing my heart without overwhelming the story. If you’re going to read one Baba Yaga retelling, THIS IS IT.
wisecraic's review against another edition
adventurous
dark
medium-paced
- Plot- or character-driven? A mix
- Strong character development? Yes
- Loveable characters? Yes
- Diverse cast of characters? Yes
- Flaws of characters a main focus? Yes
3.5