nwhyte's review
3.0
https://nwhyte.livejournal.com/2985225.html
Ten authors listed here, all of them men; no women among the artists either. It's a straightforward book of short stories featuring the Tenth Doctor and Donna (apart from the last two, in which Ten on his own links up with a plucky lad for adventure), none terribly memorable and none awful either, with art that varies from OK to good.
Having said that none of the written stories are awful, I am dubious about the comic strip, by Jonathan Morris with art by Rob Davis, in which it turns out that the terracotta army are disabled robots previously under the control of a cyborg Chinese emperor. Maybe better not to recast other cultures' achievements as "really' alien technology.
Ten authors listed here, all of them men; no women among the artists either. It's a straightforward book of short stories featuring the Tenth Doctor and Donna (apart from the last two, in which Ten on his own links up with a plucky lad for adventure), none terribly memorable and none awful either, with art that varies from OK to good.
Having said that none of the written stories are awful, I am dubious about the comic strip, by Jonathan Morris with art by Rob Davis, in which it turns out that the terracotta army are disabled robots previously under the control of a cyborg Chinese emperor. Maybe better not to recast other cultures' achievements as "really' alien technology.
didyousaybooks's review against another edition
3.0
I had a little troubled getting into the stories. I didn.t think Donna was sounding much like Donna lots of times.
This might be a better fit for younger readers are the stories are short and illustrated.
This might be a better fit for younger readers are the stories are short and illustrated.
More...