ajnel's review against another edition
dark
emotional
mysterious
reflective
sad
fast-paced
- Plot- or character-driven? A mix
- Strong character development? Yes
- Loveable characters? It's complicated
- Diverse cast of characters? Yes
- Flaws of characters a main focus? Yes
5.0
Rankln's breakthrough novel into the top tier of crime fiction centre around two serial killers in two different era, the later essentially being a copycat of the former. As always, a number of other mysteries also comes into play, whilst further incidents which influenced Rebus' persona is brought to the forefront. 4.5 /5
richard1510's review against another edition
challenging
dark
medium-paced
- Plot- or character-driven? A mix
- Strong character development? Yes
- Loveable characters? No
- Diverse cast of characters? Yes
- Flaws of characters a main focus? It's complicated
4.5
mazza57's review against another edition
4.0
I love the characterisation of Rebus he is both a good cop, bad cop. This was a great story line with some basis in fact and very all written
hilaryistired's review against another edition
2.0
2.5/5
This was not my first attempt at a Rebus book, but it is the first one I successfully got through. A friend of mine loves this series, and loaned me this book in the hopes that it would be better than the first book in the series, which I gave up on within 60 pages. I was a little skeptical about starting on the eighth book of a series, but he said that I would have no trouble keeping up.
That much was true. While there are some things that would have made more sense with knowledge of previous books, I had no trouble figuring out what was going on. A few details got missed, but none of the major plot points. And since the writing is ten thousand times better in this book than in the first of the series, it's a pretty good trade.
The book itself isn't anything spectacular. There's nothing particularly shocking or unique or wonderful about this mystery that sets it apart from any others, though many other Goodreads reviews seem to disagree with me. I didn't find the story that intriguing, nor were the characters anything to write home about. It was fine, but that's about it.
The Good Points of Black and Blue:
You know those books that are so easy to read that it doesn't really feel like you're reading? Yeah, this book is like that. It's easy to get into the story and forget that it's really just words on a page.
Every now and again, we got a small section from Bible John's perspective, which I absolutely loved. We got to see inside his head and see his side of the story, rather than just that of the protagonist. It made this whole book ten times better, and made the ending much more interesting.
The mystery is pulled together beautifully in the end. At the beginning of this book, it seemed like Rebus was getting caught up in a bunch of things that had a whole lot of nothing to do with anything else that was happening. But somehow, Rankin finds a way to make it all work, and pulls it off very well.
The Downsides of Black and Blue:
The pacing in this book was a joke. It would be fascinating and engaging for a couple of chapters, only to fall completely dead and dull or another six. There was a lot of telling, rather than doing in these slow parts, making it drag on and on. Honestly, I ended up skipping whole sections, just to find something that made me want to continue reading this book.
There was no need for 98% of the drinking scenes and conversations in this book. Yes, we know Rebus is an alcohol. We know he has a problem. We don't need to see it on every other page. This book would be half the size if we cut out all the unnecessary pub scenes.
Considering that this is the 8th book in the series, I would have expected more of Rebus' character. He was rather flat, and there wasn't a whole lot to him aside from a lot of history. I felt he should have been more developed by this point, which likely would have helped the pacing issue.
All in all, this book was fine. I don't know if I'll bother with anymore of them, because this one didn't leave me with any motivation to go seek out the next. But my friend loves them, so they may end up in my hands whether I like it or not. We'll just have to see.
This was not my first attempt at a Rebus book, but it is the first one I successfully got through. A friend of mine loves this series, and loaned me this book in the hopes that it would be better than the first book in the series, which I gave up on within 60 pages. I was a little skeptical about starting on the eighth book of a series, but he said that I would have no trouble keeping up.
That much was true. While there are some things that would have made more sense with knowledge of previous books, I had no trouble figuring out what was going on. A few details got missed, but none of the major plot points. And since the writing is ten thousand times better in this book than in the first of the series, it's a pretty good trade.
The book itself isn't anything spectacular. There's nothing particularly shocking or unique or wonderful about this mystery that sets it apart from any others, though many other Goodreads reviews seem to disagree with me. I didn't find the story that intriguing, nor were the characters anything to write home about. It was fine, but that's about it.
The Good Points of Black and Blue:
You know those books that are so easy to read that it doesn't really feel like you're reading? Yeah, this book is like that. It's easy to get into the story and forget that it's really just words on a page.
Every now and again, we got a small section from Bible John's perspective, which I absolutely loved. We got to see inside his head and see his side of the story, rather than just that of the protagonist. It made this whole book ten times better, and made the ending much more interesting.
The mystery is pulled together beautifully in the end. At the beginning of this book, it seemed like Rebus was getting caught up in a bunch of things that had a whole lot of nothing to do with anything else that was happening. But somehow, Rankin finds a way to make it all work, and pulls it off very well.
The Downsides of Black and Blue:
The pacing in this book was a joke. It would be fascinating and engaging for a couple of chapters, only to fall completely dead and dull or another six. There was a lot of telling, rather than doing in these slow parts, making it drag on and on. Honestly, I ended up skipping whole sections, just to find something that made me want to continue reading this book.
There was no need for 98% of the drinking scenes and conversations in this book. Yes, we know Rebus is an alcohol. We know he has a problem. We don't need to see it on every other page. This book would be half the size if we cut out all the unnecessary pub scenes.
Considering that this is the 8th book in the series, I would have expected more of Rebus' character. He was rather flat, and there wasn't a whole lot to him aside from a lot of history. I felt he should have been more developed by this point, which likely would have helped the pacing issue.
All in all, this book was fine. I don't know if I'll bother with anymore of them, because this one didn't leave me with any motivation to go seek out the next. But my friend loves them, so they may end up in my hands whether I like it or not. We'll just have to see.
ali_13's review against another edition
Ok so I really tried with this book but I can’t get into the writing style. Have of the time I have no idea what is happening. I did only read like 4 chapters but idc because I am not gonna force myself to read something I am not enjoying.
bibliobethreads's review against another edition
Enjoyed this book much more than the previous Rebus novels, better storyline, fast paced, and we learn more about the Rebus who fights his demons.
viktoriya's review against another edition
2.0
This was my first book by Ian Rankin and I am not sure I want to read him again. I felt that this book was moving way too slow, I didn't really care for Inspector Rebus at all. Oh, and the ending....What ending?
woolfardis's review against another edition
4.0
[Short and quick review from memory before I re-read and review at a later date:
As with books that focus on one character (usually crime thrillers) the singular books are difficult to recall without reading the blurb (which I don't want to do for this mini reviews). But it's Rebus, and the whole thing is written well, with great atmosphere and a detective who actually works out the crimes rather than stumbles in to the like a certain other Scottish detective I can name...]
As with books that focus on one character (usually crime thrillers) the singular books are difficult to recall without reading the blurb (which I don't want to do for this mini reviews). But it's Rebus, and the whole thing is written well, with great atmosphere and a detective who actually works out the crimes rather than stumbles in to the like a certain other Scottish detective I can name...]
juniperusxx's review against another edition
3.0
Tämä oli nyt toinen lukemani Rebus-dekkari, se ensimmäinen oli Ristinolla. En tiedä, jäivätkö Rankinin lukemiset nyt sitten tähän - tämä ei oikein iskenyt. Tämä oli jotenkin turhan maskuliininen dekkariksi, vähän kuin olisi katsellut toimintaelokuvaa, jotka nekään eivät ole minun juttuni. Ehkä öljynporauslautat ympäristönäkään eivät tehneet tästä kirjasta ihan minun näköistäni...
stephms's review against another edition
4.0
This one took me a bit to get through.. the plot line was a bit complex, with multiple threads all eventually coming together. The image of Rebus on the oil rig was a favorite, though, and there was a lot of character development in this book.