mrs_skywalker's review
3.0
z wielkim serduszkiem, nic specjalnego, ale jest świątecznie i Doktorowo — i ma perełki
kitvaria_sarene's review
5.0
As most doctor who books I've read so far this one was amazing too.
As always there are some stories I loved, some I liked and one that didn't do it so much for me.
But overall it was a fantastic, action packed, christmassy and entertaining read that I enjoyed a lot and will most likely reread next Christmas. ;)
As always there are some stories I loved, some I liked and one that didn't do it so much for me.
But overall it was a fantastic, action packed, christmassy and entertaining read that I enjoyed a lot and will most likely reread next Christmas. ;)
spellacl's review against another edition
3.0
Nice stories that mingle through some of the episodes.
standardman's review against another edition
4.0
A nice bit of festive fun, weaving in and out of continuity
sarahrara's review against another edition
4.0
Overall a fun book of Doctor adventures. I don't know the doctors from the original Doctor Who that well, apart from the first doctor, so I enjoyed the NuWho stories a bit more, as well as the very first one which was kind of cute.
I felt the essence of the doctors I know was well captured, and the ones I didn't really know for some reason mostly reminded me of 12. Maybe the old school doctors were less cuddly than 9 through 11.
I did feel they were mostly a tad on the short side and if they'd been a bit longer there would have been more time for plot development and resolution, but it was still a nice Christmas read.
I felt the essence of the doctors I know was well captured, and the ones I didn't really know for some reason mostly reminded me of 12. Maybe the old school doctors were less cuddly than 9 through 11.
I did feel they were mostly a tad on the short side and if they'd been a bit longer there would have been more time for plot development and resolution, but it was still a nice Christmas read.
aleighshareads13's review
4.0
4.125/5 stars.
All I Want for Christmas – 4.5/5
A Comedy of Terrors – 3/5
The Christmas Inversion – 5/5
Three Wise Men – 4.5/5
Sontar’s Little Helpers – 4/5
Fairy Tale of New York – 4.5/5
The Grotto – 2.5/5
Ghost of Christmas Past – 5/5
The Red Bicycle – 4/5
Loose Wire – 3.5/5
The Gift – 5/5
The Persistence of Memory – 4/5
All I Want for Christmas – 4.5/5
A Comedy of Terrors – 3/5
The Christmas Inversion – 5/5
Three Wise Men – 4.5/5
Sontar’s Little Helpers – 4/5
Fairy Tale of New York – 4.5/5
The Grotto – 2.5/5
Ghost of Christmas Past – 5/5
The Red Bicycle – 4/5
Loose Wire – 3.5/5
The Gift – 5/5
The Persistence of Memory – 4/5
ashlylynne's review
2.0
2.5
What a disappointment. A few of the stories were alright, one was good, but most were just...okay. Cute stories, but nothing very substantial. And with such a pretty cover! I'm sad.
FRTC
What a disappointment. A few of the stories were alright, one was good, but most were just...okay. Cute stories, but nothing very substantial. And with such a pretty cover! I'm sad.
FRTC
fellumhistane's review
3.0
Some stories were very enchanting and well written, others were terrible and belonged more to the realm of fanfiction. A nice little set of fun before the holidays.