livlosiewicz's review against another edition
dark
emotional
reflective
medium-paced
- Plot- or character-driven? Character
- Strong character development? Yes
- Loveable characters? It's complicated
- Diverse cast of characters? No
- Flaws of characters a main focus? Yes
4.25
Pros:
•The writing is beautiful! This book has a strong sense of place
•I liked the structure and the different timelines, and how they weaved back and forth, a lot. It added a really well-crafted air of mystery to the novel and kept me captivated
•I also really liked how we could understand the characters’ (mostly Elle’s) decisions, even if we didn’t agree with them. Elle is a VERY flawed character, but we come to understand how she got there, which makes her more fascinating than frustrating to me
•Overall, this book is a creative and well-written exploration of the lasting impact of trauma, and how it can impact its victims not always in one big way, but a million small ways. I disagree with GR users saying the trauma was gratuitous. I think it was hard to read (and totally okay to not want to read it or not like it) but essential for the story Heller was trying to tell
Cons:
•okay, I didn’t like Jonas. I kept thinking I was going to grow to like him, but we didn’t get much characterization from him besides lovesick/horny. I know why she liked him as a kid, but why now?
•Normally, I’m a sucker for an ambiguous ending, but this was one that needed a more decisive ending for me to stick its point. Apparently, Heller didn’t think it was ambiguous, but after reading a bit more background, I think my original interpretation of the end was the opposite of what she’d intended. Basically, there’s an interpretation of the ending that works really well for me when considering the book and its themes, and if that’s not the ending that you interpret, I think it kind of weakens the book and leaves me less satisfied
Recommendation: I recommend for readers who like books with a strong sense of place, books that travel through dual timelines, and books with complicated characters making complicated decisions. This book is really well-written and deliberate, and I was really drawn into it, despite some nitpicky reservations. Please beware before picking this up, there are SIGNIFICANT content warnings. If you’re not in a place to read about trauma/don’t want to, skip this!!
•The writing is beautiful! This book has a strong sense of place
•I liked the structure and the different timelines, and how they weaved back and forth, a lot. It added a really well-crafted air of mystery to the novel and kept me captivated
•I also really liked how we could understand the characters’ (mostly Elle’s) decisions, even if we didn’t agree with them. Elle is a VERY flawed character, but we come to understand how she got there, which makes her more fascinating than frustrating to me
•Overall, this book is a creative and well-written exploration of the lasting impact of trauma, and how it can impact its victims not always in one big way, but a million small ways. I disagree with GR users saying the trauma was gratuitous. I think it was hard to read (and totally okay to not want to read it or not like it) but essential for the story Heller was trying to tell
Cons:
•okay, I didn’t like Jonas. I kept thinking I was going to grow to like him, but we didn’t get much characterization from him besides lovesick/horny. I know why she liked him as a kid, but why now?
•Normally, I’m a sucker for an ambiguous ending, but this was one that needed a more decisive ending for me to stick its point. Apparently, Heller didn’t think it was ambiguous, but after reading a bit more background, I think my original interpretation of the end was the opposite of what she’d intended. Basically, there’s an interpretation of the ending that works really well for me when considering the book and its themes, and if that’s not the ending that you interpret, I think it kind of weakens the book and leaves me less satisfied
Recommendation: I recommend for readers who like books with a strong sense of place, books that travel through dual timelines, and books with complicated characters making complicated decisions. This book is really well-written and deliberate, and I was really drawn into it, despite some nitpicky reservations. Please beware before picking this up, there are SIGNIFICANT content warnings. If you’re not in a place to read about trauma/don’t want to, skip this!!
Content Warnings
Graphic: Rape, Sexual assault, and Pedophilia
Moderate: Child abuse
Minor: Terminal illness
georgie_mb's review
emotional
reflective
slow-paced
- Plot- or character-driven? Character
- Strong character development? Yes
- Loveable characters? No
- Diverse cast of characters? No
- Flaws of characters a main focus? Yes
2.75
I feel really mixed about this. Maybe this is more of a 2.75 than a 3…
Let’s start with the positives: the descriptions are truly beautiful, and that honestly was a whole star in my rrating system. I could see The Paper Palace and it’s surrounding, it was a very sensory experience.
For some reason (and I don’t really know why), I got more into this in the second half than the first, and I’m wondering whether it was because I settled into the banter of the family. Possibly because it reminded me slightly of my own…
I do have some issues with it though. Firstly I don’t think it helped that the Audible narrator sounded like the female US Siri which made some of it come across as very cold. But I think even looking past that, some parts really lacked emotion, and almost came across as harsh. I found this particularly hard to swallow when it come to the really disturbing parts, so much so I had to skip forward sometimes.
I also found the storyline lacked purpose. I think with the beginning it set it up to be a completely different book to what it turned out to be, and I was left slightly disappointed by that. There just didn’t seem to be any clear direction, regardless of the varying time lines.
Let’s start with the positives: the descriptions are truly beautiful, and that honestly was a whole star in my rrating system. I could see The Paper Palace and it’s surrounding, it was a very sensory experience.
For some reason (and I don’t really know why), I got more into this in the second half than the first, and I’m wondering whether it was because I settled into the banter of the family. Possibly because it reminded me slightly of my own…
I do have some issues with it though. Firstly I don’t think it helped that the Audible narrator sounded like the female US Siri which made some of it come across as very cold. But I think even looking past that, some parts really lacked emotion, and almost came across as harsh. I found this particularly hard to swallow when it come to the really disturbing parts, so much so I had to skip forward sometimes.
I also found the storyline lacked purpose. I think with the beginning it set it up to be a completely different book to what it turned out to be, and I was left slightly disappointed by that. There just didn’t seem to be any clear direction, regardless of the varying time lines.
Content Warnings
Graphic: Child abuse, Cancer, Child death, Cursing, Sexual assault, Death, Incest, Infidelity, and Rape
Moderate: Cancer, Terminal illness, Death of parent, Toxic relationship, and Alcohol
bryn_cavin's review against another edition
dark
emotional
reflective
tense
slow-paced
3.75
Content Warnings
Graphic: Sexual assault, Rape, and Sexual violence
Moderate: Animal cruelty, Child death, Animal death, Incest, and Terminal illness
bellarosereads's review against another edition
dark
emotional
mysterious
tense
medium-paced
- Plot- or character-driven? Character
- Strong character development? It's complicated
- Loveable characters? It's complicated
- Diverse cast of characters? No
- Flaws of characters a main focus? Yes
3.5
Content Warnings
Graphic: Death, Rape, Sexual assault, Sexual harassment, Incest, and Infidelity
Moderate: Miscarriage, Infertility, and Suicide
Minor: Terminal illness and Cancer
lbh_0327's review against another edition
dark
emotional
sad
fast-paced
- Plot- or character-driven? A mix
- Strong character development? It's complicated
- Loveable characters? No
- Diverse cast of characters? No
- Flaws of characters a main focus? Yes
2.5
Content Warnings
Graphic: Child death, Emotional abuse, Pregnancy, Sexual assault, Death, Sexual content, Incest, and Sexual violence
Minor: Terminal illness, Cancer, Vomit, Alcohol, Body shaming, Drug use, Alcoholism, Gaslighting, Grief, and Suicidal thoughts
cecilialau_'s review against another edition
4.25
This was defo a page-turner for me. I felt pretty immersed in the story. I am still torn when it comes to the rating tbh. As I don’t want to rate it based on character likability (bc that shit is complicated), and I found it a frustrating read at times.
I think the author is very accomplished in getting the characters to act/interact/react authentically (however disturbing or sad it might be for the reader). Quite a lot of deeply disturbing/tragic occurrences making it a very tough read at times. There’s a point where I wanted to fight one of the characters… I was beyond fuming.
Anna was a favourite. Eleanor is definitely a flawed character - sometimes you know what explains her behaviour but it was also clear that she didn’t want the responsibility of making the choice between the two. But it is almost impossible when you have a love for both, I do recognise that. Not sure how I felt about the ending bc she could easily change her mind from one moment to the next. Which was so heartbreaking for Jonas to keep having to relive. I do, though, like that she was self-aware most of the time e.g. in how her blaming Jonas (unfairly but understandably immaturely) was their downfall after the drowning - but Jonas was 14 at the time for goodness sake …
I think the author is very accomplished in getting the characters to act/interact/react authentically (however disturbing or sad it might be for the reader). Quite a lot of deeply disturbing/tragic occurrences making it a very tough read at times. There’s a point where I wanted to fight one of the characters… I was beyond fuming.
Spoiler
The weakness of the dad was hard to read. The girls had a lot going against them from the start. Many of the things that happened (outside of the most heinous ones done by Conrad which made me f-ing fuming) made me want to cry for them.Anna was a favourite. Eleanor is definitely a flawed character - sometimes you know what explains her behaviour but it was also clear that she didn’t want the responsibility of making the choice between the two. But it is almost impossible when you have a love for both, I do recognise that. Not sure how I felt about the ending bc she could easily change her mind from one moment to the next. Which was so heartbreaking for Jonas to keep having to relive. I do, though, like that she was self-aware most of the time e.g. in how her blaming Jonas (unfairly but understandably immaturely) was their downfall after the drowning - but Jonas was 14 at the time for goodness sake …
Content Warnings
Graphic: Rape
Moderate: Suicidal thoughts, Sexual harassment, Abandonment, Child death, Terminal illness, Death, Fatphobia, and Rape
serenereadssally's review against another edition
dark
emotional
sad
slow-paced
- Plot- or character-driven? Character
- Strong character development? Yes
- Loveable characters? No
- Diverse cast of characters? No
- Flaws of characters a main focus? Yes
3.0
I have mixed feelings about this book. Within the first 5 minutes of reading this there is an unnecessary description of child sexual abuse, just thrown in a paragraph like it’s nothing.
This then becomes a theme throughout the book, which also includes abusive neglectful parents, animal abuse, incest, child rape, knife crime and, now seeming tame in comparison, marital infidelity.
While I understand we should not run from these subjects I’m not sure in this case we should have run towards them. A lot of the descriptions felt gratuitous and not needed. The writing was good, hence the three stars, but this just backs up my opinion that she didn’t need to throw all this at the storyline in such a graphic way. I skipped over the sexual abuse scenes as they were truly stomach churning.
I also felt that while I know not all stories ‘go somewhere’ the ending left me feeling very flat. But then, I wonder where it could have gone anyway.
The character building was wonderful, the atmosphere and ambience of the back woods was delicious. She captured guilt and loss and heartbreak perfectly and I enjoyed the unusual timeline, but I feel she didn’t need all the other stuff.
Definitely think it’s a divisive book. Would I recommend? Probably no, there are much better in this genre. Please make sure you read trigger warnings.
⭐️⭐️⭐️
Content Warnings
Graphic: Pedophilia, Terminal illness, Child abuse, Violence, Adult/minor relationship, Animal cruelty, Child death, Emotional abuse, Incest, Infidelity, Rape, Sexual content, Sexual harassment, Sexual violence, Toxic relationship, and Sexual assault
molroseh's review against another edition
adventurous
emotional
sad
tense
medium-paced
- Plot- or character-driven? Character
- Strong character development? It's complicated
- Loveable characters? Yes
- Diverse cast of characters? Yes
3.5
Content Warnings
Graphic: Death, Incest, Infidelity, Rape, Sexual assault, Sexual content, and Sexual harassment
Moderate: Cancer, Miscarriage, Chronic illness, Pregnancy, and Terminal illness
kaffee_auf_ex's review against another edition
dark
emotional
reflective
sad
tense
slow-paced
- Plot- or character-driven? Character
- Strong character development? No
- Loveable characters? No
- Diverse cast of characters? No
- Flaws of characters a main focus? Yes
2.0
Beautifully written, yet so incredibly problematic.
Every adult in this book only exists to abuse Elle. Even strangers only exist to punch her or break into her house and assault her. All the adults are abusive towards children. Trauma is there for pure shock value and to be edgy.
Reese Witherspoon teased that there would be a fascinating love triangle. She absolutely broke my trust. You call this a love triangle?
- mild spoilers ahead -
Does it deserve to be a love triangle if the husband and mother team up to abuse Elle? If we are told that she loves him but everytime she things to herself that she loves him it is in a situation in which he was being toxic because that's all he ever is? He is a red flag walking from the very moment he comes into her life. All he ever does is gaslight her and never take her seriously but instead bully her together with her mother who is incredibly abusive.
And maybe this could be okay if there was something that we get out of all that. If she ever realised he was being abused or really call out her mother for the incredible amount of abuse. But she never does.
And I won't even talk about Jonas not being a consent king because compared to all of the rape and abuse going on, he is the nicest person in the book if you don't count Anna who is my favourite character.
The story is unnecessarily long and filled with some more abuse that we don't need. Yes, there's an abusive spouse of a parent. Oh wait, they get remarried and we get another abusive spouse because the first wasn't enough. Oh, here's a family friend or whatever behaving inappropriately towards children.
And here is some abuse that another family member face that is not directly relevant but still told to us in graphic detail like all of the rape is because, well, shock value.
It's so sad that a woman can't have character growth without sexual drama but wait - there's no character growth. Elle is one of the worst main characters I have ever read because she is passive from the beginning even when her own passiveness hurts more people than just herself and she never learns. She never calls out abuse for what it is.
Let me summarise what this book is: Straight cis rich white people abusing each other and especially children because they don't have enough struggles in their lives to keep athem entertained and plot convenience. Easily the least diverse book I have read in my live because it doesn't feature anything else than straight cis rich white people.
One mayor question remains: Why did the author waste her incredible writing talent for such an edgy and tone deaf story? To sell more books? To have more chances at having it picked up for TV adaption? Because damn, that woman can write. She really sucked me in. I hope for her to get some perspective and write something less problematic because yes, I would like to read more of her writing, just a whole different story.
Every adult in this book only exists to abuse Elle. Even strangers only exist to punch her or break into her house and assault her. All the adults are abusive towards children. Trauma is there for pure shock value and to be edgy.
Reese Witherspoon teased that there would be a fascinating love triangle. She absolutely broke my trust. You call this a love triangle?
- mild spoilers ahead -
Spoiler
Does it deserve to be a love triangle if the husband and mother team up to abuse Elle? If we are told that she loves him but everytime she things to herself that she loves him it is in a situation in which he was being toxic because that's all he ever is? He is a red flag walking from the very moment he comes into her life. All he ever does is gaslight her and never take her seriously but instead bully her together with her mother who is incredibly abusive.
And maybe this could be okay if there was something that we get out of all that. If she ever realised he was being abused or really call out her mother for the incredible amount of abuse. But she never does.
And I won't even talk about Jonas not being a consent king because compared to all of the rape and abuse going on, he is the nicest person in the book if you don't count Anna who is my favourite character.
The story is unnecessarily long and filled with some more abuse that we don't need. Yes, there's an abusive spouse of a parent. Oh wait, they get remarried and we get another abusive spouse because the first wasn't enough. Oh, here's a family friend or whatever behaving inappropriately towards children.
And here is some abuse that another family member face that is not directly relevant but still told to us in graphic detail like all of the rape is because, well, shock value.
It's so sad that a woman can't have character growth without sexual drama but wait - there's no character growth. Elle is one of the worst main characters I have ever read because she is passive from the beginning even when her own passiveness hurts more people than just herself and she never learns. She never calls out abuse for what it is.
Let me summarise what this book is: Straight cis rich white people abusing each other and especially children because they don't have enough struggles in their lives to keep athem entertained and plot convenience. Easily the least diverse book I have read in my live because it doesn't feature anything else than straight cis rich white people.
One mayor question remains: Why did the author waste her incredible writing talent for such an edgy and tone deaf story? To sell more books? To have more chances at having it picked up for TV adaption? Because damn, that woman can write. She really sucked me in. I hope for her to get some perspective and write something less problematic because yes, I would like to read more of her writing, just a whole different story.
Content Warnings
Graphic: Sexual harassment, Sexual content, Death, Child abuse, Abandonment, Toxic relationship, Rape, Sexual violence, Sexual assault, Gaslighting, Emotional abuse, Domestic abuse, and Bullying
Moderate: Child death and Terminal illness
shofoho's review against another edition
dark
emotional
reflective
medium-paced
- Plot- or character-driven? Character
- Strong character development? Yes
- Loveable characters? It's complicated
- Diverse cast of characters? No
- Flaws of characters a main focus? Yes
3.75
Content Warnings
Graphic: Grief, Pedophilia, Infidelity, Rape, Sexual assault, Sexual content, and Sexual violence
Moderate: Death
Minor: Child abuse, Terminal illness, and Miscarriage