Scan barcode
mrsbooknerd's review against another edition
5.0
As with most other reviewers, I loved 'Outlander'. I mean, why would I pick up the monstrously heavy 'Dragonfly in Amber' if I hadn’t? but I did gird my wrists for reading the second in the series, and my expectations along with it, because how easy it could be to fall from such a dizzying height of enjoyment in a 'sequel'.
The novel was in three distinct parts. The first was not at all like 'Outlander' and had me worried that I wouldn't be able to finish this novel should it continue throughout. Luckily it did improve and the second and third were much like 'Outlander' full of tension, drama, near-misses, emotion and all those good things that kept me on the edge of my seat and muttering to myself.
Set in France and with a new host of characters, storylines and settings, I found it difficult to keep up with all the new characters and their relationships and political stances in the early part of the book. Once I was more settled, I found this a little easier, but found that the plot tended to drift. It wasn't that the 'drift' was uninteresting as such, but in such a big book, I felt that constant progression was needed, because it doesn't take much for interest to waver. For example, Claire's work at the hospital was interesting, but it didn't need the amount of pages afforded to it. I would much rather have seen progression elsewhere in the plot. Raymond and his dealings were an okay read, but did it need so much page time? Luckily, the setting changed toward the end of the first section and the plot was far more tense and dramatic, shooting the book from a wavering 4* review to a solid 5* review.
I did struggle with knowing that Claire was alive and well in her own time as I read the book. I thought that it was giving away something but I came to realise the impact that the knowledge had on my blood pressure the further I made it into the novel. Every time they met with danger I would stop breathing and wonder if this was how it happened. It made the final goodbye so much more emotional because it had been building in my mind for a nine hundred pages.
I found that I grew more affectionate toward Jamie in this novel. It wasn't that I had disliked him in 'Outlander' but he hadn't climbed onto my list of 'Fictional Boyfriends'. I felt that he had a more rounded personality in this novel, full of depth and nuance that was missing in the first. He tended to just come across as a big, tall masculine man who punched first and asked questions later in the first novel. Yet in this novel, I saw his intelligence, loyalty and sense of responsibility. I wanted to know time and time again how he felt about his new role as saviour of the clans and the pressure that he was being burdened with. Perhaps a few chapters in his voice would lend itself to building his personality and would break up Claire's narratives. While I still wouldn't say that he is on my list of boyfriends, he is certainly closer than he was.
The most enjoyable - if I can call it that - aspect of these novels is that Jamie and Claire suffer. They aren't spared the brutality of the time because they are the heroes. They are hurt and threatened and injured and raped and subjected to awful things constantly, and this really ramps up the tension because you do not know what will happen to them or how it will affect their relationship. Not like in a Regency Romance where you know that good will win over evil every time.
My problem is that, again, I cannot wait to get into the next book in the series, and yet I don't want to risk reading another 1000 page book so soon for fear of overdosing. Bloody cliff-hangers! They will be the death of me.
The novel was in three distinct parts. The first was not at all like 'Outlander' and had me worried that I wouldn't be able to finish this novel should it continue throughout. Luckily it did improve and the second and third were much like 'Outlander' full of tension, drama, near-misses, emotion and all those good things that kept me on the edge of my seat and muttering to myself.
Set in France and with a new host of characters, storylines and settings, I found it difficult to keep up with all the new characters and their relationships and political stances in the early part of the book. Once I was more settled, I found this a little easier, but found that the plot tended to drift. It wasn't that the 'drift' was uninteresting as such, but in such a big book, I felt that constant progression was needed, because it doesn't take much for interest to waver. For example, Claire's work at the hospital was interesting, but it didn't need the amount of pages afforded to it. I would much rather have seen progression elsewhere in the plot. Raymond and his dealings were an okay read, but did it need so much page time? Luckily, the setting changed toward the end of the first section and the plot was far more tense and dramatic, shooting the book from a wavering 4* review to a solid 5* review.
I did struggle with knowing that Claire was alive and well in her own time as I read the book. I thought that it was giving away something but I came to realise the impact that the knowledge had on my blood pressure the further I made it into the novel. Every time they met with danger I would stop breathing and wonder if this was how it happened. It made the final goodbye so much more emotional because it had been building in my mind for a nine hundred pages.
I found that I grew more affectionate toward Jamie in this novel. It wasn't that I had disliked him in 'Outlander' but he hadn't climbed onto my list of 'Fictional Boyfriends'. I felt that he had a more rounded personality in this novel, full of depth and nuance that was missing in the first. He tended to just come across as a big, tall masculine man who punched first and asked questions later in the first novel. Yet in this novel, I saw his intelligence, loyalty and sense of responsibility. I wanted to know time and time again how he felt about his new role as saviour of the clans and the pressure that he was being burdened with. Perhaps a few chapters in his voice would lend itself to building his personality and would break up Claire's narratives. While I still wouldn't say that he is on my list of boyfriends, he is certainly closer than he was.
The most enjoyable - if I can call it that - aspect of these novels is that Jamie and Claire suffer. They aren't spared the brutality of the time because they are the heroes. They are hurt and threatened and injured and raped and subjected to awful things constantly, and this really ramps up the tension because you do not know what will happen to them or how it will affect their relationship. Not like in a Regency Romance where you know that good will win over evil every time.
My problem is that, again, I cannot wait to get into the next book in the series, and yet I don't want to risk reading another 1000 page book so soon for fear of overdosing. Bloody cliff-hangers! They will be the death of me.
genetic_reader's review against another edition
adventurous
emotional
mysterious
reflective
medium-paced
- Plot- or character-driven? A mix
- Strong character development? It's complicated
- Loveable characters? Yes
- Diverse cast of characters? Yes
- Flaws of characters a main focus? No
4.0
This book is great but the beginning is very jarring with the perspective change and time jump.
jbapmasc's review against another edition
3.0
Way too long!!! A lot of boring parts. The beginning and the ending were good, but a lot of the middle should've been cut out, there was no need for it to be that long!
haileswhales's review against another edition
adventurous
emotional
mysterious
medium-paced
- Plot- or character-driven? Plot
- Strong character development? Yes
- Loveable characters? Yes
- Diverse cast of characters? It's complicated
- Flaws of characters a main focus? It's complicated
4.75
pslili1998's review against another edition
adventurous
emotional
medium-paced
- Plot- or character-driven? A mix
- Strong character development? Yes
- Loveable characters? Yes
- Diverse cast of characters? No
- Flaws of characters a main focus? It's complicated
4.5
Really love this series and while I love the first book the most because of the story there. I love the characters more and more with every next book, as they get more defined and grown up.
Now I want to go to Scotland.
mozbolt's review against another edition
5.0
I LOVED the second Outlander book so much, but it has me soooo emotionally messed up! It answered all the questions I had from book one, only to create a whole new set of cliffhangers that are begging me to start book 3. I'm so conflicted because I almost feel like the story kind of came to a good end and I was... almost okay with it, especially since I can't imagine what new craziness Diana reveals in Voyager. But at the same time, I know I would be pissed off if this is where it ended so I'm definitely going into the next one with high anticipation. Dragonfly in Amber was very historically motivated, which was incredibly interesting. I really enjoyed the whole France setting in the first half of the book too; I wasn't expecting the books to stray from Scotland, but I liked the intertwined histories and cultures, especially surrounding the insane politics. It was also cool to read about real historical figures (*cough* Charles *cough*) as actual humans because it increases one's sense of the reality of the past, rather than glorifying individuals based on biased or exaggerated stories. And Jamie and Claire are in my top 5 OTPs... steamy and hilarious as always! This is just such a good series, I'm absolutely obsessed with everything about it.
lmkzss's review against another edition
adventurous
emotional
funny
sad
medium-paced
- Plot- or character-driven? Character
- Loveable characters? Yes
- Diverse cast of characters? Yes
5.0
alisal's review against another edition
adventurous
dark
emotional
mysterious
tense
medium-paced
4.25