kchisholm's review against another edition
ORPHEUS RISING is a standalone from Colin Bateman, perhaps best known for his dark, comic previous offerings set mostly in Northern Island. Which this one isn't - it's set in the US, albeit with an Irish central character - Michael Ryan. Although you'd be hard pressed to remember he's supposed to be Irish, as the setting is 100% mid-Atlantic sort of nowhere particularly special. But then I'd imagine setting wasn't the whole point of ORPHEUS RISING, although I confess I'm not 100% sure what the point of the book was at all.
Basically Michael is smitten when he meets and eventually marries Claire. He's been on a sort of a road trip around America, lobbing into the small town where she lives with her father - the local newspaper owner - at the time that's she's pulling the porn shop owner out of the ocean after a shark attack. Michael stays - works for the newspaper for a while - writes his great American novel. Claire's got a bit of a past with a weird ex-boyfriend who she says isn't. Long story short - she's shot dead in a bank robbery. Michael goes completely off the rails, but returns, years later, the writer of the "great novel" who is haunted by visions of his wife, who he claims has returned from the dead. Along with a whole heap of other people.
Now I confess I'm a huge fan of Colin Bateman's books - and ORPHEUS RISING wasn't really what I was expecting from this author - but the book just gets, well flat out weird very very quickly. And it stays weird for most of the narrative. And not good weird - just weird weird for a fair part of it. This probably isn't helped by Michael Ryan starting off just a bit annoying and ending up very very annoying. Maybe it's because some of the supporting characters are too over the top as well - Ambrose, who he is travelling with in the later part of the book, is just gross and mostly not very funny and Michael is flat out just unlikeable. Not that being unlikeable is a bad thing for a central character - it's just that there's got to be something that keeps you interested in him - and I struggled to find a single thing that involved me.
The structure of the book was interesting - maybe that was the only weird bit that was good weird. But, despite a willingness to store my disbelief out the back, and expect the totally unexpected, ORPHEUS RISING ended up a bit too much like hard work.
Basically Michael is smitten when he meets and eventually marries Claire. He's been on a sort of a road trip around America, lobbing into the small town where she lives with her father - the local newspaper owner - at the time that's she's pulling the porn shop owner out of the ocean after a shark attack. Michael stays - works for the newspaper for a while - writes his great American novel. Claire's got a bit of a past with a weird ex-boyfriend who she says isn't. Long story short - she's shot dead in a bank robbery. Michael goes completely off the rails, but returns, years later, the writer of the "great novel" who is haunted by visions of his wife, who he claims has returned from the dead. Along with a whole heap of other people.
Now I confess I'm a huge fan of Colin Bateman's books - and ORPHEUS RISING wasn't really what I was expecting from this author - but the book just gets, well flat out weird very very quickly. And it stays weird for most of the narrative. And not good weird - just weird weird for a fair part of it. This probably isn't helped by Michael Ryan starting off just a bit annoying and ending up very very annoying. Maybe it's because some of the supporting characters are too over the top as well - Ambrose, who he is travelling with in the later part of the book, is just gross and mostly not very funny and Michael is flat out just unlikeable. Not that being unlikeable is a bad thing for a central character - it's just that there's got to be something that keeps you interested in him - and I struggled to find a single thing that involved me.
The structure of the book was interesting - maybe that was the only weird bit that was good weird. But, despite a willingness to store my disbelief out the back, and expect the totally unexpected, ORPHEUS RISING ended up a bit too much like hard work.
littlemissbookworm's review
3.0
"You have to understand this. I die in the end."
When Michael Ryan first sets foot in Brevard, Florida, he spots a woman that immediately sparks his interest. Even though quite a few guys aren't happy to witness it, they become a couple and get married. But their luck doesn't last, because Claire is murdered at a bank robbery. After that Michael ups and leaves town and only comes back 10 years later to attend a memorial in the victims' honor. He can't believe his eyes when he sees Claire, right there in Brevard, though. Could she still be alive?
I have seriously mixed feelings about this book. "Orpheus Rising" starts slow and really drags on for the first half of the book until, finally, something interesting happens. Initially, I was really confused as to the sudden turn of events, which I absolutely did not see coming and thought to be really odd. But as the story went on, I learned to enjoy the way it was going. Until the end, that is. I am not sure, I agree with that.
The characters I did not particularly like. Ambrose, Michael's companion, a cheating drunk and full-of-himself Pulitzer winner, I probably disliked the most.
Also, I can't quite understand the fuss about Claire. Why is everybody just dying to be with her?
By no means did this novel blow my mind, but once you've made it through the first half of it, it really picks up its speed and becomes an interesting, sometimes funny, all in all enjoyable read.
When Michael Ryan first sets foot in Brevard, Florida, he spots a woman that immediately sparks his interest. Even though quite a few guys aren't happy to witness it, they become a couple and get married. But their luck doesn't last, because Claire is murdered at a bank robbery. After that Michael ups and leaves town and only comes back 10 years later to attend a memorial in the victims' honor. He can't believe his eyes when he sees Claire, right there in Brevard, though. Could she still be alive?
I have seriously mixed feelings about this book. "Orpheus Rising" starts slow and really drags on for the first half of the book until, finally, something interesting happens. Initially, I was really confused as to the sudden turn of events, which I absolutely did not see coming and thought to be really odd. But as the story went on, I learned to enjoy the way it was going. Until the end, that is. I am not sure, I agree with that.
The characters I did not particularly like. Ambrose, Michael's companion, a cheating drunk and full-of-himself Pulitzer winner, I probably disliked the most.
Also, I can't quite understand the fuss about Claire. Why is everybody just dying to be with her?
By no means did this novel blow my mind, but once you've made it through the first half of it, it really picks up its speed and becomes an interesting, sometimes funny, all in all enjoyable read.
haydenjweal's review
adventurous
challenging
dark
emotional
funny
mysterious
tense
medium-paced
- Plot- or character-driven? Character
- Strong character development? No
- Loveable characters? Yes
- Diverse cast of characters? No
- Flaws of characters a main focus? Yes
5.0
scotchneat's review
4.0
A pretty tight plot in terms of motif for Bateman, but also dabbles in the poltergeisty and I'm not sure how much I liked that part of it. It starts with a shark attack.
Michael Ryan write a super bestseller called Space Coast but his wife is murdered in a bank robbery so he disappears from the limelight.
10 years later, he's back for a civic celebration and to finally get some closure on his grief for his wife. He brings along an alkie Pulitzer-winning bully who likes the ladies (particularly if they are loose), and he meets the daughter of his old neighbour/doctor, and he drinks. A lot.
It's Bateman, so expect anything.
Michael Ryan write a super bestseller called Space Coast but his wife is murdered in a bank robbery so he disappears from the limelight.
10 years later, he's back for a civic celebration and to finally get some closure on his grief for his wife. He brings along an alkie Pulitzer-winning bully who likes the ladies (particularly if they are loose), and he meets the daughter of his old neighbour/doctor, and he drinks. A lot.
It's Bateman, so expect anything.
More...