Scan barcode
kccool12255's review against another edition
adventurous
challenging
dark
hopeful
inspiring
mysterious
tense
medium-paced
- Plot- or character-driven? A mix
- Strong character development? It's complicated
- Loveable characters? Yes
- Diverse cast of characters? Yes
- Flaws of characters a main focus? It's complicated
4.75
Now, let's be honest.
Did One of Us Is Lying NEED a sequel? No.
Were all of the characters and their archs perfectly summed up, even in the first book? Yes.
But am I going to buy every new book and devour it every single time? Yes.
This is by no means the best book I've ever read, but for what it is, this is absolutely AMAZING. Karen M. McManus KNOWS what she's doing, and she EXCELS at her craft every single time. Though One of Us Is Lying didn't need a follow-up, she smashed it out of the park with One of Us is Next, and you just HAD to have a follow-up to the cliffhanger ending. I love every single one of these characters, and I love reading in their POVs and seeing how they react to situations, as well as make (very understandable) mistakes. It was great getting to read Addy's and Nate's POVs again, since I did miss them from the first book, and even Phoebe's POV was much better than last book. She's had a lot of development, and I love seeing her (and her relationship with Knox) on the page. (Though I still am complaining how we didn't get a kiss scene, but I do understand and respect that they're taking things slow. It would've been GREAT to see, though. I don't think we had ANY kiss scenes in this book.) However, I do question the logic of THESE three characters being chosen for POVs in this book. Since we have like NINE main characters now, I was under the impression that Karen M. McManus was going to do split-POVs with ALL of them, and while that could've been very messy, I still would've liked to see it attempted. Bronwyn and Cooper got shoved into the background a LOT as a result, and it's sad that we don't get to see as much of them as usual. What I also would've liked to see is maybe some POVs from the characters we HAVEN'T seen yet. Namely, Luis, Kris, maybe even Vanessa, this random girl who gains importance this book, and maybe Keely, since she's also kind of important to the story (I get she's on vacation, but maybe if she was a main character, she could've been given more of a role in the mystery-solving aspect.) Luis and Kris are CONTINUALLY shoved into the background of this book, and bringing their POVs in could've made them more central characters. One of Us Is Lying had Bronwyn, Cooper, Addy, and Nate, and then the second book switched it up by bringing in Maeve, Bronwyn's sister, Knox, and Phoebe, and I would've loved to see new main characters for this book as well. But I don't hate the final product, and I think these POVs gave a lot of insight and a lot more depth to the story overall. I LOVE seeing Nate's development as well as Phoebe's, and as always, I love seeing how much of a girlboss Addy is becoming.
Speaking of Addy, I do have a slight critique. Was her budding romance with Keely REALLY necessary? I mean, I know she's finally gaining independence after ending her relationship with Jake, but I would've really just preferred to see her remain single. I also don't think it's necessary to make her gay, but that's a story for another time. Bottom line is, I don't HATE the pairing, but I would've loved to just see Addy stay single and continue to figure out her place in the world.
What I do LOVE, though, is getting to see Jake and SIMON'S POVs. That was a VERY welcome surprise, and it added a lot to the story. Everything came together in the end, which is always nice to see.
And because I don't know where else to put this, while some character relationships were really well-developed and fleshed out, others felt completely abandoned. Like what the heck happened to Maeve and Knox being best friends? I get they both have romantic interests now, but I don't think we saw them interacting with each other in a scene ONCE this book. It was very disappointing.
But in retrospect, the ending also feels very lackluster. I know Karen M. McManus definitely didn't PLAN for these books initially becoming a series, but I wish the "villains" were more tied together and cohesive. Jake DID come back in this book, but he wasn't the main villain, and it was just honestly a little disappointing, though the plot twists were definitely well-implemented. And talking about books being well-tied together, we didn't even get a really good GAME in this book. In the first book, you had all the gossip thingies, in the second book, we had dangerous truth or dare, but in this book, we don't really get much of ANYTHING other than the "practice makes perfect", which doesn't even turn out to be that important, if I remember correctlly . And the ending is REALLY nice, but I wish it had involved good things for ALL of the characters, not just Addy. Kinda like in the epilogue of the first book, where EVERYBODY comes together for the ending. I just wish that wasn't the ending for the entire series, was just Addy reflecting and looking forward to the future.
But all that being said, I absolutely LOVE this book. While it could've done more, I LOVE reading about these characters and this world, and I wouldn't change that for anything.
It's been a fun journey, One of Us Is Lying. I'm gonna miss you.
Did One of Us Is Lying NEED a sequel? No.
Were all of the characters and their archs perfectly summed up, even in the first book? Yes.
But am I going to buy every new book and devour it every single time? Yes.
This is by no means the best book I've ever read, but for what it is, this is absolutely AMAZING. Karen M. McManus KNOWS what she's doing, and she EXCELS at her craft every single time. Though One of Us Is Lying didn't need a follow-up, she smashed it out of the park with One of Us is Next, and you just HAD to have a follow-up to the cliffhanger ending. I love every single one of these characters, and I love reading in their POVs and seeing how they react to situations, as well as make (very understandable) mistakes. It was great getting to read Addy's and Nate's POVs again, since I did miss them from the first book, and even Phoebe's POV was much better than last book. She's had a lot of development, and I love seeing her (and her relationship with Knox) on the page. (Though I still am complaining how we didn't get a kiss scene, but I do understand and respect that they're taking things slow. It would've been GREAT to see, though. I don't think we had ANY kiss scenes in this book.) However, I do question the logic of THESE three characters being chosen for POVs in this book. Since we have like NINE main characters now, I was under the impression that Karen M. McManus was going to do split-POVs with ALL of them, and while that could've been very messy, I still would've liked to see it attempted. Bronwyn and Cooper got shoved into the background a LOT as a result, and it's sad that we don't get to see as much of them as usual. What I also would've liked to see is maybe some POVs from the characters we HAVEN'T seen yet. Namely, Luis, Kris, maybe even Vanessa, this random girl who gains importance this book, and maybe Keely, since she's also kind of important to the story (I get she's on vacation, but maybe if she was a main character, she could've been given more of a role in the mystery-solving aspect.) Luis and Kris are CONTINUALLY shoved into the background of this book, and bringing their POVs in could've made them more central characters. One of Us Is Lying had Bronwyn, Cooper, Addy, and Nate, and then the second book switched it up by bringing in Maeve, Bronwyn's sister, Knox, and Phoebe, and I would've loved to see new main characters for this book as well. But I don't hate the final product, and I think these POVs gave a lot of insight and a lot more depth to the story overall. I LOVE seeing Nate's development as well as Phoebe's, and as always, I love seeing how much of a girlboss Addy is becoming.
Speaking of Addy, I do have a slight critique.
What I do LOVE, though, is getting to see Jake and SIMON'S POVs. That was a VERY welcome surprise, and it added a lot to the story. Everything came together in the end, which is always nice to see.
And because I don't know where else to put this, while some character relationships were really well-developed and fleshed out, others felt completely abandoned. Like what the heck happened to Maeve and Knox being best friends? I get they both have romantic interests now, but I don't think we saw them interacting with each other in a scene ONCE this book. It was very disappointing.
But in retrospect, the ending also feels very lackluster. I know Karen M. McManus definitely didn't PLAN for these books initially becoming a series, but I wish the "villains" were more tied together and cohesive. Jake DID come back in this book, but he wasn't the main villain, and it was just honestly a little disappointing, though the plot twists were definitely well-implemented. And talking about books being well-tied together, we didn't even get a really good GAME in this book. In the first book, you had all the gossip thingies, in the second book, we had dangerous truth or dare, but in this book, we don't really get much of ANYTHING
But all that being said, I absolutely LOVE this book. While it could've done more, I LOVE reading about these characters and this world, and I wouldn't change that for anything.
It's been a fun journey, One of Us Is Lying. I'm gonna miss you.
Content Warnings
Moderate: Cursing, Death, Gore, Gun violence, Physical abuse, Toxic relationship, Violence, Blood, Kidnapping, Stalking, Car accident, Murder, and Injury/Injury detail
Minor: Vomit
aseel_reads's review against another edition
dark
mysterious
tense
medium-paced
- Plot- or character-driven? A mix
- Strong character development? Yes
- Loveable characters? It's complicated
- Diverse cast of characters? Yes
- Flaws of characters a main focus? Yes
2.75
This was fine, a good circling back to the original story but otherwise, just a simple read
Content Warnings
Moderate: Death, Kidnapping, Stalking, and Murder
Minor: Bullying, Outing, and Sexual harassment
sare1125's review against another edition
adventurous
mysterious
fast-paced
- Plot- or character-driven? A mix
- Strong character development? N/A
- Loveable characters? Yes
- Diverse cast of characters? Yes
- Flaws of characters a main focus? No
4.0
Content Warnings
Graphic: Death
luananki's review against another edition
dark
mysterious
tense
medium-paced
- Plot- or character-driven? A mix
- Strong character development? Yes
- Loveable characters? Yes
- Diverse cast of characters? N/A
- Flaws of characters a main focus? Yes
4.5
this was a perfect ending for the bayview crew, i’m very happy i finally got to read it
although some of the characters felt a little off, i had so much fun with the mystery and the characters’ development and i’m going to miss their little group
although some of the characters felt a little off, i had so much fun with the mystery and the characters’ development and i’m going to miss their little group
Content Warnings
Graphic: Death, Kidnapping, and Murder
Moderate: Gun violence, Toxic relationship, Stalking, and Death of parent
Minor: Infidelity and Alcohol
sabrinaleaf's review against another edition
fast-paced
- Plot- or character-driven? Plot
- Strong character development? Yes
- Loveable characters? Yes
- Diverse cast of characters? No
- Flaws of characters a main focus? No
2.0
Another edition of useless sequels with non existent plots that could have been summed up in less then 100 pages.
Plot was all over the place. I think I outgrew this author.
Plot was all over the place. I think I outgrew this author.
Content Warnings
Graphic: Death and Murder
Minor: Gun violence
beckyyreadss's review against another edition
adventurous
dark
emotional
mysterious
tense
medium-paced
- Plot- or character-driven? A mix
- Strong character development? Yes
- Loveable characters? Yes
- Diverse cast of characters? Yes
- Flaws of characters a main focus? It's complicated
4.0
I wanted to read this book as I really enjoyed this series so far and was intrigued at which member was going to be back. This book was confusing at times, but I'm glad that it got the ending the guys deserved.
This book follows the gang from the last two books who are still in Bayview. Some of these characters are Addy, Nate, Phoebe, Maeve and Cooper. Ever since Simon died in detention, life hasn’t been easy for the Bayview Crew. First the Bayview Four had to prove they weren’t killers. Then a new generation had to outwit a vengeful copycat. Now, it’s happening all over again. At first the mysterious billboard seems like a bad joke: Time for a new game, Bayview. But when a member of the crew disappears, it’s clear this “game” just got serious, and no one knows the rules. Everyone is a target and now that someone unexpected has returned to Bayview, things are getting deadly again. The thing is, Simon was right about secrets – they all will come out, eventually. And Bayview has a lot it’s still hiding.
I love being back in Bayview and seeing how the crew was doing even if there was more stress for them during this book. I love that all my favourite couples are still strong and there was no petty breakups over the situation at hand. My favourite part in any mystery book is when the pieces of the puzzle starts to make sense and the killer is revealed. The chapter where the killer and the motive are revealed is written brilliant and the suspense is nail biting especially because Karen manages to drag it on from several points of view that you are waiting just for the answer and what had just happened. I love the friendships that are in this book and that they all stayed closed. My favourite character will always be Nate, I just wanted to hug him to death during this series as he has not had it easy.
The thing that stopped it from being five stars was Jake. That boy was such a pain in the ass, and I just wanted to punch him in the face. I was also a tad confused when I started this book because I read the second book in 2021 and I couldn’t remember what happened in the second book and some of the side plots from the characters weren’t in my brain, so I was just playing catch up. I would have loved a recap at the beginning of the book.
I would have liked an epilogue with all the crew being happy and successful and how Bayview was doing. Maybe that will be a book in the future, but I want Nate and Bronwyn to be parents, Maeve and Luis traveling, Cooper and Kris being happy and parents. Addy and Keely being happy and just everyone getting the hell out of Bayview.
Content Warnings
Graphic: Death, Kidnapping, and Murder
Moderate: Gun violence, Toxic relationship, and Death of parent
Minor: Addiction, Cancer, Drug use, and Alcohol
greatexpectations77's review against another edition
challenging
dark
mysterious
tense
medium-paced
- Plot- or character-driven? A mix
- Strong character development? Yes
- Loveable characters? It's complicated
- Diverse cast of characters? It's complicated
- Flaws of characters a main focus? Yes
4.0
I have been really liking this series, and I thought this installment was a particularly strong one. Families are so messy, and it's interesting to look at the effect of having the perfect family can have on your social capital.
Content Warnings
Graphic: Bullying, Child death, and Infidelity
Moderate: Confinement, Death, Gun violence, Toxic relationship, Kidnapping, Murder, Injury/Injury detail, and Classism
Minor: Blood, Grief, Death of parent, Pregnancy, Abandonment, and Alcohol
bo0ks_are_cool91's review against another edition
dark
tense
fast-paced
- Plot- or character-driven? Character
- Strong character development? Yes
- Loveable characters? Yes
- Diverse cast of characters? No
- Flaws of characters a main focus? Yes
3.75
Maybe my expectations were too high after reading the first 2 books, but one of us is back didn’t feel like a complete end to the trilogy for me. The mystery element didn’t start until the 2nd half of the book, and I wish the loose ends were wrapped up more conclusively. The characters are still⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️ though.
Content Warnings
Graphic: Death, Death of parent, and Murder
Moderate: Toxic relationship
Minor: Homophobia
dramagirl2003's review against another edition
dark
emotional
mysterious
tense
fast-paced
- Plot- or character-driven? Character
- Strong character development? Yes
- Loveable characters? Yes
- Diverse cast of characters? Yes
- Flaws of characters a main focus? It's complicated
5.0
it's so satisfying to finally read the conclusion of the trilogy. it was brilliantly executed, and i loved the revelation of unknown details from the time of the first book
thoughts while reading
p7: I bet it's flipping owen
p8: oh never mind, ofc it's jake
p10: *cough* murderer
p18: oh right, never mind. it's been a few months since i read one of us is next, and i clearly forgot the ending. poor owen, I was wrongly remembering him as a villain. also I forgot he was so young
p136: totally fair, I would also wanna punch that guy even at the risk of losing my job
p137: oh now I really would punch that arrogant smirk off his stupid frickin face
p144: IF THAT DEVIL SPAWN HAS DONE ANYTHING I'LL PLOT HIS MURDER WITH NATE
p148: stab the snow 🤣
p205: it really, really better not actually be owen this time. i'm gonna scream if it is
p210: mr alton is 100% the reason mrs riordan was so excited about work six years ago
p282:WHAT THE HECK EVIE YOU COW
p284: no but like i'm confused. does nate work at the construction site as well or just the bar? i mean they might have told us at the start of the book and i could've just forgotten
p288: no come on cause nate told phoebe he was at work until 3, but he's still at the bar at 7, so where's the consistency here??
wait, did he mean 3am?? ughh can we just have a little more clarity here
p292:GAVIN!! SHIT!! AND YOU JUST HANDED ADDY OVER TO HIM NATE!!
p297: I FREAKING KNEW IT!! OH SHOOT
p317:WHATTT JAKE IS ALTON'S SON???
p323: oh shoot, what now??
p327: dear gosh, he really was a murdering psyopath right from the start wasn't he
p331:shit she's totally gonna shoot jake before she leaves
p332: what did I say
p344: aw knox, my hearttt that was so cute
p347: AHHHH i forgot about that!! thank goodness for addy!
p351: stoppp 🥺 i'm actually about to start crying 😭
p356:it's a GIRL!!!
p8: oh never mind, ofc it's jake
p10: *cough* murderer
p18: oh right, never mind. it's been a few months since i read one of us is next, and i clearly forgot the ending. poor owen, I was wrongly remembering him as a villain. also I forgot he was so young
p136: totally fair, I would also wanna punch that guy even at the risk of losing my job
p137: oh now I really would punch that arrogant smirk off his stupid frickin face
p144: IF THAT DEVIL SPAWN HAS DONE ANYTHING I'LL PLOT HIS MURDER WITH NATE
p148: stab the snow 🤣
p205: it really, really better not actually be owen this time. i'm gonna scream if it is
p210: mr alton is 100% the reason mrs riordan was so excited about work six years ago
p282:
p284: no but like i'm confused. does nate work at the construction site as well or just the bar? i mean they might have told us at the start of the book and i could've just forgotten
p288: no come on cause nate told phoebe he was at work until 3, but he's still at the bar at 7, so where's the consistency here??
wait, did he mean 3am?? ughh can we just have a little more clarity here
p292:
p297: I FREAKING KNEW IT!! OH SHOOT
p317:
p323: oh shoot, what now??
p327: dear gosh, he really was a murdering psyopath right from the start wasn't he
p331:
p332: what did I say
p344: aw knox, my hearttt that was so cute
p347: AHHHH i forgot about that!! thank goodness for addy!
p351: stoppp 🥺 i'm actually about to start crying 😭
p356:
Content Warnings
Moderate: Cursing, Death, Blood, Kidnapping, Murder, and Injury/Injury detail
Minor: Gun violence, Toxic relationship, and Toxic friendship
kshurtz13's review against another edition
emotional
tense
fast-paced
- Plot- or character-driven? A mix
- Strong character development? Yes
- Loveable characters? Yes
- Diverse cast of characters? Yes
- Flaws of characters a main focus? Yes
4.0
Content Warnings
Graphic: Death, Kidnapping, and Murder