elentarien's review against another edition
This was a very interesting twist on the classic tail.
I enjoyed how it tied in with Hansel and Gretel. Though I was not pleased to see the same witch reappear - and then get her 'just deserts', only to disappear again. (As well, there is a 'promised' novel that has not appeared??) I did like how she was 'killed', through no one's fault. Much improved after Hansel's. . .bad call in the previous story. Not so thrilled that it didn't stick.
I enjoyed the 'brother/sister' team in this story, and the romance. For once, not an 'instalove' thing, as the romance had been going on for some time before the story started. Yes! Thank you. Finally! lol Not as 'romantic' as watching it develop, but I'll take it.
There was no explaination as to 'who' Verity was, and how the witch came to have her. Which quite annoyed me. This was somewhat acceptable when it was mentioned Verity gets her own book. However that book is not written? So it goes back to being some undealt with threads.
All in all, the biggest complaint about this book, like many of the others, the super RUSHED feeling of the story. THere is so much more that could have happened, so many more details and world-building we could have gotten. Even in the course of the story, everything happens in a matter of 2-3 days. In truth, it could have taken longer, had more 'adventure' along the way, more discoveries, more atmosphere. (Sights, sounds, smells, textures!) The whole thing felt so whirlwind that it was a disappointment.
I enjoyed how it tied in with Hansel and Gretel. Though I was not pleased to see the same witch reappear - and then get her 'just deserts', only to disappear again. (As well, there is a 'promised' novel that has not appeared??) I did like how she was 'killed', through no one's fault. Much improved after Hansel's. . .bad call in the previous story. Not so thrilled that it didn't stick.
I enjoyed the 'brother/sister' team in this story, and the romance. For once, not an 'instalove' thing, as the romance had been going on for some time before the story started. Yes! Thank you. Finally! lol Not as 'romantic' as watching it develop, but I'll take it.
There was no explaination as to 'who' Verity was, and how the witch came to have her. Which quite annoyed me. This was somewhat acceptable when it was mentioned Verity gets her own book. However that book is not written? So it goes back to being some undealt with threads.
All in all, the biggest complaint about this book, like many of the others, the super RUSHED feeling of the story. THere is so much more that could have happened, so many more details and world-building we could have gotten. Even in the course of the story, everything happens in a matter of 2-3 days. In truth, it could have taken longer, had more 'adventure' along the way, more discoveries, more atmosphere. (Sights, sounds, smells, textures!) The whole thing felt so whirlwind that it was a disappointment.
epic_novella's review
2.0
Jack and the Beanstalk by Jenni James is a retelling of the classic fairy tale, bringing a fresh perspective to the beloved story. With its imaginative twists and engaging storytelling, this adaptation offers an enjoyable reading experience, although it may lack some depth and originality.
The story follows the familiar tale of Jack, a young boy who trades his family's cow for magic beans that grow into a colossal beanstalk. He embarks on a thrilling adventure to a land in the clouds, where he encounters a giant and uncovers hidden treasures. James presents her own take on the story, adding unique elements and character dynamics that add intrigue and excitement.
One of the strengths of this retelling is James' ability to breathe new life into the classic story. She introduces additional layers to the narrative, providing fresh insights into the characters and their motivations. The world-building is vibrant and vivid, immersing readers in the enchanting realm above the clouds.
The writing style is accessible and flows well, making it suitable for readers of various ages. The pacing is generally well-maintained, with suspenseful moments and action-packed sequences keeping readers engaged throughout. James' attention to detail helps paint a vivid picture of the settings and enhances the overall reading experience.
However, despite these positive aspects, the book may not offer substantial depth or originality. Some readers familiar with the original tale may find the story predictable, as it largely adheres to the well-known plot points. The characters, while enjoyable, may lack significant development and complexity, and their actions can at times feel predictable.
Nevertheless, Jack and the Beanstalk remains an entertaining and accessible retelling that can captivate readers with its imaginative world and engaging storytelling. It offers a fresh perspective on a beloved story, making it a suitable choice for fans of fairy tales and those seeking an enjoyable, light-hearted read.
The story follows the familiar tale of Jack, a young boy who trades his family's cow for magic beans that grow into a colossal beanstalk. He embarks on a thrilling adventure to a land in the clouds, where he encounters a giant and uncovers hidden treasures. James presents her own take on the story, adding unique elements and character dynamics that add intrigue and excitement.
One of the strengths of this retelling is James' ability to breathe new life into the classic story. She introduces additional layers to the narrative, providing fresh insights into the characters and their motivations. The world-building is vibrant and vivid, immersing readers in the enchanting realm above the clouds.
The writing style is accessible and flows well, making it suitable for readers of various ages. The pacing is generally well-maintained, with suspenseful moments and action-packed sequences keeping readers engaged throughout. James' attention to detail helps paint a vivid picture of the settings and enhances the overall reading experience.
However, despite these positive aspects, the book may not offer substantial depth or originality. Some readers familiar with the original tale may find the story predictable, as it largely adheres to the well-known plot points. The characters, while enjoyable, may lack significant development and complexity, and their actions can at times feel predictable.
Nevertheless, Jack and the Beanstalk remains an entertaining and accessible retelling that can captivate readers with its imaginative world and engaging storytelling. It offers a fresh perspective on a beloved story, making it a suitable choice for fans of fairy tales and those seeking an enjoyable, light-hearted read.
12_34's review
adventurous
lighthearted
fast-paced
- Plot- or character-driven? Plot
- Strong character development? No
- Loveable characters? It's complicated
- Diverse cast of characters? No
- Flaws of characters a main focus? No
3.0
ajrdesire's review against another edition
adventurous
lighthearted
fast-paced
- Plot- or character-driven? A mix
- Strong character development? Yes
- Loveable characters? Yes
- Diverse cast of characters? No
- Flaws of characters a main focus? No
4.5
lenni_loves_literature's review against another edition
4.0
This book was great, not the best, but great. I liked that Jack had to save Rachel from a giant. I also liked how it combined Jack and the Beanstalk, Hansel and Gretel, and Jack and Jill. That was pretty cool. I AM a little disappointed that the author hasn't written Princess of the Golden Touch or whatever like she said she would.
More...