righteousridel's review against another edition
2.0
Incarnation is a weak follow-up in the Horusian Wars series. It's possible to read this novel without reading the former -- there are perhaps two or three subplots that carried over but hardly any of the details matter. That is my greatest complaint about Incarnation - one expects the build-up to be complete, and we launch into a complex web of story threads that will climax in the third novel. You... don't really get that in this novel.
As well, Incarnation exaggerates the flaws of its predecessor: the story arc is really too small scale to be considered 'Horusian Wars'. The plot itself is very short -- honestly the book is just about the events of a single day. Somehow we are introduced to two chapters worth of new characters before picking up the plot from Resurrection, so again the novel starts off on a rocky footing.
Where it really goes wrong is that the intricate politicking and complex Imperium machinations of the former book is lost. Instead, we get Inquisitor lands to save a planet, fighting occurs, the end.
What a disappointment.
As well, Incarnation exaggerates the flaws of its predecessor: the story arc is really too small scale to be considered 'Horusian Wars'. The plot itself is very short -- honestly the book is just about the events of a single day. Somehow we are introduced to two chapters worth of new characters before picking up the plot from Resurrection, so again the novel starts off on a rocky footing.
Where it really goes wrong is that the intricate politicking and complex Imperium machinations of the former book is lost. Instead, we get Inquisitor lands to save a planet, fighting occurs, the end.
What a disappointment.
Spoiler
Specifically, the key plot-twist of Enna, and the Triumvirate, is barely relevant to the main plot. The battle in the Monastery just happens without any justification to how Chaos took hold so quickly, and Inquisitor Covenant is along for the ride. The more interesting characters of Sister Agata and Khoriv are sidelined in subplot where they wander away from the battle and find out the key villain died on his own. Like... what? It feels like the author spent most of his effort on the shipboard plot, and while Viola continues to please, I'm here for the Inquisition and not Rogue Traders. The last half of the novel is bolter porn and Covenant barely has "screen time". Sigh.trackofwords's review
5.0
The second instalment of John French’s brilliant The Horusian Wars series, Incarnation follows on pretty directly from Resurrection to continue the story of Inquisitor Covenant and his pursuit of the shadowy cabal known as the Triumvirate. Guided by the Imperial Tarot, Covenant and his warband journey to the shrine world of Dominicus Prime where, amidst the secrets and machinations of the sprawling Monastery of the Last Candle, a terrifying power is about to manifest.
It’s as pacy as you’d expect from Black Library, with inventive (and often just really cool) action scenes aplenty, but the real implications of what’s going on are only slowly revealed and require some thought to properly process. Put the effort in, however, and you’ll be rewarded with another fascinating story that builds on what’s gone before, raising the stakes and delivering a powerful example of what the 40k universe really has to offer.
Read the full review at https://www.trackofwords.com/2018/07/23/the-horusian-wars-incarnation-john-french/
It’s as pacy as you’d expect from Black Library, with inventive (and often just really cool) action scenes aplenty, but the real implications of what’s going on are only slowly revealed and require some thought to properly process. Put the effort in, however, and you’ll be rewarded with another fascinating story that builds on what’s gone before, raising the stakes and delivering a powerful example of what the 40k universe really has to offer.
Read the full review at https://www.trackofwords.com/2018/07/23/the-horusian-wars-incarnation-john-french/
nooker's review
2.0
I have no idea what happened in this book. It flipped from group to group to group that I had no idea who was doing what when and where. All I can think is that if I had a gaming group this fragmented I would shoot myself.
manthespace's review
dark
mysterious
slow-paced
- Plot- or character-driven? A mix
- Strong character development? No
- Loveable characters? No
- Diverse cast of characters? No
- Flaws of characters a main focus? Yes
2.25
More...