Reviews

The Cavalier in White by Marcia Muller

nocto's review

3.0

Oh it's fun picking up an author you love but haven't read much of for ages. I devoured all the Sharon McCone stories years ago and also read the three Elena Oliverez books but I only read one of the Joanna Stark mysteries. The one I read was the third of three and I didn't much enjoy it at the time. This is the first of those stories and it's not as good as a McCone and there are bits of the San Francisco/stolen painting plot that I find a bit weak but I did really enjoy curling up with the book and whizzing through it and meeting a new character of Muller's.

My plan is to get hold of the second book in the series and then reread Dark Star to see what I think second time around. I think these books might make more sense as a trilogy than as one offs.

bev_reads_mysteries's review against another edition

3.0

The Cavalier in White is the first book in a trilogy by Marcia Muller (1986). The short series features art security expert Joanna Stark and revolves around her efforts to track down Anthony Parducci, a brilliant art thief who has managed to elude the authorities for years. In Cavalier, Joanna is brought out of retirement--a self-imposed seclusion really--by her partner when the eponymous work of art, a painting by Frans Hals, is stolen from a San Francisco gallery. A gallery that was wired for security by their company. And the son of her long-time friends, the Wheatleys, is trying to cut a deal with the insurance company for the safe return of the painting. A security guard from the gallery, a man who also has connections to the Wheatleys, disappears and the investigators have to wonder if he's involved. Joanna spots clues that make her think Parducci might be involved--but why is he interested in a group of people who might possibly have an adopted son? And why did Mike Wheatley (the aforementioned son) give Parducci the address of Joanna's apartment? She will have to find all the missing links before she will retrieve the painting--but not before murder is done and she is forced to confront her past.

This was a strong opening to the series. Joanna has some issues that she needs to work through and it was enjoyable watching her on that journey. The mystery elements were fairly played and fairly intriguing. While it is fairly obvious fairly early that some of Joanna's suspicions about the the theft are correct, there is a surprise in store that gives the wrap-up a good twist. It was, however, frustrating to watch Joanna repeatedly get herself into a situation that she knows she shouldn't be in, then get out of it, and turn around in time to plunge into another one. It wouldn't be quite so bad if she did it without thinking. But she tells us that she knows she shouldn't and then does it anyway. It was interesting to see her make some progress with her issues by the end of the story. But it is obvious she has a long way to go. Good solid beginning.

First posted on my blog My Reader's Block. Please request permission before reposting. Thanks.

bookwrm526's review

dark emotional mysterious slow-paced

• Plot- or character-driven? A mix
• Strong character development? Yes
• Diverse cast of characters? No
• Flaws of characters a main focus? It's complicated

3.0