Reviews

You and Who Else, by Steve Herbert, Grant Bull, James Turner, Alwyn Ash, Nicholas Blake, Keith Topping, Guy Lambert, John Rivers, Rachel Redhead, Annie Worrall, Michael Russell, Rob Irwin, Warren Frey, Will Ingram, Mark Blayney, Simon Kemp, Ben Adams, Simon A. Brett, Ian Millstead, Tilla Crowne, Phil Ford, Paul Driscoll, Jemima Williams, Dean Hempstead, Rob Peasley, Stephen Dowell, Steve Roberts, Barry Collins, David Guest, Robert Day-Webb, Stephen Candy, Simon Hart, Jenny Shirt, Ian Farrington, Stuart Douglas, Steve Heywood, Paul Castle, Kate Fathers, Matt Barber, Dave O’Brien, Kevin Jordan, Drew Walko, Felix Dembinski, Alan Hayes, Ian Dickerson, Tim Gambrell, Beth Ward, Tony Green, Jef Hughes, Paul Watts, Anthony Brown, Nick Mellish, Andrew Hampel, Fred McNamara, Richie J. Haworth, Michael S. Collins, Nicholas Hollands, Jon Arnold, Robert Morrison, Lee Rawlings, Anthony Burdge, Ken Shinn, Colin Hicks, Nick Campbell, Nicola Baker, Paul Mount, Cliff Chapman, Angela Pritchett, Ben Jones, Lukas Scott, Jessica Fynboh, Matthew West, Ian Wheeler, Michael Seely, Nicola Johnson, Sue Cowley, Al No, Martin Gardner, Carolyn Arnold, Susan Bowden, Tom Henry, Karon Hollis, Andrew Blair, Martin Adams, Roisin Murray, Jon Witchell, Martha Oster, Paul Holmes, Dylan Rees, James Gent, Andrew Orton, Matthew Kresal, Caleb Schadeck, Earl Ecklund III, Dan Barratt, Chris Orton, Jeff Waddell, Samantha Warner, Jon Masters, Stephen Hatcher, Jessica Burke, Peter Nolan, Paul Vanezis, John Davies, Martin Ruddock, Alun Harris, J.R. Southall, John Feetenby, Mike Morgan, Mark Trevor Owen, Tony Jones, Miles Northcott, Greg Bakun, Nick Griffiths, Barnaby Eaton-Jones, Tony Cross, Daniel Greensmith, Dick Fiddy, Drew Meyer, Alister Davison, Christopher Bryant, Jackie Emery, Ed Fortune, Sean Alexander, George Ivanoff, Sami Kelsh, Gary Russell, Phil Cannon, Scott Varnham, Jim Cameron, Robert Hammond, Steve O’Brien, Cory Eadson, David Hughes, Georgia White, Simon Thorpe, Ian Ham, Richard Marson, Brendan Jones, Charles Bain, Tom Marshall, Maximillian Curtis, Debbie Antlitz, Suky Khakh, David Geldard, David A. Thomas, Kevin Jon Davies, Andrew Curnow, John Dorney, Christine Grit, Lucy Hyndman, Kara Dennison, David Cromarty, Pete Dillon-Trenchard, Simon Jailler, Alistair McGown, Richard McGinley

mike_baker's review

Go to review page

4.0

This was great. A bunch of Doctor Who fans got together and contributed essays about other 'cult' British TV shows, from the dawn of television to now. Much of it made me feel pangs of nostalgia, especially the chapters covering programmes I watched as a child and have semi-forgotten, gems like Sapphire and Steel, The Tripods, The Moondial. While reading this I dusted off my DVD set of the old Quatermass series (from the 1950s) and I've started rewatching Edge of Darkness also.

Of course, the pieces do much more than simply review old shows; they're often about the writers, recollections of their own formative years, the sorts of childhood rituals that too many times had me nodding in agreement. I was one of them - bookish, a loner, glued to the box at the times when kids TV was scheduled - very different from the current era of 24 hour services; back then you got a slot at lunchtime and a further block before the 'news hour' at six. That was it. TV carefully apportioned and rationed prior to the evening primetime viewing of game shows, sitcoms and soaps.

I love the recurring theme of cheapness when it comes to talking about the shows. You could tell pretty instantly whether something was British or American because the latter tended to be fairly lavish in comparison. These days, a show like Doctor Who comes with good production values, but it wasn't like that then, a time of spray-painted Fairy Liquid bottles and long scenes that involved characters talking because it didn't cost very much to film. Blake's Seven, a show I was probably too young for but I recall watching, was famous for its poverty row special effects, the shots of spaceships sliding across the heavens so poorly realised you almost wish they hadn't bothered in the first place. I was once told by my Dad that the reason so much of Dangermouse took place in the Arctic was that all-white backgrounds were cheap. That didn't stop me from loving it - DM and Penfold ("oooooh crumbs!") was catnip.

Then there was The Tripods, made at a time when Michael Grade was in control of the BBC and looking for alternatives to the good Doctor's adventures. The shots of the 'Pods themselves were rubbish, and you imagine the producers rubbing their hands with glee over the pastoral setting because it didn't involve expensive set-ups. The worst thing about The Tripods, of course, was that it was cancelled after two series - as usual, just as it was getting good and before the story could be wrapped up by adapting the third and final book in the series.

Ah, memories. After finishing the book, I was tempted to go straight onto Amazon and order box sets of Tales of the Unexpected (that music! That naked dancing lady!), Space:1999 and Star Cops. I've already been over to YouTube for clips from The Adventure Game (Drogna!) because that was a great show. Even reading about its cut-price production can't ruin what was a cracking half hour of telly, which was on just before the Sherlock Holmes movie....
More...