taaya's review against another edition
4.0
Nach ersten Ärgernissen und trotz kleiner Schwächen erstaunlich gut und unterhaltsam geschrieben, mit sympathischen neuen Charakteren.
birdmanseven's review
1.0
None of this worked for me. Too much focus on original/minor characters, Kirk's choices feel out of character, and the plot was never compelling to me.
bdplume's review
3.0
I would have rated this higher, because it was very enjoyable and a great example of the spirit of Star Trek. However, there were a few plot contrivances I just didn’t care for. I would have to add a spoiler tag to go into more detail. I’ll say that those choices may work very well for others but didn’t resonate with me.
More...