Reviews

Precious Thing by Collette McBeth

carrieemoran's review against another edition

Go to review page

4.0

This was an absorbing read that kept me wanting to read late into the night. The writing style is unique and engaging. The story picked up speed quickly and had lots of twists, although the end seemed muddled. It definitely stuck with me for days after. This is definitely a great choice for thriller fans.

kristinmagoo's review against another edition

Go to review page

2.0

I have no beef with the writing, but I am having a moment where I have no interest in psychological thrillers. And I'm not enjoying reading any stories that take place in high school.

coldlikeadqblizzard's review against another edition

Go to review page

5.0

!!!!!! oooh, so twisted! I loved it.

firefly8041's review against another edition

Go to review page

3.0

2.5

lizzyqd's review against another edition

Go to review page

dark mysterious tense medium-paced
  • Plot- or character-driven? A mix
  • Strong character development? No
  • Loveable characters? No
  • Diverse cast of characters? No
  • Flaws of characters a main focus? It's complicated

3.5

booagnes's review against another edition

Go to review page

3.0

When we first meet Megan Bright, she has just been admitted into the hospital to begin her chemotherapy treatments for the tumor in her head. Upon her arrival, she runs into the only other teenager in the children's ward, Jackson Dawes. He's all energy and smiles, which annoys the very angry, bitter Megan. She doesn't need a new friend and she certainly doesn't need this boy to bother her. Little does she know that this seemingly annoying boy will become her salvation. Jackson is exactly the person to help her through this most trying of times.

As I said above, Megan is less than pleasant when we first meet her. Off the bat, I wasn't quite sure what to think of Megan. I get that she's angry and annoyed to be in the hospital at all, let alone in the "baby" ward. It can't be easy, but still. I could tell that her mother was trying her best to make Megan feel comfortable in her hospital room, but Megan just wouldn't stop being sullen long enough to notice it. As with many teenagers, she's very much involved in her own problems and doesn't think about how others are affected. Then Jackson comes and literally runs into her, which doesn't improve Megan's mood, but certainly lights up the pages for the reader. Though she is quite moody in the beginning, Jackson is able to help turn Megan around. She really becomes a much more mature, likable and optimistic person by the end.

From the second he bumps into Megan, drip stand in hand, I loved Jackson. He is definitely the shining beacon in this novel. I just really like how full of life he is! Jackson has a super rare form of cancer, one that doesn't even have a name yet, but he's infectiously happy. Regardless of how much he's suffering, he makes it a point to laugh, be friendly, have adventures and make the most out of every moment he has. His personality is contagious, especially when he's trying to help the little ones feel better. He's so wise and gentle with the other children in the ward. He takes time to tell stories and make them laugh with silly faces, jokes and mischievous hijinks. This in turn helps the children forget, if just for a second, about the "bad cells" attacking their body and have some pure joy. As you may be able to tell, I really enjoyed this character. We don't get to find out much about his background, but he's still a gem. I'm glad Megan eventually comes around to his charm, too. Jackson really brings out the best in Megan and all those around him, making him the star of the book, in my opinion.

There were a few other characters that I liked, as well. I was really quite fond of Sister Brewster and Siobhan, who both work with the children in the cancer ward. Celia, the author, really did a great job in depicting these caring adults. You could tell they really love these kids and their job, though it can definitely be difficult and heartbreaking. I was also very fond of Megan's Grandad. He is so adorable! We don't get to "officially" meet him, as his only interactions with Megan are on the phone, but you could tell they have a really tight relationship. He's in his mid-90's, quirky, funny and completely dotes upon his granddaughter. I wish we could have seen more of him and his relationship with Megan. I have a feeling he would have gotten along with Jackson very well indeed. On the ward, there's also a little girl about 6 years old named Kipper. Kipper is a little princess and Megan even says she looks like an angel with her shiny, bald head, big eyes and sparkly pink outfits. As is to be expected when a little one has an illness such as cancer, Kipper isn't always well-behaved. She throws fits and gets emotional, but she really is the cutest little thing. Kipper really broke my heart, I felt so much for her.
SpoilerI can only imagine how hard it must be for her and her mother to go through this. It made me sad when she passed away, but I feel like it was almost an afterthought. I was kind of like, "Oh, by the way, Kipper died. The end." Except for some from Jackson, there really wasn't any emotional reaction to this little child's death. I think that could have been handled better.
Such a tiny little child with such a huge thing happening to her.

Though I liked quite a few of the characters, I wish they would have been more fleshed out. It seemed to me that the only character able to shine through the page was Jackson; which I guess is fitting, since the book title has his name in it and all. I didn't like that sometimes the story would jump around, almost like it ran off on a tangent and forgot to take the reader with it. This made it quite difficult to figure out what happened in the in-between time, which then made it hard to have a better connection to the story. I also didn't really like how Megan falls for Jackson all of a sudden. She was continuously annoyed by him and then, in the blink of an eye, she can't stand to be away from him. It just didn't seem realistic for her to fall so hard for him out of nowhere. I would have liked to read about how her feelings grew from annoyance to friendship to first love, you know?

SpoilerI was really hoping Jackson would live, but I kind of guessed he wouldn't. Especially when he told Megan his form of cancer was so rare they hadn't even named it yet. Then he came back to the hospital all sad and withdrawn. He wouldn't really tell Megan what was going on and only came around with some coaxing from Megan. Then he just kind of disappears from the story and Megan is suddenly home from the hospital after her surgery? What? She didn't even try to contact Jackson in any way, which I thought was very unrealistic. This is another situation I think could have been expanded on and made much better. I mean, Jackson is a main character! I would have liked to see more.


Celia Bryce has written about cancer - and the children and families who suffer through it all - in such a brilliant and honest way, which shows some real talent and heart. It was really difficult, but interesting, to hear about all the trials and experiences these kids have to go through. I mean, there were babies on the ward. Babies. That's just so sad and not right. Celia has handled this subject with such grace and tenderness. She shows that though there is a lot of pain and sadness associated with cancer and those who have it, but there is hope and joy to be found as well.

I would definitely recommend this moving novel to readers of both young adult and middle-grade fiction. The content is clean, and the protagonist young enough (she's 13), that many readers will be able to enjoy it. Overall, I think Anthem for Jackson Dawes is a touching story that will stick with you long after you read it.

A favorite quote: “Megan watched as everything about her, everything that said who she was, slid down her shoulders and cascaded to the floor, like leaves shaken from a dying tree.”

*This is a review of an ARC copy provided by the Book Depository Affiliate Review Program in exchange for an honest review. This review first appeared on my blog, She Dreams in Fiction.

bear_reads_books's review against another edition

Go to review page

5.0

I really liked this book. It keeps you wondering right up until the end, not sure who the real 'villain' is. I kept going back and forth, questioning Rachel and feeling sorry for her. In the end, I wasn't so conflicted, I'll just leave it at that! Great debut, I'll definitely read more from this author!

michalice's review against another edition

Go to review page

5.0

Just from the synopsis alone I knew before starting Anthem for Jackson Dawes that it would be an emotional book, and I purposely left it till I was off work for Christmas, knowing I would not be able to read it in work without sobbing my heart out.  I just never realised how much of an emotional roller coaster ride it would be.

The protagonist, Megan, was easy to like and believable in my eyes.  The feelings of loss and sadness that she portrays made me feel like it was myself being left in hospital without an family.  While her first impression, and her second and third, of Jackson weren't good, they soon become firm friends and I enjoyed getting to see this duo interact with each other  especially as they spend more time together.  From the get go I loved Jackson.  He is honest about what happens, especially regarding friends, and isn't afraid to tell Megan the truth, rather than let her believe in the promises of friends, and that was one quality I instantly liked about him.  He cares for the younger patients and is like a big brother bear to them.  Cancer isn't a nice thing, either to the family or to the person who is dealing with it, but Jackson is so up beat and has a good attitude about it all that others around him can't help but be drawn into his cheerfulness.  He makes the hospital a  nicer place for others, whether its good or bad for himself.

I don't want to say too much about Anthem for Jackson Dawes, as it's one you need to read yourself.  One part that I thought was a very poignant moment involved Megan and Jackson, and I am glad that he was there to support and help Megan thought this moment, being the voice of reason, telling her how it is, but also being a shoulder for her to cry on.  I was an absolute wreck after reading this bit, but rather than stopping and putting the book on hold I carried on reading, knowing that either way I would still cry.

Megan watched as everything about her, everything that said who she was, slid down her shoulders and cascaded to the floor, like leaves shaken from a dying tree.
[Page 125 UK proof]


Celia Bryce gets to your emotions, hitting all the right places to make you fall in love with each character, laugh at their humour and cry at their sadness. The fear and worry over treatments and operations feels like it is you sitting there with them.  Anthem for Jackson Dawes is a book that will stay in my memory for a long time, it deals with cancer in a truthful and realistic way, and while I personally do not know what if feels like to go through it myself, I have seen the after effects and they are portrayed perfectly, but compassionately by Celia.
I am lost for words with what else to say about Anthem for Jackson Dawes, I am writing this after just finishing reading, while I comfort myself with chocolate and I can't get over how powerful his book is.

Anthem for Jackson Dawes is a must read for anyone.

judithdcollins's review against another edition

Go to review page

3.0

Review to follow!

kdurham2's review against another edition

Go to review page

3.0

Check out the full review at Kritters Ramblings

An eery book from the beginning with one girl missing and her friend thrust in the middle of it as a news anchor. The way the author unfolded this story bit by bit and putting stories from the past interspersed was fantastic! With each chapter done, I wanted to know more and more - made it hard to put down.

One of the fantastic things about this book was that the author wrote from Rachel's perspective, but not only that, but she wrote it as if the character was talking to her missing friend - added an extra eery layer! The reader finds out at the very end as to why the book was formatted this way and I loved it. It made for a different kind of reading.