Scan barcode
quisiyyah's review
funny
hopeful
lighthearted
fast-paced
- Plot- or character-driven? N/A
- Strong character development? N/A
- Loveable characters? Yes
- Diverse cast of characters? Yes
- Flaws of characters a main focus? No
5.0
dreamsandprose's review against another edition
4.0
this is so ridiculously stupid that is hilarious
alec is one desperate ex and izzie is totally unhinged and a badasss
Merged review:
this is so ridiculously stupid that is hilarious
alec is one desperate ex and izzie is totally unhinged and a badasss
alec is one desperate ex and izzie is totally unhinged and a badasss
Merged review:
this is so ridiculously stupid that is hilarious
alec is one desperate ex and izzie is totally unhinged and a badasss
mehsi's review against another edition
3.0
A short novella featuring various voicemails from various characters. Including a ton from a certain boy who got dumped by Magnus and who is, along with his sister, trying to get Magnus to notice him and take him back. Along the way we also read other voicemails. And then at the end there is something else. It was quite fun to read. Sure, I still needed to read Bane Chronicles 4 to 10, but I already knew that Magnus and Alec would end up in one way or another.
Merged review:
A short novella featuring various voicemails from various characters. Including a ton from a certain boy who got dumped by Magnus and who is, along with his sister, trying to get Magnus to notice him and take him back. Along the way we also read other voicemails. And then at the end there is something else. It was quite fun to read. Sure, I still needed to read Bane Chronicles 4 to 10, but I already knew that Magnus and Alec would end up in one way or another.
Merged review:
A short novella featuring various voicemails from various characters. Including a ton from a certain boy who got dumped by Magnus and who is, along with his sister, trying to get Magnus to notice him and take him back. Along the way we also read other voicemails. And then at the end there is something else. It was quite fun to read. Sure, I still needed to read Bane Chronicles 4 to 10, but I already knew that Magnus and Alec would end up in one way or another.
sharonsm_28's review against another edition
5.0
Actual Rating: 4.5
This was hilarious. The voicemails were awesome. Izzy was calling Magnus like every few hours. I loved how everyone especially Jace, Izzy, Clary, and Simon were trying to convince Magnus to contact Alec. I think I lowered the rating because Malec had broken up. I did laugh when I read the part of how he broke his cell phone. Overall, an amazing read.
Merged review:
Actual Rating: 4.5
This was hilarious. The voicemails were awesome. Izzy was calling Magnus like every few hours. I loved how everyone especially Jace, Izzy, Clary, and Simon were trying to convince Magnus to contact Alec. I think I lowered the rating because Malec had broken up. I did laugh when I read the part of how he broke his cell phone. Overall, an amazing read.
This was hilarious. The voicemails were awesome. Izzy was calling Magnus like every few hours. I loved how everyone especially Jace, Izzy, Clary, and Simon were trying to convince Magnus to contact Alec. I think I lowered the rating because Malec had broken up. I did laugh when I read the part of how he broke his cell phone. Overall, an amazing read.
Merged review:
Actual Rating: 4.5
This was hilarious. The voicemails were awesome. Izzy was calling Magnus like every few hours. I loved how everyone especially Jace, Izzy, Clary, and Simon were trying to convince Magnus to contact Alec. I think I lowered the rating because Malec had broken up. I did laugh when I read the part of how he broke his cell phone. Overall, an amazing read.
emmy_xx's review against another edition
4.0
BROKE MY POOR LIL HEART -and I'm not even sure after which events was this (only watched the TV show sooooo) -!!!
But was good like that's how I would reacte if my bro was going through a break up I'm soo Izzy on this
Merged review:
BROKE MY POOR LIL HEART -and I'm not even sure after which events was this (only watched the TV show sooooo) -!!!
But was good like that's how I would reacte if my bro was going through a break up I'm soo Izzy on this
But was good like that's how I would reacte if my bro was going through a break up I'm soo Izzy on this
Merged review:
BROKE MY POOR LIL HEART -and I'm not even sure after which events was this (only watched the TV show sooooo) -!!!
But was good like that's how I would reacte if my bro was going through a break up I'm soo Izzy on this
faithtrustpixiedust's review against another edition
2.0
for some reason, my review of this disappeared lol but if I recall correctly, it was something like this:
Entirely irrelevant and boring. Doesn't add anything to the characters or overall narrative.
Entirely irrelevant and boring. Doesn't add anything to the characters or overall narrative.
cyrille6k's review
4.0
I don't typically read many novellas, but this Shadowhunter series is fantastic! It deepens the Shadowhunter world, answers lingering questions from City of Heavenly Fire, and explores Magnus Bane's intriguing past and present. Fans will love the rich backstory and character development.