Scan barcode
amsearer's review against another edition
4.0
I'm only taking a star off because I want to know more. More anecdotes. More detailed history. Whatever, just...more. This was a lovely, concise, interesting audiobook.
alexanedesbiens's review against another edition
emotional
informative
reflective
medium-paced
4.5
Immersing myself in the pages of Agnès Poirier's "Notre-Dame: The Soul of France" was an impassioned journey through the heart and soul of one of the most iconic symbols of France, which I thouroughly enjoyed.
From the gripping portrayal of the 2019 fire that engulfed the Parisian cathedral to the valiant efforts of firefighters and the custodians of its treasures, every word pulsated with the intensity of a nation grappling with its heritage in the face of tragedy.
From the gripping portrayal of the 2019 fire that engulfed the Parisian cathedral to the valiant efforts of firefighters and the custodians of its treasures, every word pulsated with the intensity of a nation grappling with its heritage in the face of tragedy.
Poirier masterfully weaves a tapestry of Notre-Dame's history, taking us on a captivating voyage from its origins to the tumultuous era of the French Revolution. The meticulous detailing of Viollet-Le Duc's 19th-century renovations adds an extra layer of historical richness, underscoring the unyielding spirit of preservation that has defined the cathedral over centuries.
Yet, it is the author's exploration of Notre-Dame's profound significance to the French people that elevates this work beyond a simple historical account. The intricate interplay between the cathedral, the city of Paris, and the intertwined threads of religion and secularism is expertly unraveled. Poirier's thought-provoking questions about the reconstruction process and the funding sources delve deep into the very soul of Notre-Dame, compelling readers to reflect on the values that underpin the resurrection of such cultural treasures.
A striking element that resonated with me was Poirier's artful personification of Notre-Dame, transforming the cathedral into a dynamic and influential entity. This literary device not only mirrors the evocative style of Victor Hugo but also infuses the narrative with a profound sense of connection, making Notre-Dame not merely a structure but a living, breathing symbol of resilience.
In the broader context of cathedral literature, Poirier's work finds a harmonious companion in Ken Follett's "Notre-Dame: A Short History of the Meaning of Cathedrals." Together, they enrich the reader's understanding of the cultural and historical tapestry woven by Notre-Dame and the French nation.
In conclusion, "Notre-Dame: The Soul of France" is a heartfelt tribute to resilience, heritage, and the enduring spirit of a nation. A highly enjoyable and informative read, it leaves an indelible mark on the soul, echoing the timeless beauty and significance of Notre-Dame itself.
Content Warnings
Graphic: Fire/Fire injury
nikkivrc's review against another edition
4.0
4 maanden heeft het geduurd om dit boek van een goede 200 pagina's te lezen. Ik weet niet waarom, maar ik vermoed dat het iets te maken heeft met hoe belangrijk de Notre Dame voor mij is. Ja, ik was één van die mensen die aan het blèten waren als een kind toen ze in brand stond. Ook tijdens het lezen van dit boek hebben de tranen mij meermaals in de ogen gestaan. Poirier duidt met haar historisch overzicht van de kathedraal ook waarom de brand zoveel mensen zo hard heeft geraakt. Geen vijf sterren waard, omdat ik wel erg de indruk had dat dit boek snel-snel werd geschreven. Soms blijft Poirier te hard steken bij droge feiten en mist het boek wat diepgang.
kikiandarrowsfishshelf's review against another edition
5.0
Disclaimer: ARC via Netgalley
Early in her book about Notre-Dame de Paris, Poirer writes, “We need certainties: they are the framework of our existence, the signposts without which we can’t navigate life, let alone endure its many tests and trials; for 850 years Notre-Dame was one such “ (location 36).
Poirer is right. Many people over the world were affected by the fire that ravaged Notre-Dame. I was surprised by how much a sense of loss I felt when I saw the news. Poirier’s book is a history of the cathedral, a general one but an engrossing and extremely readable one. Her love for the book is on every single page.
Poirer starts with an account of the fire, bringing into the light, some details that might not be known to the causal reader of the event. Her details of not only the rescue of the Cathedral itself but also of the art works. She then moves into a history of the Cathedral showing that the fire was not the only near destruction that the building faced.
While the book is general, something that is easily discerned from its length, there are interesting tidbits and facts – like the first royal buried there, what happened to the lead coffins, how the art survived the revolution and so on.
In many ways, it is like reading the monolog of an excellent tour guide.
More...