Scan barcode
kerrycat's review
5.0
each new book of DeStefano's is better than the last, and this is no exception. above all else, there's a lot of beautiful writing here - and quite the body count.
I think I've read all of her YA books, and I've reviewed some of her middle grade work for School Library Journal, and it's safe to say that grief is central to them all. she isn't afraid to lay out the truth of it, either - there's none of that 'time heals' business going on, just the facts. the reality of the ferocity grief bears, the unpredictability, the hopelessness, as well as characters who find their way through it, but not without a fight, and not with the idea that it is gone completely. I think I appreciate this more than anything else in her stories, and what young readers as well as older ones need to see to validate their own experience.
I think I've read all of her YA books, and I've reviewed some of her middle grade work for School Library Journal, and it's safe to say that grief is central to them all. she isn't afraid to lay out the truth of it, either - there's none of that 'time heals' business going on, just the facts. the reality of the ferocity grief bears, the unpredictability, the hopelessness, as well as characters who find their way through it, but not without a fight, and not with the idea that it is gone completely. I think I appreciate this more than anything else in her stories, and what young readers as well as older ones need to see to validate their own experience.
taygus's review against another edition
2.0
Poor pacing and ai felt the plot was undeveloped in some places and pushed far too fast in others.
and the marvelor magic is very much unpredictable plot armor.
This auther does alot of telling not showing. She tells you what the characters are like, but she doesn't show it through their behaviour.
And I'm seriously frustrated with Wil, who's supposed to be trained and used to danger and what not.||.always needing to be rescued..not once did she save herself..she didn't show herself to be strong and fearless especially in this book,|| tho the author repetitively tells us its so.
I did enjoy the friendship and connection between Loom and Zey in this series tho.
and the marvelor magic is very much unpredictable plot armor.
This auther does alot of telling not showing. She tells you what the characters are like, but she doesn't show it through their behaviour.
And I'm seriously frustrated with Wil, who's supposed to be trained and used to danger and what not.||.always needing to be rescued..not once did she save herself..she didn't show herself to be strong and fearless especially in this book,|| tho the author repetitively tells us its so.
I did enjoy the friendship and connection between Loom and Zey in this series tho.
firefly8041's review against another edition
3.0
According to my review of the first, I enjoyed it a fair bit. So I reread it when I saw this one was out, and didn't like it as much. This one I liked even less. There was nothing exactly wrong with it, it was just...a standard 3 star book.
thedarkfields's review against another edition
1.0
The term "anticlimactic" is insufficient to describe the resolutions offered by this book.
hood_ia's review against another edition
5.0
This book is so underrated but soooo good. I really enjoyed it. It made me cry many times but I’m fine
elodieblt99's review against another edition
3.0
Honestly, once again, not the best novel ever, but quite fun to read! the second book was way better than the first book, lots of plottwists, lots of change in storyline. Although the pacing sometimes was questionable, i liked that it went fast, wasnt lingering too much.
I would recommend this series to anyone who’s in a reading slump; easy read.
I would recommend this series to anyone who’s in a reading slump; easy read.
einstein7931's review against another edition
adventurous
challenging
emotional
hopeful
reflective
sad
tense
medium-paced
- Plot- or character-driven? A mix
- Strong character development? Yes
- Loveable characters? Yes
- Diverse cast of characters? Yes
- Flaws of characters a main focus? Yes
4.25