lovelyowlsbooks's review against another edition
5.0
Going into this I knew it was a loose Middle-Grade Little Women re-imagining. I'm actually not that familiar with Little Women apart from the vague plot so, I was going into this almost blind and as if this was a brand new story.
I ended up really enjoying it and sympathizing with the characters. I'd previously read [b:Amina's Voice|30312547|Amina's Voice|Hena Khan|https://i.gr-assets.com/images/S/compressed.photo.goodreads.com/books/1478818044l/30312547._SY75_.jpg|50799344] and while I did give it 4 stars, I didn't feel that connected with the book although the story itself was poignant and relatable, whereas with this book I was completely invested in the story, the characters and the outcome.
Like I said, I went into it as if it was a new story to me and it's the reason I want to find out more about the classic novel. This re-imagining was very well done, entertaining and pulled at your heartstrings. I'm aware some things will have been altered from the original story but I enjoyed it for what it was.
For a short book, I connected with the characters instantly and loved it. I do recommend this whether you're familiar with Little Women or not - it was an endearing and interesting take on a classic.
I ended up really enjoying it and sympathizing with the characters. I'd previously read [b:Amina's Voice|30312547|Amina's Voice|Hena Khan|https://i.gr-assets.com/images/S/compressed.photo.goodreads.com/books/1478818044l/30312547._SY75_.jpg|50799344] and while I did give it 4 stars, I didn't feel that connected with the book although the story itself was poignant and relatable, whereas with this book I was completely invested in the story, the characters and the outcome.
Like I said, I went into it as if it was a new story to me and it's the reason I want to find out more about the classic novel. This re-imagining was very well done, entertaining and pulled at your heartstrings. I'm aware some things will have been altered from the original story but I enjoyed it for what it was.
For a short book, I connected with the characters instantly and loved it. I do recommend this whether you're familiar with Little Women or not - it was an endearing and interesting take on a classic.
dahabow's review against another edition
5.0
This was such a sweet and endearing book. The relationship between Jameela and her family was beautiful to read about and the way they deal with the diagnosis of one of the daughters was powerful. I love that their Muslim identity was central and I learnt so much, like being grateful for the moments I have with loved ones. I also appreciated reading about Jameela's growth as a journalist and as a person, overcoming her anger and being more aware of others.
casehouse's review against another edition
4.0
Right on the heels of an intense novel, I read this gem of a middle grade book. It deals with serious issues but takes a warm approach. I appreciated the main character and her loving family.
suzannedix's review against another edition
5.0
What kismet! I read [b:Meg, Jo, Beth, and Amy: A Graphic Novel: A Modern Retelling of Little Women|39295317|Meg, Jo, Beth, and Amy A Graphic Novel A Modern Retelling of Little Women|Rey Terciero|https://i.gr-assets.com/images/S/compressed.photo.goodreads.com/books/1548515637l/39295317._SX50_.jpg|60873370] yesterday and randomly chose [b:More to the Story|43822031|More to the Story|Hena Khan|https://i.gr-assets.com/images/S/compressed.photo.goodreads.com/books/1565526333l/43822031._SY75_.jpg|68193974] from my pile. I had no idea I was reading another modern retelling of Little Women! Khan's story is fantastic and has so much heart. Highly recommended to all middle school students. Perfect for kids who enjoyed [b:Wonder|11387515|Wonder (Wonder, #1)|R.J. Palacio|https://i.gr-assets.com/images/S/compressed.photo.goodreads.com/books/1545695751l/11387515._SY75_.jpg|16319487].
gabieowleyess's review against another edition
3.0
3.5/5 stars.
So grateful to have this one in my classroom library!
So grateful to have this one in my classroom library!
kellyz628's review against another edition
5.0
I LOVE Little Women so I was hesitant to read this modern day adaption. However, my friend (our Library Department Chair) did Book Talks with my class and raved about it. So I downloaded it right away and it has the same feel as Little Women BUT it is from the perspective of a Muslim-American family. You get to learn about their culture in today’s society and it was so much fun to see how the author honored the classic novel. Highly recommend!
ljrinaldi's review against another edition
4.0
Little Women in spades
This is an interesting take on Little Women, as it takes place in modern times, is the story of four Muslim girls, and takes place outside Atlanta Georgia. Other than that, not much changes. :)
It is a cute interpretation, and the narrator has a good voice, and is very stubborn.
This is an interesting take on Little Women, as it takes place in modern times, is the story of four Muslim girls, and takes place outside Atlanta Georgia. Other than that, not much changes. :)
It is a cute interpretation, and the narrator has a good voice, and is very stubborn.
pixie_hallows's review against another edition
5.0
This middle grade read was a modern day retelling of Little Women in a Pakistani-American family. I loved it!
alteirence's review against another edition
4.0
3,5 ⭐
When I heard there's a Muslim middle-grade Little Women retelling, I'm already sold.
This story meets my expectations well. It felt like reading a modernized version of Little Women, with its warmth and love among the characters. Reading this makes me miss Jo very much.
However, this book also has its own uniqueness and originality. Even though it's a retelling, it's still refreshing to read. Especially since it takes the muslim community's point of view.
It's very bittersweet. The family and friendship dynamics are very heartwarming yet also very sad since they have to deal with cancer. I like the characters, I like how Jameela wasn't perfect. It felt so realistic thinking how she was just a middle schooler. I also like how she owned her mistakes and the way she apologized to Ali.
Simply put, I enjoyed reading this so much
When I heard there's a Muslim middle-grade Little Women retelling, I'm already sold.
This story meets my expectations well. It felt like reading a modernized version of Little Women, with its warmth and love among the characters. Reading this makes me miss Jo very much.
However, this book also has its own uniqueness and originality. Even though it's a retelling, it's still refreshing to read. Especially since it takes the muslim community's point of view.
It's very bittersweet. The family and friendship dynamics are very heartwarming yet also very sad since they have to deal with cancer. I like the characters, I like how Jameela wasn't perfect. It felt so realistic thinking how she was just a middle schooler. I also like how she owned her mistakes and the way she apologized to Ali.
Simply put, I enjoyed reading this so much