mehsi's review against another edition
4.0
Well.... that was just disturbing in many many ways. But then again, that is what this series is all about, disturbing, scary, sick events.
I finally decided to read this one, though I was wary. I knew this one would be extra disturbing because it took place during the Warden's time, before Brookline broke down completely and turned into an empty (but spooky) shell. I knew that things wouldn't be sunshine and flowers.
And after reading, and practically losing my appetite and also gaining goosebumps, I can say this was truly gruesome and there is the feeling of uneasiness from the start. You just wonder when stuff starts to get scary, when stuff starts to be disturbing. The Warden is even creepier than ever, and I just felt so sorry for Jocelyn, that she got stuck in this place. If only she knew what happens here. Though then again Jocelyn is apparently not the kind of girl who just runs away, even when things turn really creepy, she stays. I am not sure if I would call it stupidity or bravery, either way, I feel sorry for the girl.
We also meet with Lucy, this time as a child. Man, those parts about Lucy just made me feel just so uneasy (and sad). Poor girl. :(
As I said, the book has that feeling of uneasiness, but as the book goes it becomes something more than that. You feel repelled, creeped out. The author really has a great way of writing books, I also noticed the same pattern in her other Asylum books.
I won't spoil the ending, but boy, did I just say bye to my appetite. *shivers*
If you are looking for a creepy, unsettling read, and have (of course) read the other Asylum books, check this one out. Even though I was seriously uneasy I still would recommend this book because it is a great horror book.
Review first posted at http://twirlingbookprincess.com/
I finally decided to read this one, though I was wary. I knew this one would be extra disturbing because it took place during the Warden's time, before Brookline broke down completely and turned into an empty (but spooky) shell. I knew that things wouldn't be sunshine and flowers.
And after reading, and practically losing my appetite and also gaining goosebumps, I can say this was truly gruesome and there is the feeling of uneasiness from the start. You just wonder when stuff starts to get scary, when stuff starts to be disturbing. The Warden is even creepier than ever, and I just felt so sorry for Jocelyn, that she got stuck in this place. If only she knew what happens here. Though then again Jocelyn is apparently not the kind of girl who just runs away, even when things turn really creepy, she stays. I am not sure if I would call it stupidity or bravery, either way, I feel sorry for the girl.
We also meet with Lucy, this time as a child. Man, those parts about Lucy just made me feel just so uneasy (and sad). Poor girl. :(
As I said, the book has that feeling of uneasiness, but as the book goes it becomes something more than that. You feel repelled, creeped out. The author really has a great way of writing books, I also noticed the same pattern in her other Asylum books.
I won't spoil the ending, but boy, did I just say bye to my appetite. *shivers*
If you are looking for a creepy, unsettling read, and have (of course) read the other Asylum books, check this one out. Even though I was seriously uneasy I still would recommend this book because it is a great horror book.
Review first posted at http://twirlingbookprincess.com/
maxoliveira's review against another edition
dark
mysterious
fast-paced
- Plot- or character-driven? A mix
- Strong character development? It's complicated
- Loveable characters? No
- Diverse cast of characters? N/A
- Flaws of characters a main focus? N/A
2.75
simonlewis17's review against another edition
3.0
Frustrating.
Good but forgettable. Doesn't make any sense. Just opens another what ifs story to the series.
Still recommended to everyone who reads the series.
Read in order okay?
LOL!
:)
Good but forgettable. Doesn't make any sense. Just opens another what ifs story to the series.
Still recommended to everyone who reads the series.
Read in order okay?
LOL!
:)
aylimmcidio's review against another edition
dark
mysterious
fast-paced
- Plot- or character-driven? Character
- Strong character development? Yes
- Loveable characters? Yes
- Diverse cast of characters? It's complicated
- Flaws of characters a main focus? No
4.5
SLAY QUEEN I LOVE YOU.
raquelzuniga's review against another edition
1.0
Spanish/English Review.
Otra historia un poco innecesaria. Lo pondre todo bajo spoiler.
Nos presentan a la misma enfermera de la precuela, lo cual like así como otros personajes como el antepasado de Dan, y Lucy, la tía de Abby. De quién en realidad nos mostraba mucha promesa de historia la autora (con eso que es la chica de la portada de la primera novela) y pues, nos dejo sin nada. Supongo que esta novela fue ese intento de añadirle un poco más de historia. Pero solo cayó como algo sin sentido después de Sanctum y Catacomb.
Esperen pronto mi review de la saga en Youtube. No se les olvide seguirme y decirme que les pareció este review.
Sígueme en:
@nocturnal.reads en Instagram
@_nocturnalreads en Twitter
Nocturnal Reads en Youtube
Another unnecesary story. I'll leave it all under spoiler.
We're shown the same nurse from the prequel, which i did like, as well as some other characters like the infamous Warden and Lucy, Abby's aunt. About Lucy, I think it was somewhat clickbait given that she is the cover of the first novel and showed a lot of promise from the author, but fell flat to focus on other plot points. I guess this novel was to give these character some more spotlight. It just didn't seem like a great thing and didn't make much sense after Sanctum and Catacomb.
Follow me:
@nocturnal.reads on Instagram
@_nocturnalreads on Twitter
Nocturnal Reads on Youtube
Otra historia un poco innecesaria. Lo pondre todo bajo spoiler.
Spoiler
Nos presentan a la misma enfermera de la precuela, lo cual like así como otros personajes como el antepasado de Dan, y Lucy, la tía de Abby. De quién en realidad nos mostraba mucha promesa de historia la autora (con eso que es la chica de la portada de la primera novela) y pues, nos dejo sin nada. Supongo que esta novela fue ese intento de añadirle un poco más de historia. Pero solo cayó como algo sin sentido después de Sanctum y Catacomb.
Esperen pronto mi review de la saga en Youtube. No se les olvide seguirme y decirme que les pareció este review.
Sígueme en:
@nocturnal.reads en Instagram
@_nocturnalreads en Twitter
Nocturnal Reads en Youtube
Another unnecesary story. I'll leave it all under spoiler.
Spoiler
We're shown the same nurse from the prequel, which i did like, as well as some other characters like the infamous Warden and Lucy, Abby's aunt. About Lucy, I think it was somewhat clickbait given that she is the cover of the first novel and showed a lot of promise from the author, but fell flat to focus on other plot points. I guess this novel was to give these character some more spotlight. It just didn't seem like a great thing and didn't make much sense after Sanctum and Catacomb.
Follow me:
@nocturnal.reads on Instagram
@_nocturnalreads on Twitter
Nocturnal Reads on Youtube
holly_mcc's review against another edition
dark
mysterious
tense
fast-paced
- Plot- or character-driven? Character
- Strong character development? It's complicated
- Loveable characters? Yes
- Diverse cast of characters? It's complicated
- Flaws of characters a main focus? No
4.0
nikkiethereader's review against another edition
3.0
The Warden was practically famous during his time at the Asylum. Two nurses are happy to find themselves employed there. But one will find out that the Asylum is not what it appears to be. There are many practices going on behind closed doors. Patients that normal staff is not permitted to see. Can she survive knowing the dark secrets she uncovers?
I really did like this book. I will not be bashing this book at all. I can't say it was my favorite of the Asylum series, to be honest. But I did enjoy it. I always wondered what happened dear the time the Asylum was open. I wondered how he was able to hide all his experiments from everybody without raising suspicions.
I think maybe that's the reason I can't say I fully enjoyed this book. I was expecting a bigger production. To me, the book fell rather flat and didn't offer the background that I was expecting. I was expecting a lot more spook and flair. A lot more background than a mere skim of the events surrounding it all. I don't mean to be overly critical. It just didn't work for me.
Despite that, I do recommend this book. I recommend reading all of the Asylum trilogies. It's definitely one of my favorite trilogies of all times. Even though it's not one of my favorites of the entire series, it is definitely worth the read. The little bit of background makes it worth it alone!
I really did like this book. I will not be bashing this book at all. I can't say it was my favorite of the Asylum series, to be honest. But I did enjoy it. I always wondered what happened dear the time the Asylum was open. I wondered how he was able to hide all his experiments from everybody without raising suspicions.
I think maybe that's the reason I can't say I fully enjoyed this book. I was expecting a bigger production. To me, the book fell rather flat and didn't offer the background that I was expecting. I was expecting a lot more spook and flair. A lot more background than a mere skim of the events surrounding it all. I don't mean to be overly critical. It just didn't work for me.
Despite that, I do recommend this book. I recommend reading all of the Asylum trilogies. It's definitely one of my favorite trilogies of all times. Even though it's not one of my favorites of the entire series, it is definitely worth the read. The little bit of background makes it worth it alone!
emilyyjjean's review against another edition
2.0
Hmm...I know this is a novella, but the story ended quite abrupt. It didn't wrap itself up at all, and I'm quite upset. The story was getting rather interesting and now I'm just left with wondering what happened.
It has connections that are made in the 3rd installment [book:Catacomb|23429355] so that was nice. I was able to notice them right away. But this could also be a standalone story as well.
The part that really has me vexed is the ending. It was an introduction of characters, a build up to interesting events, exciting plot parts happen, and then it just . . .
It has connections that are made in the 3rd installment [book:Catacomb|23429355] so that was nice. I was able to notice them right away. But this could also be a standalone story as well.
The part that really has me vexed is the ending. It was an introduction of characters, a build up to interesting events, exciting plot parts happen, and then it just . . .