joshgauthier's review
4.0
Delving more into the backstories and complexities of the central characters, Vol. 4 is one of the better stories so far in this series. With a relatively straightforward murder mystery, it builds up the bold characters and steampunk aesthetic that make the series fun to read. And while the art maintains its distinctly male-gaze in character design, it is otherwise striking. And the end of this volume seems to be setting up an interesting direction for future installments.
lady_nett's review
3.0
This was a good installment of the series. I love the art in these graphic novels so much!
carroq's review
4.0
Disclaimer: I received a free ecopy via NetGalley in exchange for an honest review.
Anyone who has read this far into the series is probably enjoying it and I'm glad to say that volume four delivers more of the same. This time around, there is someone out killing inventors and all signs point to Lady Mechanika as the killer.
This book strongly follows up on the previous volumes. While Lady Mechanika's past still remains a bit of a mystery, this book plunges into the past of one of her associates. This helps round out the setting a bit and fills in some gaps of how certain characters and organizations are connected.
Someone reading this book as the first in the series really shouldn't be lost. There are a few references to events of the past few books, but nothing that should leave a reader out in the cold. The art is still good. I've had some issues with the way that Lady Mechanika and some of the other women have been drawn, but this volume seems to be moving away from a lot of those elements. The steampunk Victorian age setting is fun and the art goes a long way to bringing the books to life.
Anyone who has read this far into the series is probably enjoying it and I'm glad to say that volume four delivers more of the same. This time around, there is someone out killing inventors and all signs point to Lady Mechanika as the killer.
This book strongly follows up on the previous volumes. While Lady Mechanika's past still remains a bit of a mystery, this book plunges into the past of one of her associates. This helps round out the setting a bit and fills in some gaps of how certain characters and organizations are connected.
Someone reading this book as the first in the series really shouldn't be lost. There are a few references to events of the past few books, but nothing that should leave a reader out in the cold. The art is still good. I've had some issues with the way that Lady Mechanika and some of the other women have been drawn, but this volume seems to be moving away from a lot of those elements. The steampunk Victorian age setting is fun and the art goes a long way to bringing the books to life.
aelurus's review against another edition
5.0
Ma chronique complète :
http://letmentertainyou.com/2018/10/21/lady-mechanika-le-mystere-du-corps-mecanique-t-5/
http://letmentertainyou.com/2018/10/21/lady-mechanika-le-mystere-du-corps-mecanique-t-5/
quirkycatsfatstacks's review
4.0
I received a copy of Lady Mechanika Vol. 4 through NetGalley in exchange for a fair and honest review.
About a year ago I had a friend suggest the Lady Mechanika series to me, and I’ve been so grateful ever since. Now we’re up to four volumes in the main plot, as well as one short story (Le Dama de la Muerte) to the series. It’s hard to believe it’s come so far so fast, but here we are!
There are a lot of reasons I enjoy the Lady Mechanika series, one of the reasons is probably pretty obviously. The Artwork is absolutely amazing. I’d say that this series probably has the best artwork out of all of the series I read (and if somebody knows work of this quality – please send me the name of a new series I can fall in love with!). I love the steampunk elements used in this series, and how much attention is giving to the details, something that is especially important in a believable steampunk series.
The one downside to this series is the length. Most of the volumes are pretty short, with this one being less than ninety pages. It would be nice to have more pages to immerse oneself into it, but really it is what it is. Each volume is more or less a standalone plot, with the main plot being an undercurrent that’s supplemented by the events occurring. That means that at least we’re not left with cliffhangers or anything annoying like that.
Also, quick side note. If you look at this volume in multiple locations you’ll find that the novel number changes from one to the other. I think this probably depends on if they’re counting the Le Dama de la Muerte to be number four or not, but I’m not entirely certain of it. All I know is that it’s listed as five on Goodreads and NetGalley, but only four on Amazon. The cover also says four, so take from that what you will.
If you’re enjoyed the previous few volumes of this series, then I can pretty much guarantee you’ll enjoy this one as well. The tone has been uniform throughout the series, as has the artwork (thank goodness – I don’t think I could survive a deviation from the style I’ve fallen so in love with). Lady Mechanika is still trying to track down her origins, though as always more current issues take the fore front of her adventures.
I absolutely loved the tone of this volume. I know that could probably be said for every volume, but this one in particular felt like they perfected what they were aiming for. They held to the same elements, while introducing yet another new set of characters, intrigue for our current members, and potential risks and danger. There wasn’t really that much advancement to the main plot, though we learned quite a lot about Mr. Lewis and his background, which was fantastic.
I’m looking forward to the next volume. Hopefully it’ll once again begin hinting at Lady Mechanika’s past and creation. They’ve been building up to it since the start, and who knows how long it’ll be before we ever learn the truth. Still, I hold out hopes each volume that we’ll get a hint or two (admittedly this volume was rather slim on that front).
For more reviews, check out Quirky Cat's Fat Stacks
About a year ago I had a friend suggest the Lady Mechanika series to me, and I’ve been so grateful ever since. Now we’re up to four volumes in the main plot, as well as one short story (Le Dama de la Muerte) to the series. It’s hard to believe it’s come so far so fast, but here we are!
There are a lot of reasons I enjoy the Lady Mechanika series, one of the reasons is probably pretty obviously. The Artwork is absolutely amazing. I’d say that this series probably has the best artwork out of all of the series I read (and if somebody knows work of this quality – please send me the name of a new series I can fall in love with!). I love the steampunk elements used in this series, and how much attention is giving to the details, something that is especially important in a believable steampunk series.
The one downside to this series is the length. Most of the volumes are pretty short, with this one being less than ninety pages. It would be nice to have more pages to immerse oneself into it, but really it is what it is. Each volume is more or less a standalone plot, with the main plot being an undercurrent that’s supplemented by the events occurring. That means that at least we’re not left with cliffhangers or anything annoying like that.
Also, quick side note. If you look at this volume in multiple locations you’ll find that the novel number changes from one to the other. I think this probably depends on if they’re counting the Le Dama de la Muerte to be number four or not, but I’m not entirely certain of it. All I know is that it’s listed as five on Goodreads and NetGalley, but only four on Amazon. The cover also says four, so take from that what you will.
Spoiler
If you’re enjoyed the previous few volumes of this series, then I can pretty much guarantee you’ll enjoy this one as well. The tone has been uniform throughout the series, as has the artwork (thank goodness – I don’t think I could survive a deviation from the style I’ve fallen so in love with). Lady Mechanika is still trying to track down her origins, though as always more current issues take the fore front of her adventures.
I absolutely loved the tone of this volume. I know that could probably be said for every volume, but this one in particular felt like they perfected what they were aiming for. They held to the same elements, while introducing yet another new set of characters, intrigue for our current members, and potential risks and danger. There wasn’t really that much advancement to the main plot, though we learned quite a lot about Mr. Lewis and his background, which was fantastic.
I’m looking forward to the next volume. Hopefully it’ll once again begin hinting at Lady Mechanika’s past and creation. They’ve been building up to it since the start, and who knows how long it’ll be before we ever learn the truth. Still, I hold out hopes each volume that we’ll get a hint or two (admittedly this volume was rather slim on that front).
For more reviews, check out Quirky Cat's Fat Stacks
melisag's review
5.0
Loved it. Loved the art work. Just enough story and drama and action. I'm hoping he delves more into her past
cathepsut's review
3.0
I read Volume 1 some time ago and thought I give this a try. Pretty much the same experience. Pretty nice artwork, if you don‘t mind that the women are built like Barbie and have rubber tire lips. I like the muted colours.
The murder mystery was ok, alas it did not interest me much. There is a twist at the end, but it is not terribly surprising.
If you are into steampunk murder-mysteries with busty women, this might be a great choice.
There is some confusion regrading the numbering. Not quite sure if this is Volume 4 or 5.
I received this free e-copy from the publisher/author via NetGalley, in exchange for an honest review, thank you!
The murder mystery was ok, alas it did not interest me much. There is a twist at the end, but it is not terribly surprising.
If you are into steampunk murder-mysteries with busty women, this might be a great choice.
There is some confusion regrading the numbering. Not quite sure if this is Volume 4 or 5.
I received this free e-copy from the publisher/author via NetGalley, in exchange for an honest review, thank you!
More...