Reviews with content warning for Deportation - With A Vengeance

Reviews tagging 'Deportation'

With A Vengeance by Freydís Moon

7 reviews

graceheartsbooks's review

1.0

Edit: As of May 7th, 2024, I have learned things about this author that I don’t feel comfortable supporting so I am removing my review and taking this author off my TBR. I’m very disappointed as I loved their books up until point and I feel gutted knowing that they’ve lied about their identity multiple times. The gist is that they are not a trans latin author and are actually a white woman named Taylor Barton who has made several identities for herself. If you want more info, look at withcindy’s YouTube video posted on April 24th.

[I am only keeping my star ratings on the books so this can hopefully be seen by more people]

Content Warnings

moonyreadsbystarlight's review

Go to review page

Plot- or character-driven? A mix
Strong character development? Yes
Diverse cast of characters? Yes
Flaws of characters a main focus? Yes

I did read this but I no longer feel comfortable recommending anything by this author.

Content Warnings

authoroconnor's review

Go to review page

dark emotional inspiring mysterious reflective tense medium-paced

Plot- or character-driven? Character
Strong character development? It's complicated
Loveable characters? Yes
Diverse cast of characters? Yes
Flaws of characters a main focus? Yes

5.0

Wow. Where do I even begin? Perhaps with the first thing I wrote in my notes: "Oh my gods?? Amazing?"

I didn't entirely know what to expect when picking up this book. I don't remember adding it to my TBR but when I was gifted it for Christmas I was excited to tuck into the first book I've ever read with a trans or nonbinary protagonist. And I am so glad I did.

From the start, Freydís Moon draws the reader into the main character's world, their prose sharp and powerful enough that we can empathise with Kye Lovato's struggles, their experiences, and their grief -- even if we have not personally been through some of it. While I am not Mexican or even PoC, I was deeply invested in learning tidbits of Kye's culture and history while also sharing some of their trauma and mixed feelings towards their family. The author does an excellent job at making it clear the story is for and about not only trans people, but Mexicans and PoC, and does not hold the reader's hand on the offchance they might not know the culture -- merely conveying the importance of the subplot involving Kye's family Alebrijes business and trusting the reader's intelligence and empathy will do the rest, which I appreciated as someone completely ignorant of the culture but not entitled enough to believe I should be spoon-fed that information.

While some readers might find the nature of the erotica within this book to be disturbing, I immediately latched on to Kye's journey with Eli, absolutely charmed by the way Moon is able to depict all the elements that come with a healthy BDSM relationship -- consent, boundaries, and to what extent it can be used as a coping mechanism and exploration of personal identity. I found a lot of Kye's relationship with sex mirrored my own: the belief that pain was something I deeply needed, the use of 'subspace' to relinquish control in a life that offered me none, putting myself in dangerous situations as a form of self-harm and control-seeking. The evolution of Kye sexual relationship with Eli from relinquishing control to taking it back, all in a safe environment with no judgement, was poignant and resonated deeply with me.

On the subject of trauma recovery, it is easy to believe that this story will end up another "broken protagonist simply needs a good dicking down to be 'cured'" cliche, but Moon takes that narrative by the throat and tears it to pieces. Even when their body is transformed to their most ideal self, the story makes it clear that their dysphoria is not magically cured as it is primarily caused by others' perception of them -- something my fellow trans people will understand intimately. The same can be said for their trauma. Kye's past haunts them from start to finish regardless of Eli's help, allowing the character full agency to take back their power and be reborn in a beautiful metaphor that will resonate with both trauma survivors and trans people alike. The prose and story both contain a beautiful mix of raw, honest truths and sweeping, vivid metaphor that had me utterly engrossed from start to finish, especially with the expert way every theme of the story is interwoven in its metaphors.

The romance within this story is equal parts erotic, thrilling and heartwarming. There were multiple parts that had me smiling like a smitten schoolgirl with how sweet the dynamic between Eli and Kye gets, especially as the story progresses. Their dialogue feels natural, real; like they've known each other for lifetimes. The little bits of Eli's past we get given are tiny tastes of his true motivation that show us just how sincere and invested he is in Kye's life, and the ways they communicate had me chuckling aloud in places. Equally, their rocky, awkward friendship with Esther is adorable and wholesome, even while acknowledging they may never truly know each other closely.

Without spoiling anything, the end of the story is one that quite literally had me grinning at my book at 6 in the morning, unable to put it down for something as paltry as sleep. While the story is primarily character-focused, the conclusion of the family business/ICE plot is so satisfying and thrilling. The post-it I marked the section in my book with literally just says "FUCK YES". Truly the ACAB conclusion we deserve.

From start to finish, With a Vengeance is the trans power fantasy I didn't know I needed. It brought me to laughter, to tears, had me all but kicking my legs and twirling my hair. And right at the end of the book are the Acknowledgements -- their placement there rather than the beginning absolutely genius, as I found myself brought to tears one last time.

To everyone who resonated with Kye Lovato: I see you. Your rage is a gift.

-Acknowledgements

To Freydis Moon: I feel seen. Thank you for making my first read of 2024 an absolute gif

Content Warnings

amyreadsitall's review against another edition

Go to review page

challenging dark mysterious sad medium-paced

Plot- or character-driven? Character
Strong character development? Yes
Loveable characters? It's complicated
Diverse cast of characters? Yes
Flaws of characters a main focus? Yes

3.75

Content Warnings

fromthefoxhole's review against another edition

Go to review page

medium-paced

Plot- or character-driven? Character
Strong character development? Yes
Loveable characters? Yes
Diverse cast of characters? Yes
Flaws of characters a main focus? Yes

ETA : I no longer support this author due to the wealth of evidence that they have been misrepresenting themselves as a POC author when they are in fact white.

More details can be found here - https://docs.google.com/document/d/1VDvDujeoisTBddhXYaWGi-8V0EUdFZ5Uc00f4tnWpSY/edit?usp=drivesdk

Content Warnings

lasafica_reads's review

Go to review page

dark medium-paced

Strong character development? No
Loveable characters? No

2.0

*UPDATE 05/01/2024: Just found out that this author is in fact not Latine in any way whatsoever and has been pretending to not just be Latine but also a POC Latine which is very sickening.

Now in regards to my original review of this book i think that this explains the offness i felt when reading this. Im glad i followed my gut and never read anything else from this author. The harm that this has caused is maddening.**

This book rubbed me the wrong way and i cant quite put my finger on why but ill try.

Before i start I want to say there will be some spoilers and also that this review is coming from my experience as a Queer Latine who is a child of a immigrants. Also, also, also forgive my sentence structure i know its awful lmao.

To start, the way the friendship with Esther was written really got under my skin. I understand the main character is supposed to be imperfect and messy and distrusting especially after what happened with their mom, however i cant get over how Kye, who is Latine & knows how awful ICE is to their community, made the choice to intimidate Esther with ICE violence. Having to read through the scene where Kye threatens to give Esthers picture to the ICE agent if Esther didnt do what Kye wanted, made my stomach twist. And then the next time they talk Kye gets what they want from Esther and proceeds to tell Esther that "if itll save my own ass" ill turn in all the undocumented workers from my moms business AND THEN proceeded to talk down to and explain to Esther how oppressive systems work as if Esther is a naive child. The thing is, i think i might be able to get past that if Kye ever appropriately apologized for it. But they didnt it was kind of like "Well you know me im kind of f*cked up. Oppsie ✌🏼😃"As if thats a good reason to not fully own up to and rectify the awful way Kye treated Esther for the majority of the book and was willing to use their own community as canon fodder, to benefit themselves.

Personally i thought everything about the ICE/undocumented/immigrant storyline was handled so carelessly and not wrapped up with any kind of thoughtfulness.

I think the only part of this book that felt like it was handled semi well was the gender identity however it still felt kind of removed from Kyes Latine identity. It made me sad because i only read this book because i thought i was going to get a story about the Trans Latine experience and yet the Latine experience was not done well and felt separate from the Trans identity as if their isnt an entire intersection to be explored. Its so hard to find a queer/trans book about Latine people by Latine people so when i found this i was so excited unfortunately for me this book was overall a very disappointing read, with very few redeeming qualities.

Content Warnings

krystalg's review against another edition

Go to review page

dark fast-paced

Plot- or character-driven? A mix
Strong character development? Yes
Loveable characters? It's complicated
Diverse cast of characters? Yes
Flaws of characters a main focus? Yes

5.0

Content Warnings

More...