ivybeans's review against another edition
4.0
A good antidote to Moneyball. It points out where Moneyball was right and where in many cases it was wrong. It does a critical review of sabermetrics; what is good and what is bad. He likes consistency and predictive value. He is also very critical of propriety work being done that cannot be validated by peers. He has an interesting statistic on the value of sabermetrics to MLB teams. Although most teams have jumped on the bandwagon, there is the notable exception of the very successful Atlanta Braves.
More...