raven_morgan's review against another edition
5.0
Reread, read originally before I was on Goodreads.
And just lovely on a reread. I opted to get a kindle version of this to save my hands from the thick book (though there's no way I'm getting rid of my paper versions of Marillier's books!).
Pure magic. Anyone who enjoys historical fantasy, or historical fiction, should give Marillier's work a go.
And just lovely on a reread. I opted to get a kindle version of this to save my hands from the thick book (though there's no way I'm getting rid of my paper versions of Marillier's books!).
Pure magic. Anyone who enjoys historical fantasy, or historical fiction, should give Marillier's work a go.
bloggingwithdragons's review against another edition
4.0
I received this book for free from NetGalley in exchange for an honest review. This does not affect my opinion of the book or the content of my review.
Actual rating: 4.5/5 stars
There are no words for just how much I enjoyed Daughter of the Forest, a truly enchanting and unique novel. I was immediately ensnared from the very first page of Daughter of the Forest, which follows a young girl named Sorcha, who grows up in a magical, wild forest with her six older brothers. With a father completely focused on war and bereft of his wife, who died bearing his only daughter, Sorcha is completely raised and cared for by her brothers. Sorcha grows up running wild in a forest that is more than it seems, learning how to heal with its plants and to respect the magical forces and the nature that reside there. But her idyllic life comes to an end when her father unexpectedly remarries a wicked woman named Oonagh with strange powers, who promptly and systematically tries to destroy everything her new stepchildren hold dear.
Life as she knows it for Sorcha as a healer and sister is irrevocably over when Oonagh turns her brothers into swans. Fleeing for her life, Sorcha is told by her mysterious ally, the Lady of the Forest, that if she weaves her swan brothers each a shirt made out of a painful, thorny plant known as starwort, and places them over their necks one after the other, they can be changed back into humans. But there’s more than one catch, as there usually is in these types of fairy tales--each part of the making of the shirt, must be Sorcha’s doing and Sorcha’s alone--the harvesting of the thorny plant, the creation of the thread, the spinning of the shirts. And sweet, Sorcha, lover of telling tales cannot speak a single word or tell anyone of her plight in any way, shape, or form--for then her brothers can never be changed back and will remain cursed as swans forever. Though the brothers transform back into human form on midsummer and midwinter evenings, she is unable to speak to even them or to tell them of her mission to save those most precious to her.
So invested was I in brave, kind Sorcha’s quest to save her brothers that I stayed up until all hours of early morning in order to finish it. Daughter of the Forest is the most magical book I have read since The Bear and The Nightingale. It made me weep on multiple occasions for Sorcha is faced with more than just the evil of magic--she is faced with the pure evil of mankind. These parts of the novel were hard to read, as Daughter of the Forest conveys them in such a realistic way. But I loved kind, gentle Sorcha so much. The depth of dedication to and love for her brothers was even more astonishing than the magic of the tale and her surroundings. I loved the focus on this selfless, platonic love.
Throughout all of her tribulations, the magical, sentient forest is a character of its own, one providing a safe harbor for Sorcha until she is swept away by circumstance to the strange, foreign lands of Britain, who were forever at war with her own people. There she is faced with prejudice and fear, but also finds companionship in Lord Hugh “Red” of Harrowfield, who shelters her despite the disapproval of his family and neighbors. I thought I would be bored when Sorcha left the forest--but I was anything but. Not only does Sorcha have to confront a culture different from her own, but accusations of witchcraft, lechery, and a very different kind of love than the one she holds for her brothers--something that is more terrifying for her than any magic she has faced before.
Though I found this love, slow-forming (which is to my personal taste), well-developed, and as beautiful as everything else in Daughter of the Forest, I could not help but to feel conflicted about it. This was the main reason that I gave this amazing book a 4.5 instead of 5 stars. I was somewhat dismayed that Sorcha ended up with the love interest that she did. In the beginning of Daughter of the Forest, we learned of a prophecy that she would end up with a Briton and that only the child of such a union could stop the war between her people of the forest and theirs. As such, I was sure that the younger brother of Red, Simon, whom she nursed back to health so tenderly after being tortured as prisoner of war by her family, would be the one for her. Since she healed more than just his physical wounds, I had hoped that the two would somehow find each other again, especially with her newfound connection to Red. But that was not the case and Though I wished it had gone a different way, the ending that Sorcha gets is still beautiful.
Lines like those are enough to make any reader swoon and see that the speaker of them is still a great love match for Sorcha, even if he wasn’t my first choice for her. I also took pleasure in the fact that Sorcha remained so close to her brothers, and didn’t drop everything to be with a man. In many fairy tales, the maiden, once defeating a curse, moves away to be with her one true love in a castle or kingdom far away. But this is not so in Daughter of the Forest. What a breath of fresh air.
Literally the only other thing stopping me from giving Daughter of the Forest a 5/5 star rating was that once
Honestly, I absolutely adored Daughter of the Forest and it is now one of my all-time favorite novels. I am not sure any review, especially mine, could adequately capture how magical, engrossing, and simply beautiful this novel is. I cannot recommend reading it enough for fans of fantasy, fairy-tales, romance, magic, or strong female characters. And for those that loved that Winternight Trilogy, you will certainly love Daughter of the Forest as well. I’m already planning to read more of the series and to purchase a hard copy of the novel.
Bloggingwithdragons.com
My Book Review Policy
Actual rating: 4.5/5 stars
There are no words for just how much I enjoyed Daughter of the Forest, a truly enchanting and unique novel. I was immediately ensnared from the very first page of Daughter of the Forest, which follows a young girl named Sorcha, who grows up in a magical, wild forest with her six older brothers. With a father completely focused on war and bereft of his wife, who died bearing his only daughter, Sorcha is completely raised and cared for by her brothers. Sorcha grows up running wild in a forest that is more than it seems, learning how to heal with its plants and to respect the magical forces and the nature that reside there. But her idyllic life comes to an end when her father unexpectedly remarries a wicked woman named Oonagh with strange powers, who promptly and systematically tries to destroy everything her new stepchildren hold dear.
“We all accepted that this land was a gate to the other world, the realm of spirits and dreams and the Fair Folk, without any question.”
Life as she knows it for Sorcha as a healer and sister is irrevocably over when Oonagh turns her brothers into swans. Fleeing for her life, Sorcha is told by her mysterious ally, the Lady of the Forest, that if she weaves her swan brothers each a shirt made out of a painful, thorny plant known as starwort, and places them over their necks one after the other, they can be changed back into humans. But there’s more than one catch, as there usually is in these types of fairy tales--each part of the making of the shirt, must be Sorcha’s doing and Sorcha’s alone--the harvesting of the thorny plant, the creation of the thread, the spinning of the shirts. And sweet, Sorcha, lover of telling tales cannot speak a single word or tell anyone of her plight in any way, shape, or form--for then her brothers can never be changed back and will remain cursed as swans forever. Though the brothers transform back into human form on midsummer and midwinter evenings, she is unable to speak to even them or to tell them of her mission to save those most precious to her.
“You must listen, and listen well. For indeed you have a choice. You can flee and hide, and wait to be found. You can live out your days in terror, without meaning. Or you can take the harder choice, and you can save them.”
So invested was I in brave, kind Sorcha’s quest to save her brothers that I stayed up until all hours of early morning in order to finish it. Daughter of the Forest is the most magical book I have read since The Bear and The Nightingale. It made me weep on multiple occasions for Sorcha is faced with more than just the evil of magic--she is faced with the pure evil of mankind. These parts of the novel were hard to read, as Daughter of the Forest conveys them in such a realistic way. But I loved kind, gentle Sorcha so much. The depth of dedication to and love for her brothers was even more astonishing than the magic of the tale and her surroundings. I loved the focus on this selfless, platonic love.
Throughout all of her tribulations, the magical, sentient forest is a character of its own, one providing a safe harbor for Sorcha until she is swept away by circumstance to the strange, foreign lands of Britain, who were forever at war with her own people. There she is faced with prejudice and fear, but also finds companionship in Lord Hugh “Red” of Harrowfield, who shelters her despite the disapproval of his family and neighbors. I thought I would be bored when Sorcha left the forest--but I was anything but. Not only does Sorcha have to confront a culture different from her own, but accusations of witchcraft, lechery, and a very different kind of love than the one she holds for her brothers--something that is more terrifying for her than any magic she has faced before.
Though I found this love, slow-forming (which is to my personal taste), well-developed, and as beautiful as everything else in Daughter of the Forest, I could not help but to feel conflicted about it. This was the main reason that I gave this amazing book a 4.5 instead of 5 stars. I was somewhat dismayed that Sorcha ended up with the love interest that she did. In the beginning of Daughter of the Forest, we learned of a prophecy that she would end up with a Briton and that only the child of such a union could stop the war between her people of the forest and theirs. As such, I was sure that the younger brother of Red, Simon, whom she nursed back to health so tenderly after being tortured as prisoner of war by her family, would be the one for her. Since she healed more than just his physical wounds, I had hoped that the two would somehow find each other again, especially with her newfound connection to Red. But that was not the case and
Spoiler
Sorcha winds up with Red, to the dismay of Simon and her newly human brothers.“He would have told her--he would have said, it matters not if you are here, or there for I see you before me every moment.”
Lines like those are enough to make any reader swoon and see that the speaker of them is still a great love match for Sorcha, even if he wasn’t my first choice for her. I also took pleasure in the fact that Sorcha remained so close to her brothers, and didn’t drop everything to be with a man. In many fairy tales, the maiden, once defeating a curse, moves away to be with her one true love in a castle or kingdom far away. But this is not so in Daughter of the Forest.
Spoiler
Instead, Sorcha returns home to her forest with her beloved brothers and it is Red, not her, who gives up his home and moves to the forest to be with Sorcha.Literally the only other thing stopping me from giving Daughter of the Forest a 5/5 star rating was that once
Spoiler
Sorcha and her restored human brothers returned home, the Lady Oonagh fled immediately with her infant son! There was no vanquishing of evil or major battle. Although this means that there likely will be a conflict in future novels, I was disappointed. I also thought it a flaw that Oonagh was suddenly threatened by the brothers, though she wasn’t before. And frankly, she was more powerful than all of them before and able to turn them into swans! It just seemed like a bit of a leap for her to up and run this time, especially with all the havoc she had successfully reaped in their home in the meantime. There wasn’t really any explanation given for why she was so afraid of the seven siblings this time either, when she wasn’t before.Honestly, I absolutely adored Daughter of the Forest and it is now one of my all-time favorite novels. I am not sure any review, especially mine, could adequately capture how magical, engrossing, and simply beautiful this novel is. I cannot recommend reading it enough for fans of fantasy, fairy-tales, romance, magic, or strong female characters. And for those that loved that Winternight Trilogy, you will certainly love Daughter of the Forest as well. I’m already planning to read more of the series and to purchase a hard copy of the novel.
Bloggingwithdragons.com
My Book Review Policy
jacquilee's review against another edition
adventurous
emotional
slow-paced
- Plot- or character-driven? Character
- Strong character development? It's complicated
- Loveable characters? It's complicated
- Diverse cast of characters? No
- Flaws of characters a main focus? No
4.0
foreveryoungadult's review against another edition
Graded By: Stephanie
Cover Story: Let It Be Known: It’s A Fantasy!
BFF Charm: Platinum
Swoonworthy Scale: 6
Talky Talk: Masterclass
Bonus Factor: Retellings, History & Folklore, Healers
Anti-Bonus Factor: Rape
Relationship Status: Swans Mate For Life
Read the full book report here.
Cover Story: Let It Be Known: It’s A Fantasy!
BFF Charm: Platinum
Swoonworthy Scale: 6
Talky Talk: Masterclass
Bonus Factor: Retellings, History & Folklore, Healers
Anti-Bonus Factor: Rape
Relationship Status: Swans Mate For Life
Read the full book report here.
dancing_with_our_hands_tied's review against another edition
adventurous
medium-paced
- Plot- or character-driven? Character
- Strong character development? Yes
- Loveable characters? Yes
4.0
savsturg's review against another edition
5.0
It's been so long since I've had a book haunt me until I can find the time to pick it up again. This book hurt me, made me smile, made me yearn, made me grip the pages so hard I feared the library would be angry with me. Beautiful.
haewilya's review against another edition
5.0
So awesome! Goodness gracious. It won't be for everyone as there are some stretches of seeming like nothing is happening (as can be seen by my start date). But push through it, the parts that are good, are really, really good. It's not an entirely happy tail though.
taffy_sea's review against another edition
4.0
This fairy tale is long and dark, but magically told, set in mythical early Ireland and Britain.
myjourneywithbooks's review against another edition
4.0
I didn't really know anything else about the book when I started reading it, so the Irish setting came as quite a pleasant surprise. I loved the descriptions of the surroundings throughout the book and the details on the forest setting made me feel like I was right there myself!
The characters were so well crafted, especially Sorcha and her brothers. Sorcha's feelings, mainly of desperation and helplessness, during her quest were expertly conveyed and I couldn't help admiring her for her resilience in the face of all the obstacles and setbacks she suffered. One of the things I loved about Sorcha is that she's not a "badass heroine" like those spilling out of books today, but she still exhibits a great amount of strength in her own quiet way. Speaking of which, I thought I should put in a trigger warning here for a horrific rape scene about halfway through the book which can be quite difficult to read.
I loved that the story centered around the task Sorcha had to complete, and also that things never seemed to fall into place easily. The romance in the story was slow to develop and wasn't guilty of any of those cringe-worthy tropes like insta-love, for which I was very grateful.
If you'd like an old-timey fantasy novel filled with magic and a bit of Irish folklore mixed in, I'd definitely recommend this one. It is quite a slow read though, so be warned!
Now if only it wasn't so difficult to find the next two books in the series!
The characters were so well crafted, especially Sorcha and her brothers. Sorcha's feelings, mainly of desperation and helplessness, during her quest were expertly conveyed and I couldn't help admiring her for her resilience in the face of all the obstacles and setbacks she suffered. One of the things I loved about Sorcha is that she's not a "badass heroine" like those spilling out of books today, but she still exhibits a great amount of strength in her own quiet way. Speaking of which, I thought I should put in a trigger warning here for a horrific rape scene about halfway through the book which can be quite difficult to read.
I loved that the story centered around the task Sorcha had to complete, and also that things never seemed to fall into place easily. The romance in the story was slow to develop and wasn't guilty of any of those cringe-worthy tropes like insta-love, for which I was very grateful.
If you'd like an old-timey fantasy novel filled with magic and a bit of Irish folklore mixed in, I'd definitely recommend this one. It is quite a slow read though, so be warned!
Now if only it wasn't so difficult to find the next two books in the series!
cathik411's review against another edition
adventurous
emotional
hopeful
sad
medium-paced
- Plot- or character-driven? A mix
- Strong character development? Yes
- Loveable characters? Yes
- Diverse cast of characters? Yes
- Flaws of characters a main focus? It's complicated
4.75