angelqueen04's review
2.0
One of my reading guilty pleasures is juvenile mysteries, and I was very excited to read the first in the Suzanna Snow series. I came to like Suzanna very much, and was much intrigued by her "cousin", Will James, and her friend, Isaac Quimby. Beyond them, however, my reaction to the other characters ranged from mild irritation to vehement dislike. Suzanna is a delightful young girl, and has the makings of a fine detective, but just about everything around her was irritating in some manner or another. Perhaps it's just the time period the story takes place that irritates me, as I grew more and more impatient every time Suzanna was sidetracked or delayed because she had to go serve tea to one of the grumpy or snobby guests in her parents' hotel. What's more, the story started out very slowly, and it took all of my patience and determination to stick with it to the end.
deservingporcupine's review
5.0
This book reminded me so much of the nights I spent as a little girl reading by flashlight before bed. It was a really well-written YA mystery. The historical setting might make it a little tougher for my 5th graders, but I'm eager to see if any of them like it -- so I can start pushing Nancy Drew on them. I think I will definitely read the second one.
quietjenn's review
4.0
31/2. If you've been paying attention, you should know that two of the things I heart most are mysteries and plucky + smart girl heroines. Perfect combo of these qualities here. I really look forward to seeing the series (assumedly) develop.
bethnellvaccaro's review
3.0
This was a very enjoyable kids mystery and I think my students will like it. I would gladly read the next in the series.
barefootsong's review
4.0
An enjoyable mystery set in early 19th-century Canada on the Bay of Fundy (which has the highest and lowest tides in the world -- a fact I had just learned earlier this year in a different book!). My one complaint was that there are a lot of characters (Zanna's parents manage a hotel, so there are all the guests to keep track of) and younger readers might get confused, but the narrative usually provides some context to help you remember the characters who haven't been "on scene" in a while. I really enjoyed the main characters and am looking forward to the further adventures of Zanna and co.
hdbblog's review
5.0
Suzanna, or Zanna as she prefers, was one of the most fun, intelligent and witty young protagonists that I've had the pleasure of reading in a long time. Angie Frazier aims The Midnight Tunnel at the middle grade reader, but what I loved is that she didn't sacrifice anything to do that. This book has tons of crossover appeal, and anyone who loves a good mystery coupled with historical fiction will fall in love. Beware the rambling my friends, so it begins.
First let me tell you why I loved Suzanna so much. Her mother and father want her to be a well behaved young woman. They hope that she will follow in their footsteps and want to run the inn. Unfortunately for them, and fortunately for us, Suzanna has a much different path in mind! She wants to be a world renown detective like her Uncle Bruce. For that, I love her. She's a little bit rebel, and a whole lot of trouble without meaning to be. I instantly fell in love with her wit, her inability to stay away from trouble, and her downright brilliant deductions! Young or old, readers will definitely find something to connect to in her character.
In terms of story, as I mentioned above there is an entire mystery wrapped up in these pages! When a young guest goes missing, Suzanna takes it upon herself to unravel the mystery. Those of you who are older readers might be worried that this book will be too "young" for you. Let me tell you this. I read mystery novels and I generally solve mystery novels about half way through. This one? I was guessing until almost the very end. As I said, Angie Frazier doesn't sacrifice one bit for her audience. I like that she doesn't find it necessary to "dumb things down" for a middle grade reader. Utterly fantastic. I wish I could say more, but I've already had to delete so much to keep this spoiler free.
I ended up having to put The Midnight Tunnel down for a few days last week to take care of other commitments, and I tell you that it killed me to do it! I kept wondering how everything was going to end. What Angie Frazier has written here is a stunning mystery that is wrapped up in a very middle grade friendly package. I enjoyed each and every minute of this book and I can't wait to read the next one! I know Suzanna will keep on doing her detective work, and I'll be there to follow along.
First let me tell you why I loved Suzanna so much. Her mother and father want her to be a well behaved young woman. They hope that she will follow in their footsteps and want to run the inn. Unfortunately for them, and fortunately for us, Suzanna has a much different path in mind! She wants to be a world renown detective like her Uncle Bruce. For that, I love her. She's a little bit rebel, and a whole lot of trouble without meaning to be. I instantly fell in love with her wit, her inability to stay away from trouble, and her downright brilliant deductions! Young or old, readers will definitely find something to connect to in her character.
In terms of story, as I mentioned above there is an entire mystery wrapped up in these pages! When a young guest goes missing, Suzanna takes it upon herself to unravel the mystery. Those of you who are older readers might be worried that this book will be too "young" for you. Let me tell you this. I read mystery novels and I generally solve mystery novels about half way through. This one? I was guessing until almost the very end. As I said, Angie Frazier doesn't sacrifice one bit for her audience. I like that she doesn't find it necessary to "dumb things down" for a middle grade reader. Utterly fantastic. I wish I could say more, but I've already had to delete so much to keep this spoiler free.
I ended up having to put The Midnight Tunnel down for a few days last week to take care of other commitments, and I tell you that it killed me to do it! I kept wondering how everything was going to end. What Angie Frazier has written here is a stunning mystery that is wrapped up in a very middle grade friendly package. I enjoyed each and every minute of this book and I can't wait to read the next one! I know Suzanna will keep on doing her detective work, and I'll be there to follow along.
More...