alphalimaindia's review against another edition
adventurous
emotional
mysterious
tense
medium-paced
- Plot- or character-driven? Plot
- Strong character development? Yes
- Loveable characters? It's complicated
- Diverse cast of characters? No
- Flaws of characters a main focus? Yes
3.75
ssjonoyoung's review against another edition
4.0
This picks up with the quest of the Keystones with the Freefolk in tow. Crow Tal's old adversary makes a reappearance as the Shadows grow stronger.
Whilst this book mostly serves to set up the last two it does it with an incredible amount of action and character development. I think most importantly in this Tal really begins to change his ways. It's in the little things when he doesn't always admonish the Underfolk or treat them poorly. He grows and works with Crow to reclimb the Red Tower where the Keystone lies.
The Freefolk were a cool movement if a little extreme. Though incredibly short on numbers it is undeniable that they were skilled in fighting and courage. Crow was particularly interesting because he is clearly untrusting and slightly villainous in how he treats Tal yet I really enjoyed him. Tal and Crow's sections in the latter half were so much fun. The Red Tower presents a challenge but both of them are constantly trying to slightly one up one another, that's the feeling you get anyway. The whole section with the recovery of the Red Keystone and Tal's Veil were brilliant and intense though the Tal's Veil scene was a little adorable. Of course Crow betrays him in the end but Tal kinda knew it was coming and then Tal almost kills everyone brilliant.
Milla on the other hand after meeting the Freefolk heads on her way back to the Icecarl with Odris. After a sadly violent interaction with the Shield Maidens, a moment I feel spelling out she shall not become one, she tells the Crones everything. After the deadwalking thingy bit that was creepy as hell. But the Crones are fair to her and appoint her War Chief because the threat of the Veil's collapse is too much. It is a risk they cannot take even the Icecarl. And the epilogue has the Icecarl marching on the Castle. And Tal is trapped and it's all pretty hopeless for everyone else.
Odris and Adras were of course brilliant with Adras's thick-headedness becoming especially memorable as he thinks he can fight his way through just about anything. Odris is clever and rather nicely is beginning to care for Milla which is sweet because Milla doesn't expect it like Tal does. The relationship of the Spiritshadows and their counterparts is really marked by their different upbringing. Tal expect Adras to be there whilst Milla would rather she didn't but clearly they care for one another. Then you have the growing amount of light magic and the complications of Sunstones and the Keystones. It's so incredibly fleshed out and the way it's been built is perfect. Tal's own limited knowledge plays a great factor in how we learn because the Lectorium has clearly failed him.
The next book really poses a threat because the free Spiritshadows are all around and that is a threat that none should take lightly. Sushin is plotting still to take the Keystones and presumably destroy the Veil though Tal thinks it's already weakened which would probably be correct. Bizarrely this book mostly takes place in a single day, the Day of Ascension, where the Empress is in Aenir. I hope we get to meet her. Like seriously looking forward to the next one because I have a feeling it's gonna be stunning.
Whilst this book mostly serves to set up the last two it does it with an incredible amount of action and character development. I think most importantly in this Tal really begins to change his ways. It's in the little things when he doesn't always admonish the Underfolk or treat them poorly. He grows and works with Crow to reclimb the Red Tower where the Keystone lies.
The Freefolk were a cool movement if a little extreme. Though incredibly short on numbers it is undeniable that they were skilled in fighting and courage. Crow was particularly interesting because he is clearly untrusting and slightly villainous in how he treats Tal yet I really enjoyed him. Tal and Crow's sections in the latter half were so much fun. The Red Tower presents a challenge but both of them are constantly trying to slightly one up one another, that's the feeling you get anyway. The whole section with the recovery of the Red Keystone and Tal's Veil were brilliant and intense though the Tal's Veil scene was a little adorable. Of course Crow betrays him in the end but Tal kinda knew it was coming and then Tal almost kills everyone brilliant.
Milla on the other hand after meeting the Freefolk heads on her way back to the Icecarl with Odris. After a sadly violent interaction with the Shield Maidens, a moment I feel spelling out she shall not become one, she tells the Crones everything. After the deadwalking thingy bit that was creepy as hell. But the Crones are fair to her and appoint her War Chief because the threat of the Veil's collapse is too much. It is a risk they cannot take even the Icecarl. And the epilogue has the Icecarl marching on the Castle. And Tal is trapped and it's all pretty hopeless for everyone else.
Odris and Adras were of course brilliant with Adras's thick-headedness becoming especially memorable as he thinks he can fight his way through just about anything. Odris is clever and rather nicely is beginning to care for Milla which is sweet because Milla doesn't expect it like Tal does. The relationship of the Spiritshadows and their counterparts is really marked by their different upbringing. Tal expect Adras to be there whilst Milla would rather she didn't but clearly they care for one another. Then you have the growing amount of light magic and the complications of Sunstones and the Keystones. It's so incredibly fleshed out and the way it's been built is perfect. Tal's own limited knowledge plays a great factor in how we learn because the Lectorium has clearly failed him.
The next book really poses a threat because the free Spiritshadows are all around and that is a threat that none should take lightly. Sushin is plotting still to take the Keystones and presumably destroy the Veil though Tal thinks it's already weakened which would probably be correct. Bizarrely this book mostly takes place in a single day, the Day of Ascension, where the Empress is in Aenir. I hope we get to meet her. Like seriously looking forward to the next one because I have a feeling it's gonna be stunning.
constant_reader_19's review against another edition
4.0
He series is still going strong. Interesting plot twist at the end of this one.
imyerhero's review against another edition
3.0
he more I read in this series the more I enjoy the story. Each of the characters is growing up a little more with each installment and the plot line evolves into something more intricate and enveloping. I’m surprised at some of the plot twists, which is nice to have for a change especially in a YA novel. And although I’m pretty sure I know how this book is going to end, I’m still excited to get there.
glowing_embers16's review against another edition
5.0
I love this series. It's gripping, adventurous fantasy at its finest.
benjfleck's review against another edition
3.0
Above the Veil: Or, So the Drama, So the Sunstone
Tal and Milla get separated in this volume after much drama and fighting. Things aren't looking good for anyone. Milla is cranky and annoyed, wanting to rejoin her Shield Maidens. Tal is nervous and worried, trying to free his father and stop Sushin from whatever evil things he is up to. Oh that's right, to prevent the Veil from falling. Cause that would be bad. I think.
Milla eventually rejoins the Shield Maidens, who think it is a great time to attack the Castle. Oh great! Meanwhile, Tal, and his new frenemy, grumpy Crow, go above the Veil to help free the people. I don't know. This one got way too convoluted for me.
There is a lot going on -- but this volume definitely felt like a link between two books. Just a lot of journeying and positioning with nothing really happening at all. Spiritshadows Adras and Odris are the only things saving this book from being really blah.
Tal and Milla get separated in this volume after much drama and fighting. Things aren't looking good for anyone. Milla is cranky and annoyed, wanting to rejoin her Shield Maidens. Tal is nervous and worried, trying to free his father and stop Sushin from whatever evil things he is up to. Oh that's right, to prevent the Veil from falling. Cause that would be bad. I think.
Milla eventually rejoins the Shield Maidens, who think it is a great time to attack the Castle. Oh great! Meanwhile, Tal, and his new frenemy, grumpy Crow, go above the Veil to help free the people. I don't know. This one got way too convoluted for me.
There is a lot going on -- but this volume definitely felt like a link between two books. Just a lot of journeying and positioning with nothing really happening at all. Spiritshadows Adras and Odris are the only things saving this book from being really blah.
lhawk1's review against another edition
4.0
This book was amazing. I wasn't sure how this one would continue the story, but it really did a great job. Really one of my favorite things about this book is how short it is. In all honesty, this whole series could probably be condensed into 2, maybe 3 books, just by combing books. But it is SO much more enjoyable and relaxing this way.
My favorite part, though? Milla. I love her character arc, and overall development and the huge part she plays in this story (and that awful cliffhanger, too.)
Aside from Milla, I adore the world. It's really fascinating. Not in an oh-my-gosh-this-could-happen-to-me way that a lot of Dystopian/Sci-fi/Fantasy novels often have. But just the plain and simple a) politics of the society, and b) the way the magic and shadows work. It's just fascinating.
The plot of this series is really original and, well, refreshing. Everything is new, and really intriguing.
I'm 15, and I recommend this book.
My favorite part, though? Milla. I love her character arc, and overall development and the huge part she plays in this story (and that awful cliffhanger, too.)
Aside from Milla, I adore the world. It's really fascinating. Not in an oh-my-gosh-this-could-happen-to-me way that a lot of Dystopian/Sci-fi/Fantasy novels often have. But just the plain and simple a) politics of the society, and b) the way the magic and shadows work. It's just fascinating.
The plot of this series is really original and, well, refreshing. Everything is new, and really intriguing.
I'm 15, and I recommend this book.
jessica_rodrigues's review against another edition
adventurous
lighthearted
medium-paced
- Plot- or character-driven? Plot
- Strong character development? No
- Loveable characters? Yes
- Diverse cast of characters? No
- Flaws of characters a main focus? No
3.0
jaxamaline's review against another edition
4.0
Really enjoying this series - the plot thickens and the action and intrigue is coming in hot!
reginaborsellino's review against another edition
adventurous
fast-paced
- Plot- or character-driven? Plot
2.75