mayukiiq's review against another edition
3.5
the pacing wasn’t great, and i would’ve loved to at least read some of the events from Caleb’s perspective, but a pretty good hisfic overall
pamiverson's review against another edition
5.0
Another good book by a favorite author. What it would be like to be an independent young woman during a period (1600's) that does not look favorably upon independent young women. Or the Native American young man who became her friend. Their shared love of learning was a strong bond. I especially appreciated Brooks' use of language -- it really sounded like the diary of the young woman reflecting back on important phases of her life.
canadiyank's review against another edition
4.0
Loosely based on a historical character, Caleb, one of the first Native Americans to graduate from Harvard, "Caleb's Crossing" tells of his life, schooling, and death as intertwined with his friend (and the narrator) Bethia's experiences. A beautiful and unexpected story set in 17th c. colonial America.
bese199's review against another edition
4.0
I totally agree with the Washington Post reviewer who said this book is 'intelligent, thoughtful, gracefully written and original..." I enjoyed it. One criticism - the last few chapters felt rushed. Suddenly, we were no longer a part of the lives of the characters; we were listening to the narrator sum things up. But so much happened to the main characters in that time, and we were not there.
waterlily12's review against another edition
5.0
incredible book, so well written and a page turner... gorgeous writing and fascinating historical content
mary412's review
3.0
I listened to this book because it is a book group selection, but I didn't think I'd be that crazy about it and I was right. Probably should listen again and see if I change my mind.
dpm's review against another edition
4.0
I very much enjoyed this book. It was an informative picture into the settling of New England and in particular Nantucket as well as the beginnings of Harvard. Brooks paints a picture in long detailed strokes of the 1600's and the lives of both Native Americans and immigrants that forever changed the landscape.
biblioph1le's review against another edition
4.0
Not sure about this one. Not as good as People of the Book which I loved
greenrain's review against another edition
4.0
This novel appealed to me for several reasons, the biggest two being the female narrator and the history of Native Americans prior to European contact and the aftermath of that contact. The story didn't go where I was afraid it might, staying historically accurate. The old language was done well, from what I can tell. Overall, something I'd recommend to others.
I'm beginning to like this author. I have a difficult time finding fiction about women that focuses on more than just romantic relationships (nothing wrong with that, but I like writing that really makes me think about other issues).
I'm beginning to like this author. I have a difficult time finding fiction about women that focuses on more than just romantic relationships (nothing wrong with that, but I like writing that really makes me think about other issues).