buchundgewitter's review against another edition
5.0
Habs wieder sehr geliebt, auch wenn ich das halbe Buch ein Nervenbündel war wegen 'the untrue sister' und ich eine gewissen Figur nicht zu 100% vertrauen wollte.
Aber die Schwesternbeziehungen, die Mythologie, Arus Wut, hach, *chef's kiss*!
Kommt mir fast schon zynisch vor über Erwachsene & Mächtige zu lesen, die sich nicht in die Kriege anderer einmischen wollen, weil es sie direkt nicht betrifft oder die das nur als Unterhaltung sehen, aber das wurde vor 2022 geschrieben, also ...
Aber die Schwesternbeziehungen, die Mythologie, Arus Wut, hach, *chef's kiss*!
Kommt mir fast schon zynisch vor über Erwachsene & Mächtige zu lesen, die sich nicht in die Kriege anderer einmischen wollen, weil es sie direkt nicht betrifft oder die das nur als Unterhaltung sehen, aber das wurde vor 2022 geschrieben, also ...
nmeeyorelvr's review against another edition
adventurous
medium-paced
- Plot- or character-driven? A mix
- Strong character development? Yes
- Loveable characters? Yes
- Diverse cast of characters? Yes
- Flaws of characters a main focus? It's complicated
5.0
emmreadsbooks's review against another edition
4.0
This book was good, but didn't live up to the previous 3 to me. Perhaps it's just because we keep adding characters to the ensemble cast, or because I predicted the majority of the plot twists throughout. But we do get to see Aru really grow as a person in this one, as she navigates the introduction of Kara to her friend group and a new and dangerous quest. The humor in this book is top notch with a few callbacks to our traditional Aru wit (DEE TWO!!). With all of that being said, I can't WAIT to see the finale of this series in 2022 (and hopefully Roshani will finally end a book without a cliffhanger).
booksandpops4000's review against another edition
4.0
I really enjoyed this read and think it is my favorite book in the series to date. This book reminded me alot of the group quest elements that I adored in the percy jackson world. I loved how this book tackled indian mythology in so many ways and such a captivating way. I liked how the romance plot line is slowly developmentally though the read and finally pop a bit. It also added so new characters and dived in to the drama that occurred at the tale end of the previous book. It was really fast pace read and had a hard time putting it down. I am dying for last book. Aru really went through it in this book and loved where she wound up at the very end.
briarrose1021's review
5.0
Aru made a wish on the Tree of Wishes, but she can't remember what it was. She is pretty sure, though, that her wish was NOT for a sister. Yet, a new sister is what she apparently has if she is to believe the girl who looks strangely familiar. She does know that she needs to find her friends, the other Pandavas.
At the same time, Aru is sure she wants to continue the battle she's been fighting on behalf of the devas against the Sleeper. The gods have not been truthful, and they have been too devious with their plans. A prime example is Kubera, the ruler of the city of gold, who promises two powerful new weapons to the Pandavas... IF they pass the trials he has set forth. If they lose, they won't be able to defeat the Sleeper's forces that will be attacking Lanka soon in his bid to take over the Overworld.
This is another great book from Chokshi, and there are quite a few twists for Aru and her friends. With the loss of her memories surrounding the Tree of Wishes, Aru is dealing with increasing anxiety about her friends and whether or not they think she is the Pandava of prophecy that is untrue. This isn't helped by the difficulty that she faces trying to convince them all that Boo betrayed them; it's not surprising that the others have trouble believing his betrayal, as he has been close to the entire group through a lot of ups and downs.
The addition of Aru's new sister Kara adds an interesting dynamic to the group, and the question of whether or not she's there on behalf of the Sleeper and just waiting to betray them weighs on the group. That's not helped by the way she talks about the Sleeper, extolling his virtues as a dad.
Where some authors might let the character development fall by the wayside by this point in a series - after all, by the fourth book, if you don't know who the characters are and aren't able to identify with any of them, it's unlikely you're going to, so why bother continuing to develop the characters? Chokshi says to Heck with that and continues with the development. I didn't realize it was possible, but I found myself identifying with Aru more in this book than I had previously. With the addition of Kara and her being accepted into the group, Aru begins to feel left out. When she compares herself to Kara, she finds herself wanting, and that leads her to question her own abilities. What if she's not good enough to protect them? To save them? What if her friends like Kara more than her? It's not surprising that Aru develops jealousy. But what I loved about Aru is that she realizes jealousy is not a good feeling to have. Rather than give in to those feelings, she fights through the feelings, for her friends, and for the world, growing into her role as a leader.
Aiden gets a lot of development in this book. He's been a bit underdeveloped in the previous books when compared with the other characters, but the patience for his development pays off in this book. He opens up in this book, showing his vulnerability. We also learn more about his background, which helps explain his refusal to take sides in disagreements. A bit of warning, though: Aiden is a complete jerk to Aru for a lot of the book, and we don't find out why for a long while. Lacking any apparent reason, I found myself really disliking Aiden in this book. I wouldn't go so far as saying I hated him, but I definitely did not like him. I don't want to give anything away, so I will just say that Chokshi doesn't leave him there. There is a reason for his actions and his behavior, and there is definitely a payoff for the wait at the end.
Mini's major growth happened in the last book, and in this one, we see the results of the growth. I definitely liked the new strength that Mini has, and how she uses that to support everyone as they work towards their goals. Brynne's growth circles around her impulsivity and her tendency to make decisions for everyone. Her tendency to try to take control is frustrating at times, but Chokshi does a great job of building her relationships with everyone else, which also leads her to realize that she can care for others without controlling them.
As for Kara, she was somewhat of an enigma throughout the entire book. While her sincerity remained constant throughout the book, I never really knew how I felt about her. In large part, that's because she's a brand new character, introduced into a group of established characters. Still, because of her sincerity, her desire to want to be friends with everyone, I found myself being won over by her. There are some things that I can't mention without giving away spoilers, but I am definitely looking forward to seeing what kind of role she plays in the series finale. For those of you asking about the twins, there are in this book, but they aren't running around with the group so we don't see much of them. I hope they play a larger role in the next book because I want to learn more about them!
All this talk about character development doesn't mean the action was left behind. Quite the opposite. The action, the pacing of it, was absolutely perfect, and the way the plot came together at the end - along with the new information that was revealed - was just *chef's kiss* perfect.
As with the other books, I listened to the audiobook which was also narrated by Soneela Nankani. She gave a wonderful performance, pulling me into the book to the point that I had to force myself to stop listening so I could go to sleep. Given the option, I will definitely be listening to the final book. I can't wait to start that book and find out how everything is going to come together.
At the same time, Aru is sure she wants to continue the battle she's been fighting on behalf of the devas against the Sleeper. The gods have not been truthful, and they have been too devious with their plans. A prime example is Kubera, the ruler of the city of gold, who promises two powerful new weapons to the Pandavas... IF they pass the trials he has set forth. If they lose, they won't be able to defeat the Sleeper's forces that will be attacking Lanka soon in his bid to take over the Overworld.
This is another great book from Chokshi, and there are quite a few twists for Aru and her friends. With the loss of her memories surrounding the Tree of Wishes, Aru is dealing with increasing anxiety about her friends and whether or not they think she is the Pandava of prophecy that is untrue. This isn't helped by the difficulty that she faces trying to convince them all that Boo betrayed them; it's not surprising that the others have trouble believing his betrayal, as he has been close to the entire group through a lot of ups and downs.
The addition of Aru's new sister Kara adds an interesting dynamic to the group, and the question of whether or not she's there on behalf of the Sleeper and just waiting to betray them weighs on the group. That's not helped by the way she talks about the Sleeper, extolling his virtues as a dad.
Where some authors might let the character development fall by the wayside by this point in a series - after all, by the fourth book, if you don't know who the characters are and aren't able to identify with any of them, it's unlikely you're going to, so why bother continuing to develop the characters? Chokshi says to Heck with that and continues with the development. I didn't realize it was possible, but I found myself identifying with Aru more in this book than I had previously. With the addition of Kara and her being accepted into the group, Aru begins to feel left out. When she compares herself to Kara, she finds herself wanting, and that leads her to question her own abilities. What if she's not good enough to protect them? To save them? What if her friends like Kara more than her? It's not surprising that Aru develops jealousy. But what I loved about Aru is that she realizes jealousy is not a good feeling to have. Rather than give in to those feelings, she fights through the feelings, for her friends, and for the world, growing into her role as a leader.
Aiden gets a lot of development in this book. He's been a bit underdeveloped in the previous books when compared with the other characters, but the patience for his development pays off in this book. He opens up in this book, showing his vulnerability. We also learn more about his background, which helps explain his refusal to take sides in disagreements. A bit of warning, though: Aiden is a complete jerk to Aru for a lot of the book, and we don't find out why for a long while. Lacking any apparent reason, I found myself really disliking Aiden in this book. I wouldn't go so far as saying I hated him, but I definitely did not like him. I don't want to give anything away, so I will just say that Chokshi doesn't leave him there. There is a reason for his actions and his behavior, and there is definitely a payoff for the wait at the end.
Mini's major growth happened in the last book, and in this one, we see the results of the growth. I definitely liked the new strength that Mini has, and how she uses that to support everyone as they work towards their goals. Brynne's growth circles around her impulsivity and her tendency to make decisions for everyone. Her tendency to try to take control is frustrating at times, but Chokshi does a great job of building her relationships with everyone else, which also leads her to realize that she can care for others without controlling them.
As for Kara, she was somewhat of an enigma throughout the entire book. While her sincerity remained constant throughout the book, I never really knew how I felt about her. In large part, that's because she's a brand new character, introduced into a group of established characters. Still, because of her sincerity, her desire to want to be friends with everyone, I found myself being won over by her. There are some things that I can't mention without giving away spoilers, but I am definitely looking forward to seeing what kind of role she plays in the series finale. For those of you asking about the twins, there are in this book, but they aren't running around with the group so we don't see much of them. I hope they play a larger role in the next book because I want to learn more about them!
All this talk about character development doesn't mean the action was left behind. Quite the opposite. The action, the pacing of it, was absolutely perfect, and the way the plot came together at the end - along with the new information that was revealed - was just *chef's kiss* perfect.
As with the other books, I listened to the audiobook which was also narrated by Soneela Nankani. She gave a wonderful performance, pulling me into the book to the point that I had to force myself to stop listening so I could go to sleep. Given the option, I will definitely be listening to the final book. I can't wait to start that book and find out how everything is going to come together.
rain_baby's review against another edition
adventurous
emotional
funny
inspiring
reflective
tense
fast-paced
- Plot- or character-driven? A mix
- Strong character development? Yes
- Loveable characters? Yes
- Diverse cast of characters? Yes
- Flaws of characters a main focus? Yes
5.0
librarypatronus's review against another edition
4.0
Aru is such a fun character to watch develop, as she's not perfect but she's clearly trying. There are scenes when her anger gets the better of her, but her friends help her or she learns a lesson, and there are scenes where their flaws get the better of them and Aru hops right in to help. In this book, especially, she struggles more with the reality of her absent father, when compared to how he has been treating her sister, and while he is center stage the villain that she has to fight but has complicated feelings about. Her Mom is also absent for most of this book, and while that frustrates Aru, I think we also see how much she has grown in her behavior without her mother there to help tell her what to do. And I LOVED the budding romance, and I hope we see more of it in future books, which I can't wait to read.
ahoward12's review against another edition
adventurous
funny
lighthearted
fast-paced
- Plot- or character-driven? A mix
- Strong character development? Yes
- Loveable characters? Yes
- Diverse cast of characters? Yes
- Flaws of characters a main focus? No
4.5
nora_mcgowan's review against another edition
adventurous
emotional
funny
lighthearted
fast-paced
- Plot- or character-driven? Plot
- Strong character development? Yes
- Loveable characters? Yes
- Diverse cast of characters? Yes
- Flaws of characters a main focus? Yes
4.5