jashoney22's review against another edition
adventurous
funny
mysterious
fast-paced
- Plot- or character-driven? A mix
- Strong character development? Yes
- Loveable characters? Yes
- Diverse cast of characters? Yes
- Flaws of characters a main focus? No
5.0
madisynmanzella's review
adventurous
dark
funny
fast-paced
- Plot- or character-driven? A mix
- Strong character development? N/A
- Loveable characters? Yes
- Diverse cast of characters? N/A
3.5
katereads2much's review
5.0
I started reading the Wynonna Earp after falling in love with the TV show and I found the earlier runs to be amusing if a little shallow. This new run is more in line with the TV show in that characters that were introduced in the TV show that were not in the earlier comics are here and the humor is very similar and in my opinion the jokes land better. It seems Smith was able to reinvent his own stories in a way that I really enjoyed. The plot and even some of the character development happens differently in this volume than it did on the show so even though there were the familiar characters and humor that I already know and love the stories are fresh. I found the art and design to be more inviting and engaging as well. If you enjoyed the show, you’ll enjoy this volume of comics and if you enjoy monster hunting stories with a good dollop of humor, you’ll definitely want to pick this up.
reading_cat's review
4.0
Originally posted on Book-o-Craze!
This was a really interesting read, with a very original and unique plot.
I liked most of the characters, and the strength and independence of the main heroine!
I loved her interactions with the rest of the characters, as well as, how things ended up between her and someone specific *wink wink*
I would have liked a little less blood, and that's the only thing I would change in this big volume, that consists of 6 short issues!
The illustration was amazing and very life-like!
All in all, 4 stars for the beginning of a very promising series of graphic novels!
This was a really interesting read, with a very original and unique plot.
I liked most of the characters, and the strength and independence of the main heroine!
I loved her interactions with the rest of the characters, as well as, how things ended up between her and someone specific *wink wink*
I would have liked a little less blood, and that's the only thing I would change in this big volume, that consists of 6 short issues!
The illustration was amazing and very life-like!
All in all, 4 stars for the beginning of a very promising series of graphic novels!
a_chickletz's review
3.0
I took a leap of faith and started watching Wynonna Earp on SyFy last year and I loved it dearly. So now I wanted to check out the comics.
I can see that the characteristics, the look and the 'feel' of the comics is very much like the show... I felt confused by it because it felt like I was missing an earlier collection or I was supposed to put the comic arc between the events of the show.
But if I did that, then where would Officer Hyatt and Waverly fit in? They weren't exactly in the comic, but Waverly was in alluding to Wynonna having sisters.
Overall, it felt like a confusing comic arc but had interesting characters. I'll keep watching the show for sure.
I can see that the characteristics, the look and the 'feel' of the comics is very much like the show... I felt confused by it because it felt like I was missing an earlier collection or I was supposed to put the comic arc between the events of the show.
But if I did that, then where would Officer Hyatt and Waverly fit in? They weren't exactly in the comic, but Waverly was in alluding to Wynonna having sisters.
Overall, it felt like a confusing comic arc but had interesting characters. I'll keep watching the show for sure.
scostner's review
3.0
I watched several episodes of the TV series this summer, so when I saw this collection of issues 1-6, it caught my interest. The show and comics both capture a feeling that is almost "Deadpool" meets the wild west. The body count is staggering. The gore is dripping everywhere. There are plenty of snarky remarks. But there are also demons, witches, and cannibals rather than mutant villains. And Wynonna's natural talents in hunting down the unnatural enemies of mankind are a result of inheriting the family curse, not an extra options package in her DNA. The backstory of that curse and her famous ancestor (Wyatt), is revealed in small bits so that readers put together the big picture slowly, just as you do whenever you meet someone new. This new acquaintance just happens to have shootouts with demonic gunslingers and busts up black market deals for large shipments of brains.
Dealing with a family curse can make someone a bit touchy, so it shouldn't be a surprise that Wynonna tends to annoy her superior, Xavier Dolls. Then again, with a name like that, he should expect to be annoyed by people. Besides Wy and X (LOL), there are also John Henry, a questionable ally with a mysterious past, and another agent that has many years of experience (you'll have to read to find out who).
It's obvious that the writer is familiar with the Earp legend. Several of the lines spoken by Wynonna are almost identical to those spoken by Kurt Russell in the movie "Tombstone." As a fan of the movie, it was hard for me not to put the words, "I'll be your huckleberry," into John Henry's mouth, especially when he confronts Johnny Ringo (my mind kept picturing Val Kilmer and Michael Biehn).
If you have been enjoying the TV series, then you should try the comics and graphic novels.
I read an e-book provided by the publisher through NetGalley.
Dealing with a family curse can make someone a bit touchy, so it shouldn't be a surprise that Wynonna tends to annoy her superior, Xavier Dolls. Then again, with a name like that, he should expect to be annoyed by people. Besides Wy and X (LOL), there are also John Henry, a questionable ally with a mysterious past, and another agent that has many years of experience (you'll have to read to find out who).
It's obvious that the writer is familiar with the Earp legend. Several of the lines spoken by Wynonna are almost identical to those spoken by Kurt Russell in the movie "Tombstone." As a fan of the movie, it was hard for me not to put the words, "I'll be your huckleberry," into John Henry's mouth, especially when he confronts Johnny Ringo (my mind kept picturing Val Kilmer and Michael Biehn).
If you have been enjoying the TV series, then you should try the comics and graphic novels.
I read an e-book provided by the publisher through NetGalley.
nerdynexus's review
4.0
First of all, I will say that I devoured the Wynonna Earp TV show a few days ago; so stumbling across the first 6 comics on NetGalley was a real treat. Now I know it's not fair to compare a television show to a comic book, but I can see how a few things were similar.
Wynonna Earp is a US Marshall in the secret Black Badge division that hunt and eliminate paranormal threats. This comic has it all! Zombies, cannibals, demon fight clubs, bad ass women...and that's just the first few stories. Wynonna is sarcastic, quick tempered woman with a difficult past so watching her interact with the other characters was satisfying in a way. She always has something to say and she's not afraid to say it. The supporting characters are all interesting and I enjoyed them all. I really liked how Valdez and Agent Dolls were throwing the sass at each other! Doc was a great addition to help tie in with the Earp family curse. While there were a few bad guys that were taken down, there wasn't an ultimate big baddie yet so I'm looking forward to see how they will continue.
I will definitely be keeping up this comic AND show.
Wynonna Earp is a US Marshall in the secret Black Badge division that hunt and eliminate paranormal threats. This comic has it all! Zombies, cannibals, demon fight clubs, bad ass women...and that's just the first few stories. Wynonna is sarcastic, quick tempered woman with a difficult past so watching her interact with the other characters was satisfying in a way. She always has something to say and she's not afraid to say it. The supporting characters are all interesting and I enjoyed them all. I really liked how Valdez and Agent Dolls were throwing the sass at each other! Doc was a great addition to help tie in with the Earp family curse. While there were a few bad guys that were taken down, there wasn't an ultimate big baddie yet so I'm looking forward to see how they will continue.
I will definitely be keeping up this comic AND show.
engelsigh's review
4.0
I really enjoyed the opportunity to read Wynonna Earp Volume 1: Homecoming by Beau Smith. I am always glad for female comic book characters that kick butt. The idea of turning the Western world of Wyatt Earp into a paranormal story was intriguing to me. I found the story to be engaging and I like Wynonna's character, even though she is prickly and rough around the edges. This graphic novel inspired me to check out the TV Show that was made after it and I'm enjoying both the graphic novels and the show. I hope for more adventures in both mediums. Wynonna and her crew are an interesting group.
dkscully's review
3.0
Much, much, much better than the original. (Though nowhere near as good as the TV show.)