Scan barcode
wobbler's review against another edition
adventurous
challenging
dark
mysterious
sad
tense
medium-paced
- Plot- or character-driven? Character
- Strong character development? No
- Loveable characters? It's complicated
- Diverse cast of characters? No
- Flaws of characters a main focus? Yes
4.0
zare_i's review against another edition
4.0
While lots of people consider this novel to be satire I have to say I do not see it as such. Reason is I have come across people with characters as those portrayed in this novel and trust me these types of personality are more common in real world than one would admit. As a matter of fact not a single character in this novel is exaggeration of any sort. For me this makes novel very real one (and very sad one).
Alain - mid-level manager (although he likes to say he is working man with no managerial ambitions) who gets let go due to "restructuring within company" feels cheated and considering that he is not anymore in what is considered prime years hits the rock bottom. He decides to achieve his goals no matter what and is ready to walk over the dead bodies if necessary. Did he finally achieve what he wanted? Realistically yes. For those more romantic and idealistic answer would be no. But I would go for realistic.
Charles - Alain's friend. Some would say he is simple, he is not. Where it not for the Charles' of the world, people trusting the system, people that get mauled ever so often by that very system but who keep pushing on there would be no system. When they finally understand they are defeated they are ready to repay any kindness they receive - usually whoever they help forgets them after few minutes. You may call them door-mats I call them reminders of what it is to be human in a world where people trust nobody and are ready to backstab on first possible opportunity.
Nicole (and daughters) - the high morale holders. They are willing to carry the burden but I wonder 'till when. People like Alain are very difficult when things are not going their way so ... lets say it is questionable if his wife would stay with him (since Alain is a storyteller and he is very much in love with his wife we are left assuming she would but then again... would she?). Also daughters tend to come to their parents very often but I do not see them helping a lot (birthday presents notwithstanding) although they are aware of the situation. Pretty opportunistic but again something you see in every day life.
Management of Exxyol and HR company - depictions of your everyday manager. Cool, ruthless and ready to cake themselves in opposition's blood to prove how mighty they are. Until secrets are revealed after which they break down and are rather ready to die then be publicly shamed. They are also very prone to using violence as long as they do not know the details and keep their hands celan. People's lives mean nothing to them.
As for Fontana and his team, these are standard cutthroat types. One of the reviewers said they are not sure how Fontana & co got outsmarted but there was nothing in the novel hinting they were outsmarted. Where it not for the final twist everything would end up very very differently.
I especially liked news like "CEO of X and Y embezzled & billions of Euros", "Exquisite profits for company A, record breaking year" followed by "Unemployment grows" and "Company A had to release thousands of employees due to financial situation" spread throughout the novel - usual dumb news fed to the people. Interestingly majority would just go over it because everybody hopes to be at the top and who cares about the bottom feeders and stragglers. We like to think we are above this as society but we are not. Many people I know who used to talk a lot about corporations' "evil" etc ended up working for the same - no regret at all (plus side being that they stopped with their speeches).
Translation to English is great, story flows so naturally and grabs you from start and you need to stop reading in order to savor the story.
Excellent novel that pushes all the buttons about our society and values in general. One of the defining elements of our society is conflict but one would suspect fellow men would be more sympathetic. Unfortunately in this date and time they are not (although we like to say and think that situation is opposite). Unfortunately man is still a wolf to fellow man.
Highly recommended to fans of thriller and drama genre.
Alain - mid-level manager (although he likes to say he is working man with no managerial ambitions) who gets let go due to "restructuring within company" feels cheated and considering that he is not anymore in what is considered prime years hits the rock bottom. He decides to achieve his goals no matter what and is ready to walk over the dead bodies if necessary. Did he finally achieve what he wanted? Realistically yes. For those more romantic and idealistic answer would be no. But I would go for realistic.
Charles - Alain's friend. Some would say he is simple, he is not. Where it not for the Charles' of the world, people trusting the system, people that get mauled ever so often by that very system but who keep pushing on there would be no system. When they finally understand they are defeated they are ready to repay any kindness they receive - usually whoever they help forgets them after few minutes. You may call them door-mats I call them reminders of what it is to be human in a world where people trust nobody and are ready to backstab on first possible opportunity.
Nicole (and daughters) - the high morale holders. They are willing to carry the burden but I wonder 'till when. People like Alain are very difficult when things are not going their way so ... lets say it is questionable if his wife would stay with him (since Alain is a storyteller and he is very much in love with his wife we are left assuming she would but then again... would she?). Also daughters tend to come to their parents very often but I do not see them helping a lot (birthday presents notwithstanding) although they are aware of the situation. Pretty opportunistic but again something you see in every day life.
Management of Exxyol and HR company - depictions of your everyday manager. Cool, ruthless and ready to cake themselves in opposition's blood to prove how mighty they are. Until secrets are revealed after which they break down and are rather ready to die then be publicly shamed. They are also very prone to using violence as long as they do not know the details and keep their hands celan. People's lives mean nothing to them.
As for Fontana and his team, these are standard cutthroat types. One of the reviewers said they are not sure how Fontana & co got outsmarted but there was nothing in the novel hinting they were outsmarted. Where it not for the final twist everything would end up very very differently.
I especially liked news like "CEO of X and Y embezzled & billions of Euros", "Exquisite profits for company A, record breaking year" followed by "Unemployment grows" and "Company A had to release thousands of employees due to financial situation" spread throughout the novel - usual dumb news fed to the people. Interestingly majority would just go over it because everybody hopes to be at the top and who cares about the bottom feeders and stragglers. We like to think we are above this as society but we are not. Many people I know who used to talk a lot about corporations' "evil" etc ended up working for the same - no regret at all (plus side being that they stopped with their speeches).
Translation to English is great, story flows so naturally and grabs you from start and you need to stop reading in order to savor the story.
Excellent novel that pushes all the buttons about our society and values in general. One of the defining elements of our society is conflict but one would suspect fellow men would be more sympathetic. Unfortunately in this date and time they are not (although we like to say and think that situation is opposite). Unfortunately man is still a wolf to fellow man.
Highly recommended to fans of thriller and drama genre.
strawfly14's review against another edition
4.0
Pierre Lemaitre lo ha vuelto a hacer. Desde que leí Irène, Lemaitre es uno de mis imprescindibles, y con esta novela me ha vuelto a sorprender. Diferente a las demás, aunque mantiene la intriga y quizá con un toque demasiado exagerado en el tramo final, pero con un trasfondo normal que hace del libro más que una simple historia. Me ha parecido un novelón.
josemosle's review against another edition
4.0
Un protagonista al que uno odia pero quiere que gane. Una trama que a uno lo atrapa desde el segundo o tercer capítulo. Una moraleja encubierta. No se sabe qué va a pasar a la vuelta de la página. Aunque el final no podía ser tan bueno como el resto del libro, bravo por Pierre Lemaitre.
lintkaurea's review against another edition
4.0
Qué gozada. No le doy cinco estrellas porque me sobra un tercio del libro y la resolución de la trama no me acaba de convencer. Pero por otro lado, las últimas páginas no dejan ni respirar y hay que ser muy bueno para lograr eso en el lector. Súper recomendable.
mg_libros's review against another edition
3.0
Aunque tiene un giro muy chulo a mitad del libro, me he quedado con la sensación de historia floja. Es estretenido pero me parece que tiene demasiadas páginas para poca chicha.
A ratos parece escrito con desgana. Suelo ser muy fan del señor Lemaitre, pero en este caso no me ha fascinado como lo hace con otras novelas.
A ratos parece escrito con desgana. Suelo ser muy fan del señor Lemaitre, pero en este caso no me ha fascinado como lo hace con otras novelas.
estherbismarck's review against another edition
2.0
El punto de partida es muy interesante e igualmente interesante es el desarrollo de la trama durante el primer tercio de la novela aproximadamente, y el tema está de actualidad, es cierto, pero la mayor parte del libro me ha aburrido soberanamente.
remocpi's review against another edition
3.0
Entretenida novela, primera que leo de este autor. Un antiguo jefe de recursos humanos de una mediana empresa acaba en el paro y tras cuatro años subsistiendo de minijobs y perdiendo escalón a escalón todas las esperanzas que le iban quedando; pero un día le llegan noticias de un proceso de selección para un trabajo que será la solución a todos sus problemas.
La descripción del descenso al abismo de un parado de 57 años es bastante inquietante y me recordó mucho a otra que sí fue de verdad, la de la loca de la Fallarás. Es un retrato costumbrista de una clase media aspiracional que no puede llegar. Luego llegamos a la oferta de entrevista de trabajo y la novela cambia de registro, transformándose en una novela de aventuras que poco tiene que ver con la primera parte en cuestión de estilo y velocidad.
Un par de curiosidades: Cada vez que alguien pone la tele o la radio a lo largo de toda la novela se dan dos noticias: una sobre alguien que ha ganado una cantidad obscena de dinero (trader, CEO...) y otra sobre despidos masivos y EREs que tienen lugar en alguna empresa. Además, me pareció raro ver un "mañana en la batalla piensa en mí" como frase que estaba un poco encajada a martillazos, pronunciada por el prota. Dije anda, como el libro de Marías (que es en realidad una frase de Shakespeare). Luego, al final del libro, el autor destripa, restriega por la cara del lector, que ha dejado por el texto referencias (homenajes) a algunos autores favoritos, entre ellos Marías. Qué poca finesse, oiga.
En conjunto es una lectura entretenida, que pretende ser moralizante a la vez que ágil y emocionante. Para mí se queda en entretenida como lectura de verano.
La descripción del descenso al abismo de un parado de 57 años es bastante inquietante y me recordó mucho a otra que sí fue de verdad, la de la loca de la Fallarás. Es un retrato costumbrista de una clase media aspiracional que no puede llegar. Luego llegamos a la oferta de entrevista de trabajo y la novela cambia de registro, transformándose en una novela de aventuras que poco tiene que ver con la primera parte en cuestión de estilo y velocidad.
Un par de curiosidades: Cada vez que alguien pone la tele o la radio a lo largo de toda la novela se dan dos noticias: una sobre alguien que ha ganado una cantidad obscena de dinero (trader, CEO...) y otra sobre despidos masivos y EREs que tienen lugar en alguna empresa. Además, me pareció raro ver un "mañana en la batalla piensa en mí" como frase que estaba un poco encajada a martillazos, pronunciada por el prota. Dije anda, como el libro de Marías (que es en realidad una frase de Shakespeare). Luego, al final del libro, el autor destripa, restriega por la cara del lector, que ha dejado por el texto referencias (homenajes) a algunos autores favoritos, entre ellos Marías. Qué poca finesse, oiga.
En conjunto es una lectura entretenida, que pretende ser moralizante a la vez que ágil y emocionante. Para mí se queda en entretenida como lectura de verano.
mg_espi's review against another edition
3.0
Aunque tiene un giro muy chulo a mitad del libro, me he quedado con la sensación de historia floja. Es estretenido pero me parece que tiene demasiadas páginas para poca chicha.
A ratos parece escrito con desgana. Suelo ser muy fan del señor Lemaitre, pero en este caso no me ha fascinado como lo hace con otras novelas.
A ratos parece escrito con desgana. Suelo ser muy fan del señor Lemaitre, pero en este caso no me ha fascinado como lo hace con otras novelas.