urlphantomhive's review
3.0
Read all my reviews on http://urlphantomhive.booklikes.com
I really liked the concept for this. A middle-aged woman, mother of three, descents into Hell in order to find her lost family in this modern take on Dante's inferno.
What I liked was the main character, she was a real person and not a likely main character. I also liked the concept, as I said, but I felt that in the execution is was sometimes a bit too crowded, and I felt less would have been more in this case. Virgil has been changed for William Blake, possibly because he wrote some works on heaven and hell, that I haven't read. Also, Agatha Christie alters as the guide. There are a lot of quotes from the works of people they encounter, but once again it was a bit too much.
Also, the artwork was not really my style. While I appreciate the desperateness that is clear from it, it was a bit too sketchy for me.
Thanks to the publisher and Netgalley for providing me with a free copy of this book in exchange for an honest review!
I really liked the concept for this. A middle-aged woman, mother of three, descents into Hell in order to find her lost family in this modern take on Dante's inferno.
What I liked was the main character, she was a real person and not a likely main character. I also liked the concept, as I said, but I felt that in the execution is was sometimes a bit too crowded, and I felt less would have been more in this case. Virgil has been changed for William Blake, possibly because he wrote some works on heaven and hell, that I haven't read. Also, Agatha Christie alters as the guide. There are a lot of quotes from the works of people they encounter, but once again it was a bit too much.
Also, the artwork was not really my style. While I appreciate the desperateness that is clear from it, it was a bit too sketchy for me.
Thanks to the publisher and Netgalley for providing me with a free copy of this book in exchange for an honest review!
etienne02's review
2.0
I loved the concept of this book way more than the book itself. This branded itself as a retelling of Dante Inferno, which I want to read for years now but never read it yet... I wanted to like it and I like the fact that each issue is one of the Hell circles and all, but I would have like it better if it has been darker. I find it too «soft» even in the illustrations style, everything is too young and easy going to be a trip to Hell. Good concept but the execution failed unfortunately!
montgomerypierce's review
2.0
The largest issue I had with this graphic novel was that it was a premise, and little more. It was hard to find investment in Lynn's story—and part of the reason that I was drawn to this graphic novel in the first place was the promise of an emotional journey. After all, what's more evoking of heart-wrenching emotion than a mother literally plummeting through the circles of hell for her family?
Her Infernal Descent, however, doesn't deliver on this. It doesn't deliver on much, if I'm honest, aside from the general idea that this is a retelling of the Divine Comedy. We don't get much of a chance to connect with Lynn and empathize with her situation, especially with how much we're just told is supposed to be sad through interspersed sections of exposition rather than being shown through illustration. The story itself doesn't do a lot of work to give foundation to what should be an emotional, potentially philosophical, trek through what is arguably one of the most horrific places a person could find themselves, either. Instead, what I read was more a meandering stroll through a somewhat weird landscape with the occasional horror meant to shock but not really do much else for the story as a whole.
This could have easily been a five star read for me. I love the concept of classical retellings and seeing how authors can put a modern spin on tried and true stories. Her Infernal Descent, however, felt almost like the graphic novel equivalent of a first draft: lots of good ideas (the premise, layering in the stages of grief, character designs, the overall ideas represented in each circle of hell) with lukewarm execution. I did enjoy the art style and in general, what this graphic novel attempted to do, I just wish it had been better.
*Thanks to NetGalley for a free copy in exchange for an honest review.*
Her Infernal Descent, however, doesn't deliver on this. It doesn't deliver on much, if I'm honest, aside from the general idea that this is a retelling of the Divine Comedy. We don't get much of a chance to connect with Lynn and empathize with her situation, especially with how much we're just told is supposed to be sad through interspersed sections of exposition rather than being shown through illustration. The story itself doesn't do a lot of work to give foundation to what should be an emotional, potentially philosophical, trek through what is arguably one of the most horrific places a person could find themselves, either. Instead, what I read was more a meandering stroll through a somewhat weird landscape with the occasional horror meant to shock but not really do much else for the story as a whole.
This could have easily been a five star read for me. I love the concept of classical retellings and seeing how authors can put a modern spin on tried and true stories. Her Infernal Descent, however, felt almost like the graphic novel equivalent of a first draft: lots of good ideas (the premise, layering in the stages of grief, character designs, the overall ideas represented in each circle of hell) with lukewarm execution. I did enjoy the art style and in general, what this graphic novel attempted to do, I just wish it had been better.
*Thanks to NetGalley for a free copy in exchange for an honest review.*
More...