ninjamuse's review against another edition
adventurous
tense
medium-paced
- Plot- or character-driven? Plot
- Strong character development? Yes
- Loveable characters? Yes
- Diverse cast of characters? It's complicated
- Flaws of characters a main focus? No
3.5
Content Warnings
Moderate: Violence, Kidnapping, Blood, Gaslighting, Toxic relationship, Confinement, and Slavery
schnaucl's review
adventurous
challenging
dark
emotional
sad
fast-paced
- Plot- or character-driven? A mix
- Strong character development? Yes
- Loveable characters? Yes
- Diverse cast of characters? Yes
- Flaws of characters a main focus? No
4.75
I think this book and Be the Serpent were particularly strong entries in this series.
I can't say much about what happened without spoilers, so:
I assumed when I read the chapter in Be the Serpent that it was something Amadine had somehow done, so I was surprised to find that Tatania was behind it. Though of course, that makes sense, given how widespread it was, which wasn't apparent from the brief glimpse at the spell.
I'm not sure if this was what the seers would have warned against or not. It would have been a massive enough change to Faerie that I would say yes, except that possibility isn't really talked about.
It was a punch in the gut to see Jessica as a night haunt, made worse by the fact that Toby didn't know who she was. Interestingly, Toby didn't seem afraid of the night haunts, despite her lack of context for them. Just uncomfortable. I'm still sad the line of seers who used books to prophecy was wiped out (aside from the loss of Jessica herself). That was a cool power.
I feel like I'm missing something. The Luidaeg was very clear that the route was more important than the ride itself, but I never figured out why that was. Hopefully that's something that gets explained in The Innocent Sleep.
I get why there were the two time jumps, but I also found them frustrating, the second one in particular. It gets Toby through most of her pregnancy without showing her in danger, which might be upsetting to read about. But I feel like all the characters learned upsetting things about themselves and we should have seen more of the fallout from that. It's another thing I hope gets covered in The Innocent Sleep.
I don't really believe Tatania is gone for seven years. Especially given how slowly time advances in the books.
I won't blame Simon if he never leaves the undersea again, but it'll be too bad. I feel like we're just getting to know him.
I'll be interested to see how things go with August and Rayseline in the future.
I can't say much about what happened without spoilers, so:
I assumed when I read the chapter in Be the Serpent that it was something Amadine had somehow done, so I was surprised to find that Tatania was behind it. Though of course, that makes sense, given how widespread it was, which wasn't apparent from the brief glimpse at the spell.
I'm not sure if this was what the seers would have warned against or not. It would have been a massive enough change to Faerie that I would say yes, except that possibility isn't really talked about.
It was a punch in the gut to see Jessica as a night haunt, made worse by the fact that Toby didn't know who she was. Interestingly, Toby didn't seem afraid of the night haunts, despite her lack of context for them. Just uncomfortable. I'm still sad the line of seers who used books to prophecy was wiped out (aside from the loss of Jessica herself). That was a cool power.
I feel like I'm missing something. The Luidaeg was very clear that the route was more important than the ride itself, but I never figured out why that was. Hopefully that's something that gets explained in The Innocent Sleep.
I get why there were the two time jumps, but I also found them frustrating, the second one in particular. It gets Toby through most of her pregnancy without showing her in danger, which might be upsetting to read about. But I feel like all the characters learned upsetting things about themselves and we should have seen more of the fallout from that. It's another thing I hope gets covered in The Innocent Sleep.
I don't really believe Tatania is gone for seven years. Especially given how slowly time advances in the books.
I won't blame Simon if he never leaves the undersea again, but it'll be too bad. I feel like we're just getting to know him.
I'll be interested to see how things go with August and Rayseline in the future.
Content Warnings
Moderate: Bullying, Gaslighting, and Classism
Minor: Physical abuse, Fire/Fire injury, Injury/Injury detail, Child death, and Pregnancy
booksthatburn's review against another edition
adventurous
challenging
mysterious
reflective
medium-paced
- Plot- or character-driven? A mix
- Strong character development? Yes
- Loveable characters? It's complicated
- Diverse cast of characters? Yes
- Flaws of characters a main focus? It's complicated
5.0
I specifically enjoy books and series where nominally the same character has a transformation of mind, perception, and/or understanding of current events and their own history. While Toby has changed a great deal over the series so far, up until now most of the changes have been gradual (or, when extreme, temporary - e.g. her brief addiction to Goblin Fruit several books ago). SLEEP NO MORE, at long last, offers a very different version of October. This one is grateful to be her sister’s handmaiden, grew up with Simon Torquill as her father even though they share no blood, and knows of Amandine’s nature as Firstborn of the Dóchas Sidhe. October's memories have been rewritten, recontextualized, transformed to the point that many of the faces she ought to know best are alien to her. Entities who had been dealt with in earlier volumes are returned, rather, to her, they never left. Titania's vision of a perfect Faerie includes neither mixed bloods nor shapeshifters, let alone seers. Most immediately, it does not include the Cait Sidhe, and this version of October has never even met Tybalt.
Because October is unaware of her real previous history, much of the book follows a new storyline which was not present in any of the earlier volumes, but which in another way is a direct continuation of the previous books. There's often much backstory that could be explained, but if every bit of the story that got us here were detailed, not only would October run from the room at the news of just how often she'd gotten hurt before, but also it would bring this story to a grinding halt. Instead, what needs to be explained is summarized for October's benefit and to aid the reader's recall. It avoids belaboring any one point to those magicked to reject that understanding of reality.
SLEEP NO MORE is a direct continuation of the cliffhanger ending in BE THE SERPENT, and it addresses October's side of Titania's illusion. It is paired with the next book, THE INNOCENT SLEEP, which follows the same basic timeframe but from Tybalt's perspective. A few specific things are mentioned towards the end that will need to be handled in later books, but chief among them will be dealing with the aftermath of these events. So many people had their personalities changed and were bound by illusions which messed with their understanding of their own history, and the trauma inflicted here will have long-lasting repercussions.
"Candles and Starlight" is the novella included at the end of SLEEP NO MORE. It follows one of the characters who retained their memories during the illusion because they were too inconvenient to be easily rewritten or put in a new role. It showcases a character who has had a large influence but hasn't yet had much of a voice.
Because October is unaware of her real previous history, much of the book follows a new storyline which was not present in any of the earlier volumes, but which in another way is a direct continuation of the previous books. There's often much backstory that could be explained, but if every bit of the story that got us here were detailed, not only would October run from the room at the news of just how often she'd gotten hurt before, but also it would bring this story to a grinding halt. Instead, what needs to be explained is summarized for October's benefit and to aid the reader's recall. It avoids belaboring any one point to those magicked to reject that understanding of reality.
SLEEP NO MORE is a direct continuation of the cliffhanger ending in BE THE SERPENT, and it addresses October's side of Titania's illusion. It is paired with the next book, THE INNOCENT SLEEP, which follows the same basic timeframe but from Tybalt's perspective. A few specific things are mentioned towards the end that will need to be handled in later books, but chief among them will be dealing with the aftermath of these events. So many people had their personalities changed and were bound by illusions which messed with their understanding of their own history, and the trauma inflicted here will have long-lasting repercussions.
"Candles and Starlight" is the novella included at the end of SLEEP NO MORE. It follows one of the characters who retained their memories during the illusion because they were too inconvenient to be easily rewritten or put in a new role. It showcases a character who has had a large influence but hasn't yet had much of a voice.
Content Warnings
Graphic: Classism, Xenophobia, and Blood
Moderate: Gaslighting, Pregnancy, Kidnapping, Violence, Fire/Fire injury, Bullying, Murder, Emotional abuse, Injury/Injury detail, Confinement, and Death
Minor: Genocide, Mental illness, Child death, Death of parent, Self harm, Death, and Infidelity
“Candles and Starlight” - CW for confinement, kidnapping, body horror. Minor CW for torture, child abuse.
More...