lbatch's review against another edition

Go to review page

Uhhh hate to DNF this because I used a free-trial audible credit and it came highly recommended but there was enough fatpbobia (*lots*) and some questionable mental health metaphors and ethnocentric leanings in the first chapter and a half that I'm just not inclined to keep hanging out with this one. I know it's a business book so maybe I should lower my standards but woof. The format also seemed pretty anecdotal and reliant on a central metaphor without (as far as I could tell a very short way in, to be fair) strong practical applications. Very surprised, this was a #1 recommendation at the end of a book I just gave 5 stars and that was pretty justice-informed, so not sure what's up with that.

Expand filter menu Content Warnings

stephanieridiculous's review

Go to review page

medium-paced
 If I could give this negative stars I would.
This is a disgusting love letter to capitalism and patriarchy. The examples used to illustrate the authors points are rife with fatphobia, sexism, misogyny; with caviler attitudes about abuse and child rape.

I'm not being hyperbolic, either. Literal child sexual slavery was framed as a quirky problem to solve in order to decrease HIV/AIDS numbers, with no acknowledgement that young girls shouldn't be prostituting themselves in order to survive, regardless of if HIV/AIDs is a risk factor or not. Every story has a hero, and often that hero is a "noble white person out to save the communities of color that just couldn't fix things themselves."

The few nuggets of useful information are absolutely not worth the garbage heap of overwriting that exalts some of the most distrusting aspects of American society.
(I had to read this for work, I would have rage quite after the first few chapters of enforcing toxic diet culture if I could have.) 

Expand filter menu Content Warnings
More...