jeremy_bearimy's review against another edition

Go to review page

informative

2.0

Repeats the advice throughout the book to lose weight without acknowledging concerns raised by folks like Aubrey Gordon about how low-quality research is used to justify fatphobic messages, and the impacts of fatphobia on wellbeing. 

I also wish she’d discussed issues related to racial and other socioeconomic inequities, like different levels of access to health care or unprocessed foods.

With those major caveats, I did think there was helpful info for people who have access to the resources (time, money, energy…) needed to act on it.

Expand filter menu Content Warnings

kit_steitz's review against another edition

Go to review page

This books is written for cis women. If you are a cis woman, you should be fine here (except for the fatphobia). There are a few brief mentions of the rest of us going through menopause, but really only for the author to point out that there isn't enough research for us. The rest of what I read approaches menopause from a binary and deeply second wave perspective that only superficially engages with intersectional Identities and how they are affected by social/physical perspectives. Her chapter and discussions of fat are incredibly triggering and clearly demonstrate that she has not bothered to engage in weight neutral advocacy and didn't consult anybody within the HAES movement. I was unable to continue and keep my inner peace.

Expand filter menu Content Warnings