kurt's review against another edition
4.0
Definitely better than the first book! Much more action and some really great battle and fight scenes. Of course, not on the scale of John Gwynne, but really good stuff.
My problem with this series though is, I'm not too much of a fan of the magic system. It's definitely unique, but not really what I'm looking for. Maybe I'm just such a traditional fantasy kind of guy, with dragons and swords, and this isn't really in that realm, at least not yet. There are some very interesting characters in this book though, and that helped out a lot!
I will read the next book and make a decision as to whether I want to keep going with this series. It's not bad at all, really, it is quite great... just not what I'm really looking for.
My problem with this series though is, I'm not too much of a fan of the magic system. It's definitely unique, but not really what I'm looking for. Maybe I'm just such a traditional fantasy kind of guy, with dragons and swords, and this isn't really in that realm, at least not yet. There are some very interesting characters in this book though, and that helped out a lot!
I will read the next book and make a decision as to whether I want to keep going with this series. It's not bad at all, really, it is quite great... just not what I'm really looking for.
publius's review against another edition
3.0
Raj Ahtan has fled from Gaborn Val Orden, the prophesied and ascendant Earth King. Tricked on the field of battle by a ruse, Ahtan is far from vanquished. Bolstered by the strength, speed, stamina, charisma, and beauty of thousands of men, he moves to strike at where Gaborn is weakest, to tear down the kingdoms of Rofehaven from within. But while Ahtan works to lure Gaborn into a trap, Gaborn realizes a greater enemy is threatening, and designs a plan that he hopes will ally Ahtan with him against this foe.
Taking place over the course of just a few days, [b:Brotherhood of the Wolf|144112|Brotherhood of the Wolf (Runelords, #2)|David Farland|https://d.gr-assets.com/books/1400630733s/144112.jpg|1166994] picks up right where [b:The Sum of All Men|144127|The Sum of All Men (Runelords #1)|David Farland|https://d.gr-assets.com/books/1388196460s/144127.jpg|139049] left off without breaking stride. Gaborn is grappling with the ramifications of becoming the Earth King, as well as his marriage to Iome Sylvarresta, the daughter of the late King Jas Laren Sylvarresta. Determined not to use forcibles to increase his strength and power, Gaborn finds himself at an immediate disadvantage to Ahtan's super human abilities, not to mention vulnerable to any who does not share his qualms.
It is an ongoing source of dissonance for Gaborn: he sees the slavery and debilitation caused when ever one man gives his abilities to another, but is faced with an enemy that is prepared to end not just humanity but all life on the earth. Should he accept the endowments of other men to become strong enough for the coming battle, or should he rely on his new found abilities as the Earth King? With the selection by the Earth, though, comes responsibility above those of other men, and Gaborn must weigh the future of all men as he makes his decisions.
With how short a time as passes during the novel, events unfold at a breakneck pace. If only Farland would move his text as fast. Not atypical for an epic fantasy, Brotherhood clocks in at nearly 700 pages. Frequently I found myself wondering if a few of those pages weren't unnecessary to the story.
The result is that Farland develops his characters more than might otherwise be possible in such a short period of time. The length of the novel lends itself to more viewpoints than a shorter story might allow, and shows the reader a broader vision of the events unfolding. While the story never drags--per se--a faster paced story might have spent less time with each view point.
If The Sum of All Men was intended to introduce the main protagonist and antagonist of The Runelords series, then Brotherhood feels like a pulling back of the curtain. The threat to Rofehaven and the entire world is far greater than anything introduced in The Sum of All Men, and Farland takes advantage of the opportunity to hint at the scope of his series by introducing side plots, new abilities to what initially appeared to be small characters, and expanding his system of magic beyond the initial forcibles/endowments magic introduced in the first book.
Picking up a thick novel is always a risky endeavor. The time investment is long, and the pay-off may be a long time in coming. In the end, Farland provides, however, delivering a denouement that satisfies his promises, if not perfectly, at least satisfactorily. It's a worthy successor to The Sum of All Men and continuation of The Runelords' series. I ran into Farland at the Salt Lake FanXperience in April and picked up [b:Wizardborn|144109|Wizardborn (Runelords, #3)|David Farland|https://d.gr-assets.com/books/1388210779s/144109.jpg|1270521] from him there. I look forward to following where he takes Gaborn, Iome, Ahtan, and the rest of his growing cast next.
Taking place over the course of just a few days, [b:Brotherhood of the Wolf|144112|Brotherhood of the Wolf (Runelords, #2)|David Farland|https://d.gr-assets.com/books/1400630733s/144112.jpg|1166994] picks up right where [b:The Sum of All Men|144127|The Sum of All Men (Runelords #1)|David Farland|https://d.gr-assets.com/books/1388196460s/144127.jpg|139049] left off without breaking stride. Gaborn is grappling with the ramifications of becoming the Earth King, as well as his marriage to Iome Sylvarresta, the daughter of the late King Jas Laren Sylvarresta. Determined not to use forcibles to increase his strength and power, Gaborn finds himself at an immediate disadvantage to Ahtan's super human abilities, not to mention vulnerable to any who does not share his qualms.
It is an ongoing source of dissonance for Gaborn: he sees the slavery and debilitation caused when ever one man gives his abilities to another, but is faced with an enemy that is prepared to end not just humanity but all life on the earth. Should he accept the endowments of other men to become strong enough for the coming battle, or should he rely on his new found abilities as the Earth King? With the selection by the Earth, though, comes responsibility above those of other men, and Gaborn must weigh the future of all men as he makes his decisions.
With how short a time as passes during the novel, events unfold at a breakneck pace. If only Farland would move his text as fast. Not atypical for an epic fantasy, Brotherhood clocks in at nearly 700 pages. Frequently I found myself wondering if a few of those pages weren't unnecessary to the story.
The result is that Farland develops his characters more than might otherwise be possible in such a short period of time. The length of the novel lends itself to more viewpoints than a shorter story might allow, and shows the reader a broader vision of the events unfolding. While the story never drags--per se--a faster paced story might have spent less time with each view point.
If The Sum of All Men was intended to introduce the main protagonist and antagonist of The Runelords series, then Brotherhood feels like a pulling back of the curtain. The threat to Rofehaven and the entire world is far greater than anything introduced in The Sum of All Men, and Farland takes advantage of the opportunity to hint at the scope of his series by introducing side plots, new abilities to what initially appeared to be small characters, and expanding his system of magic beyond the initial forcibles/endowments magic introduced in the first book.
Picking up a thick novel is always a risky endeavor. The time investment is long, and the pay-off may be a long time in coming. In the end, Farland provides, however, delivering a denouement that satisfies his promises, if not perfectly, at least satisfactorily. It's a worthy successor to The Sum of All Men and continuation of The Runelords' series. I ran into Farland at the Salt Lake FanXperience in April and picked up [b:Wizardborn|144109|Wizardborn (Runelords, #3)|David Farland|https://d.gr-assets.com/books/1388210779s/144109.jpg|1270521] from him there. I look forward to following where he takes Gaborn, Iome, Ahtan, and the rest of his growing cast next.
alfierose66's review against another edition
4.0
Really loved this one. I love the badass women in it and the men who are written with depth of character. Gaborn is a bit whiny but he's also going in blind with everything around him so I can sort of understand that, just makes him not my favourite POV.
trsclee's review against another edition
adventurous
dark
mysterious
tense
medium-paced
- Plot- or character-driven? Character
- Strong character development? Yes
- Loveable characters? Yes
- Diverse cast of characters? Yes
- Flaws of characters a main focus? No
5.0
storyphoria's review against another edition
4.0
Listen or Read the full review at:
https://storyphoria.substack.com/p/brotherhood-of-the-wolf-rise-up-earth
Book two of an epic fantasy series that can feel a bit cliche or "tropey", but is pure epic fantasy fun. We see Farland begin to expand his lush world and the threats within continue to grow as we become more entangled with our characters.
It's pure, popcorn blockbuster style fantasy fun and it has been a delightful revisit to this series.
https://storyphoria.substack.com/p/brotherhood-of-the-wolf-rise-up-earth
Book two of an epic fantasy series that can feel a bit cliche or "tropey", but is pure epic fantasy fun. We see Farland begin to expand his lush world and the threats within continue to grow as we become more entangled with our characters.
It's pure, popcorn blockbuster style fantasy fun and it has been a delightful revisit to this series.
storyphoria's review
4.0
Listen or Read the full review at:
https://storyphoria.substack.com/p/brotherhood-of-the-wolf-rise-up-earth
Book two of an epic fantasy series that can feel a bit cliche or "tropey", but is pure epic fantasy fun. We see Farland begin to expand his lush world and the threats within continue to grow as we become more entangled with our characters.
It's pure, popcorn blockbuster style fantasy fun and it has been a delightful revisit to this series.
https://storyphoria.substack.com/p/brotherhood-of-the-wolf-rise-up-earth
Book two of an epic fantasy series that can feel a bit cliche or "tropey", but is pure epic fantasy fun. We see Farland begin to expand his lush world and the threats within continue to grow as we become more entangled with our characters.
It's pure, popcorn blockbuster style fantasy fun and it has been a delightful revisit to this series.
arrr's review against another edition
2.0
This is one of those fantasy books that's super frustrating. The story is interesting and I like the universe. The type of magic is new and is a unique take on classism and environmentalism. I like the use of runes and earth air fire water magic. There are a bunch of great female characters... But then they're also sexually threatened harassed and attacked, and one of the women is naked all the time and is a sort of newborn blank slate (which would be fine, is great even when she's in the company of a little girl character, if there weren't so many asshole leering dudes describing her body) . Most of the characters are men and it would barely pass the Bechdel test. Characters promote problematic wartime ideas about masculinity. And of course, the enemy is a brown dude from a place meant to sound like India. There are just too many gross boring tropes. I don't plan to continue with this series.
vaderbird's review against another edition
4.0
5 star - Perfect
4 star - i would recommend
3 star - good
2 star - struggled to complete
1 star - could not finish
4 star - i would recommend
3 star - good
2 star - struggled to complete
1 star - could not finish
kknudsen3's review against another edition
2.0
I really only have this on in the background when I have run out of other audio books to listen to so this book is probably better than I think it is I just am only half paying attention.