Scan barcode
andrew_j_r's review against another edition
2.0
I confess that I was slightly underwhelmed by this one.
I really enjoyed the last three books, they made up a trilogy of tales concerning Blofeld. What is irritating about this one is that the story I really wanted to read about was what happened between this book and the last.
This starts with a brainwashed Bond attempting to kill M. I would’ve liked to have seen the brainwashing process, and the book ending with this attempt. What we actually got was the attempt, followed by a very quick recovery that we don’t even get to see in which he is cured, then put on a dangerous mission that will prove whether he is still the man he needs to be. It’s very wishy-washy and the whole brainwashing thing was glossed over far too quickly.
We then get a fairly average story In which Bond returns to Jamaica, somewhere we have seen so many times before in these books it kind of feels like the writer couldn’t be bothered to research anything and just used a locale he already knew well. The story is not that exciting and the end is predictable. It is a shame that this is the final novel in the series, I’m sure the short stories that follow it are fine and I will read them, but as the final full novel it ended with a whimper rather than a bang. Rather disappointing.
jon288's review against another edition
4.0
(Re-read). One of the few where I think the film may have improved on it (with the exceptions of some dated scenes), but maybe that's just Christopher Lee. A relatively low key mission, but a good final confrontation and interesting beginning with a brainwashed Bond
duparker's review against another edition
4.0
Fun, and very different from the last Bond I read. I like the more modern feel to be storytelling, and the local was cool. Haven't seen this movie in a long time but I suspect it's vastly different overall a really enjoyable read with a great flow and fun tone.
historyrebel's review against another edition
3.0
I've heard some people think Fleming died before he could really revise this book. I don't know if it's true, but it does feel plausible. It's a decent story. There are some good, tense moments, but the story also feels very rough at times. The beginning of the book is better than the rest.
stuporfly's review against another edition
2.0
The last of Ian Fleming's original James Bond novels is one of his least successful, with the author having died before the editorial process was completed. Would it have been a more enjoyable book had he lived long enough to see it to completion? I'm not convinced.
The Man With the Golden Gun is one of the most incongruous of the Bond series, picking up where its predecessor left off, with the secret agent having been brainwashed by the Soviet secret service to kill the head of the British secret service, known as M. The assassination attempt is thwarted in the moment, and Bond is soon returned to his sour, alcoholic, womanizing self. Bond is then tasked with the job of killing Francisco "Pistols" Scaramanga, who as the title suggests, has a golden gun. Though Scaramanga has killed British secret agents, he seems less the sort of megalomaniacal villain Bond is normally set against, and is instead sort of a hitman. Which is fine, I guess, except it doesn't really work.
For the second time in Fleming's original works, Bond is given the job by a bad guy of taking notes at a meeting of gangsters. It didn't make much sense when it happened in Goldfinger, and it doesn't make much sense here. But not much makes sense here anyway. As a farewell to the original James Bond series, it falls flat. It's not a worthy goodbye, which is partly why I've undertaken the self-appointed task of reading the James Bond timeline following roughly from 1950-69, including books written by other authors (please see my Goodreads blog for further information).
I started reading the series on the page, but a cross-country drive pushed me over into audiobooks. Ordinarily that worked out beautifully, especially as the Fleming estate in 2014 enlisted numerous British actors to read a book each. David Tennant was particularly good, though there were others as well. Kenneth Branagh narrated The Man With the Golden Gun, which was something of a mixed bag, primarily when it came to his interpretation of Scaramanga. In the oft-reviled film adaptation, Scaramanga is played by Christopher Lee with a sort of homicidal aristocratic voice. Here, Branagh Americanizes Scaramanga's voice, and he just sounds like a lazy goon.
Though this is the last of the Fleming works in the timeline (including the short story collections), there are three novels which follow. For more on those, I'll again refer you to my blog, and I will also be reviewing those separately as well.
The Man With the Golden Gun is one of the most incongruous of the Bond series, picking up where its predecessor left off, with the secret agent having been brainwashed by the Soviet secret service to kill the head of the British secret service, known as M. The assassination attempt is thwarted in the moment, and Bond is soon returned to his sour, alcoholic, womanizing self. Bond is then tasked with the job of killing Francisco "Pistols" Scaramanga, who as the title suggests, has a golden gun. Though Scaramanga has killed British secret agents, he seems less the sort of megalomaniacal villain Bond is normally set against, and is instead sort of a hitman. Which is fine, I guess, except it doesn't really work.
For the second time in Fleming's original works, Bond is given the job by a bad guy of taking notes at a meeting of gangsters. It didn't make much sense when it happened in Goldfinger, and it doesn't make much sense here. But not much makes sense here anyway. As a farewell to the original James Bond series, it falls flat. It's not a worthy goodbye, which is partly why I've undertaken the self-appointed task of reading the James Bond timeline following roughly from 1950-69, including books written by other authors (please see my Goodreads blog for further information).
I started reading the series on the page, but a cross-country drive pushed me over into audiobooks. Ordinarily that worked out beautifully, especially as the Fleming estate in 2014 enlisted numerous British actors to read a book each. David Tennant was particularly good, though there were others as well. Kenneth Branagh narrated The Man With the Golden Gun, which was something of a mixed bag, primarily when it came to his interpretation of Scaramanga. In the oft-reviled film adaptation, Scaramanga is played by Christopher Lee with a sort of homicidal aristocratic voice. Here, Branagh Americanizes Scaramanga's voice, and he just sounds like a lazy goon.
Though this is the last of the Fleming works in the timeline (including the short story collections), there are three novels which follow. For more on those, I'll again refer you to my blog, and I will also be reviewing those separately as well.
ultimatumman's review against another edition
3.0
Simple novel but fun. Bond gets to get back into service after a year of being "dead". Fun to see Bond get to go undercover to hunt down Scaramanga. Interesting to see what things came from the book and into the movie and what things were completely different.(which were many)
andrewgraphics's review against another edition
2.0
This final James Bond novel was ultimately a let down: Bond is brainwashed by the KGB to kill M, but Bond is knocked out just in time and M decides to send him off on an extremely difficult mission to get him back on track; all of this in the first chapter. The rest of the book takes place in Jamaica, where Bond is to track down and kill a contract assassin, who it turns out is involved in a KGB plot to destabilize the region. Throughout the book hardly a mention is made of Bond's time being brainwashed, how he is doing since he was "cured", and so on.
However, Fleming died in the middle of the process: the first draft of the book was done and edited, but he added a lot of detail to his books after that point; so I'll forgive him this.
However, Fleming died in the middle of the process: the first draft of the book was done and edited, but he added a lot of detail to his books after that point; so I'll forgive him this.
homoerotisch's review against another edition
1.0
vraag me niet hoe fleming het voor elkaar krijgt om "cultureel icoon met gadgets die vooral cool en sexy is en schiet" saai weet te maken, maar het is 'm wel gelukt