titanic's review against another edition
dark
mysterious
fast-paced
- Plot- or character-driven? Plot
- Strong character development? No
- Loveable characters? Yes
- Diverse cast of characters? Yes
- Flaws of characters a main focus? No
3.25
honestly? i loved oxel
james7634's review
mysterious
sad
medium-paced
- Plot- or character-driven? Plot
- Strong character development? No
- Loveable characters? It's complicated
- Diverse cast of characters? It's complicated
- Flaws of characters a main focus? Yes
3.25
I liked the green river killer by Case. Two friends kill themselves and a grieving mother hires her ex boyfriend to investigate.
The story is good. But so bizarre. The boy mystery is they feel guilty for a hunting accident and not calling a hospital. The presumed dead man is in fact not dead then eaten by a bear. Kids off themselves.
The detective is noir which is fun but blah. He has a hormone defect which makes him grow abnormally large. His ex gf has an unhappy marriage and the detective wants to make her happy but overall fails.
It’s a good noir detective story but didn’t feel to connected
The story is good. But so bizarre. The boy mystery is they feel guilty for a hunting accident and not calling a hospital. The presumed dead man is in fact not dead then eaten by a bear. Kids off themselves.
The detective is noir which is fun but blah. He has a hormone defect which makes him grow abnormally large. His ex gf has an unhappy marriage and the detective wants to make her happy but overall fails.
It’s a good noir detective story but didn’t feel to connected
wxrldwalker's review
4.0
This graphic novel was very beautifully done! The plot, dialogue, characters and colours! wow.
An amazing experience. I just wish it was longer!
An amazing experience. I just wish it was longer!
evildr3ad's review
dark
mysterious
fast-paced
- Plot- or character-driven? Character
- Strong character development? It's complicated
- Loveable characters? No
- Diverse cast of characters? No
- Flaws of characters a main focus? It's complicated
2.5
Content Warnings
Graphic: Suicide and Death
ltg584's review
4.0
Here I go again, reviewing yet another graphic novel. Yup. I'm a fan. And while I do like a lot of different comics, I am an especially huge Dark Horse fan! How can I not be?! The comics hold a certain dark mystery, and The Creep is no exception.
I have to start out with our protagonist, Oxel Karnh, as he is not your typical detective. (I apologize if I'm getting the last name wrong here. It isn't used often in the story, and I only had a digital copy. The quality degrades when I try to zoom in and read it) I object a little to the synopsis describing him as having a "freakish appearance". He suffers from acromegaly, which is an excess of growth hormone. There are many manifestations of the deformity, but in this case, Oxel is large, and his face and hands are a different proportion than most people would be used to. Hardly what I would call "freakish", though Oxel's self esteem has clearly been affected by the public's treatment of him. Despite all of this, or maybe because of it, he has become a great detective.
The plot is obviously dark, as Oxel investigates a suicide, with no apparent motive. Oxel gets a letter from an ex-girlfriend, beside herself with grief at the loss of her son. She has nowhere else to turn, since the police don't think it warrants investigation. Oxel, however, decides to help. While the dialogue, itself, is solid, the plot contains a few holes. On the plus side, I wasn't aware of them at all while reading. I was completely drawn into the story, and it wasn't until afterwards that I started to question how the story was built.
The artwork is where I truly felt pulled forward. Jonathan Case presents some fabulous work, but there are also the individual issue covers by guest artists. First off, Case's work is pretty standard on the most part. What got me were the past scenes, where the drawings felt more sketched. Here is where the true artistry was displayed. Although the lines were less defined, I felt like there was a clear emotion being conveyed.
For the graphic novel aficionado, this volume contains a series of artwork at the back. I only wish I had my hands on a hard copy, so that I could bask in their glory. As it was, I am thankful to Netgalley for providing me with the digital copy. Certainly better than having to wait until the release date in May!
I have to start out with our protagonist, Oxel Karnh, as he is not your typical detective. (I apologize if I'm getting the last name wrong here. It isn't used often in the story, and I only had a digital copy. The quality degrades when I try to zoom in and read it) I object a little to the synopsis describing him as having a "freakish appearance". He suffers from acromegaly, which is an excess of growth hormone. There are many manifestations of the deformity, but in this case, Oxel is large, and his face and hands are a different proportion than most people would be used to. Hardly what I would call "freakish", though Oxel's self esteem has clearly been affected by the public's treatment of him. Despite all of this, or maybe because of it, he has become a great detective.
The plot is obviously dark, as Oxel investigates a suicide, with no apparent motive. Oxel gets a letter from an ex-girlfriend, beside herself with grief at the loss of her son. She has nowhere else to turn, since the police don't think it warrants investigation. Oxel, however, decides to help. While the dialogue, itself, is solid, the plot contains a few holes. On the plus side, I wasn't aware of them at all while reading. I was completely drawn into the story, and it wasn't until afterwards that I started to question how the story was built.
The artwork is where I truly felt pulled forward. Jonathan Case presents some fabulous work, but there are also the individual issue covers by guest artists. First off, Case's work is pretty standard on the most part. What got me were the past scenes, where the drawings felt more sketched. Here is where the true artistry was displayed. Although the lines were less defined, I felt like there was a clear emotion being conveyed.
For the graphic novel aficionado, this volume contains a series of artwork at the back. I only wish I had my hands on a hard copy, so that I could bask in their glory. As it was, I am thankful to Netgalley for providing me with the digital copy. Certainly better than having to wait until the release date in May!
adubrow's review
3.0
Not really what I expected and a bit too open-ended for my tastes. But a quick read with an unique main character with familiar/relatable problems dealing with a great deal of crazy.
francomega's review
3.0
Good small story (plus interesting art) about a private detective investigating the double suicide of teen best friends. Nice twist climax, though the real strength was the sympathetic main character.
Bonus: I learned what acromegaly is.
Bonus: I learned what acromegaly is.
More...