achaperonwrites's review against another edition
5.0
“Choices are never easy. There are good and bad options, but the most dangerous is to not make any choice at all.”
—
—
sri_savita's review against another edition
Bold choice to completely undo everything readers had to invest in while reading Book 1. Also shit got dark at the end. I'm not in the intended audience for this book -- it's not for me and I'll leave it at that. I remember liking Book 1, but I was just getting back into reading then and hadn't really found my favorite genres/authors yet.
kimdw's review against another edition
4.0
I was a bit bummed out that, in this book, I didn't get to see much of the characters I fell in love with in the first book. I especially missed Harper!! But I definitely fell in love with the characters in this book too. I did not expect the ending!! I'm excited for whenever book 3 will be released!
minxtee's review against another edition
adventurous
lighthearted
relaxing
medium-paced
- Plot- or character-driven? A mix
- Strong character development? Yes
- Loveable characters? Yes
- Diverse cast of characters? Yes
- Flaws of characters a main focus? Yes
4.0
lemnoodle's review against another edition
3.0
THIS BOOK WAS AN EMOTIONAL ROLLERCOASTER.
AAH Kimmerer, how you never fail to disappoint me. The writing was as wonderful as I expected, the description, the plot, everything was great. I really admire Kimmerer’s vocab and writing style. It’s so flowy and nice. The characters were well developed too even though I might now have liked some of their motives.
Talking about the story itself, the start was great obviously. We got some noice Harper/ Rhen content yayy. But then came Grey who I didn’t really mind at the beginning but around 30% into the book I was getting seriously pissed at him ugh.
Also, I hate Lia Mara. She was ok when she first appeared but THEN. I hated how she continuously judged Rhen.
Most of the reviews of this book that I have read are all about fangirling over Grey but for me….no, he merely made me angry.
I NEED MORE RHEN RHEN IS GREAT I LOVVE RHEN I cant believe I have to wait like a year for more Rhen content ughhhhhhh Grey can fall in a ditch and die but nobody touches my precious Rhen… *heart eyes*
ok, Imma head out and wait for an year till the next book comes out. *sigh*
AAH Kimmerer, how you never fail to disappoint me. The writing was as wonderful as I expected, the description, the plot, everything was great. I really admire Kimmerer’s vocab and writing style. It’s so flowy and nice. The characters were well developed too even though I might now have liked some of their motives.
Talking about the story itself, the start was great obviously. We got some noice Harper/ Rhen content yayy. But then came Grey who I didn’t really mind at the beginning but around 30% into the book I was getting seriously pissed at him ugh.
Also, I hate Lia Mara. She was ok when she first appeared but THEN. I hated how she continuously judged Rhen.
Spoiler
I mean yeah she had a bad encounter with him, he captured her blah blah but since I know Rhen’s story and understand why he thought she was lying when she came back alone and tried to negotiate, I was really frustrated by her.Spoiler
Most of the reviews of this book that I have read are all about fangirling over Grey but for me….no, he merely made me angry.
Spoiler
How his “loyalty” to Rhen during his curse was just because of his oath. How as soon as he was released from it he became a rebel. Fine. He was the true heir. And he acted like a total jerk hiding it from Rhen and then making a fuss when Tycho was flogged as well. Which was cruel on Rhen’s side. BUT. Grey should have understood.Spoiler
He spent 300+ seasons witnessing a magesmith torture Rhen and knew how much he feared them and why he would go to such extents to find the identity of the true heir who ,I might add, had magesmith blood in him and might just turn out to be as evil as Lilith. But noooo, Grey had to pretend to be the victim and kill me while I read about his shitty personality and actions. BUt no, it doesn’t stop there. We’re gonna have a grand war between Rhen and Grey. Yayy soo excited for it I hope you get shot in the head, Grey. Fucking bastard ugh.I NEED MORE RHEN RHEN IS GREAT I LOVVE RHEN I cant believe I have to wait like a year for more Rhen content ughhhhhhh Grey can fall in a ditch and die but nobody touches my precious Rhen… *heart eyes*
ok, Imma head out and wait for an year till the next book comes out. *sigh*
juliterario's review against another edition
2.0
Debo decir que tenía mis dudas con leer la secuela de Una Maldición Oscura y Solitaria, pero me aventuré con este libro de todos modos. No había oído muchas cosas buenas que digamos de A Heart So Fierce and Broken, y ahora mismo no sé si darle 2 o 3 estrellas a la última novela de Brigid Kemmerer :( Sin duda me siento decepcionada con lo que pasó con esta historia :/
“Ah yes, the most dangerous person at the party is always the girl sitting alone with a book.”
Todavía no me decido qué puntuación darle a esta novela. Algo que sin duda me enojó a montones es que lxs protagonistas de la novela anterior ya no son los personajes principales en este libro. En A Heart So Fierce and Broken tenemos dos protagonistas nuevos que, aunque habían aparecido antes como personajes secundarios, no me interesaban en lo personal. En serio, esto a mí me molestó muchísimo, ya que no soy fan de cuando cambian a los protagonistas de manera tan deliberada. No sé, me decepcionó mucho. Después, mis problemas con esta novela fueron los mismos que tuve con el libro anterior de Kemmerer: la escritura demasiado simple y poco descriptiva, personajes poco desarrollados y poco diálogo... etc. No sé, demasiadas cosas de este libro me decepcionaron, y no tengo casi nada bueno que atribuirle :( Ojalá hubiera disfrutado más A Heart So Fierce and Broken, pero bueno :/
“This one is for you, my dear reader. Look in the mirror. You’re a cursebreaker. You’re strong. You’re amazing. You are changing the world by just being in it. And I am so very proud of you.”
“Ah yes, the most dangerous person at the party is always the girl sitting alone with a book.”
Todavía no me decido qué puntuación darle a esta novela. Algo que sin duda me enojó a montones es que lxs protagonistas de la novela anterior ya no son los personajes principales en este libro. En A Heart So Fierce and Broken tenemos dos protagonistas nuevos que, aunque habían aparecido antes como personajes secundarios, no me interesaban en lo personal. En serio, esto a mí me molestó muchísimo, ya que no soy fan de cuando cambian a los protagonistas de manera tan deliberada. No sé, me decepcionó mucho. Después, mis problemas con esta novela fueron los mismos que tuve con el libro anterior de Kemmerer: la escritura demasiado simple y poco descriptiva, personajes poco desarrollados y poco diálogo... etc. No sé, demasiadas cosas de este libro me decepcionaron, y no tengo casi nada bueno que atribuirle :( Ojalá hubiera disfrutado más A Heart So Fierce and Broken, pero bueno :/
“This one is for you, my dear reader. Look in the mirror. You’re a cursebreaker. You’re strong. You’re amazing. You are changing the world by just being in it. And I am so very proud of you.”
__gmike's review against another edition
3.0
A good book if you view it as a standalone, but a really disappointing sequel that went in a completely different direction than the first book.
disturbedtwistedtales's review against another edition
5.0
Brilliant! I didn't want it to end and I have to wait until January for the next part
cvkirkpatrick's review against another edition
adventurous
emotional
hopeful
tense
medium-paced
- Plot- or character-driven? A mix
- Strong character development? Yes
- Loveable characters? Yes
- Diverse cast of characters? Yes
- Flaws of characters a main focus? No
4.0
jadeisgreen's review against another edition
It became clear pretty quickly that this was would be from different perspectives than the previous book and I honestly couldn’t find it in myself to be interested. Maybe another time when there aren’t other books I’m more eager to read.