brandonisaacson416's review against another edition
3.0
Note: Rating based on content as literature. If I was simply rating this as a new American Haggadah, I would give it a 5. I love the ways they make it more clear, accessible and visual.
sophronisba's review against another edition
3.0
This is a beautiful book, and since Nathan Englander translated it, you know that it must be beautifully written. When I opened it for the first time, I wished I had ordered more than one copy, so I could use it at our seder this year.
But after I read it, I decided that I am just as happy with the current Haggadah, one I assembled by taking the parts I liked best from half-a-dozen sources. Yes, probably violating all sorts of copyright laws, but I'm not trying to sell it or pass it off as my work, so I think I'm okay. (I would argue it falls under Fair Use.)
Here's what I like about it: did I mention that it's beautiful? It's really, really beautiful. But here's what I don't like about it: no gender-neutral language, and no mention of alternative traditions such as the Miriam's Cup (which has been a part of our seder for many years). These omissions make the Haggadah feel dated. I like to strike a balance between tradition and modernity, and I don't think this haggadah does that quite. There are also no transliterations, which would really be a deal-breaker for us since we often invite non-Jewish friends to our seder and we want them to be comfortable and feel included.
Having said that, there are many passages I like and I think I will incorporate parts of it into my crazy quilt of a Haggadah.
But after I read it, I decided that I am just as happy with the current Haggadah, one I assembled by taking the parts I liked best from half-a-dozen sources. Yes, probably violating all sorts of copyright laws, but I'm not trying to sell it or pass it off as my work, so I think I'm okay. (I would argue it falls under Fair Use.)
Here's what I like about it: did I mention that it's beautiful? It's really, really beautiful. But here's what I don't like about it: no gender-neutral language, and no mention of alternative traditions such as the Miriam's Cup (which has been a part of our seder for many years). These omissions make the Haggadah feel dated. I like to strike a balance between tradition and modernity, and I don't think this haggadah does that quite. There are also no transliterations, which would really be a deal-breaker for us since we often invite non-Jewish friends to our seder and we want them to be comfortable and feel included.
Having said that, there are many passages I like and I think I will incorporate parts of it into my crazy quilt of a Haggadah.
craftyhilary's review against another edition
3.0
Ok, but I expected more from it. Not planning on purchasing to supplement future seders.
More...