muddypuddle's review against another edition
4.0
Plot, characters, setting. It's the setting that was most wonderful for me in this fairly grizzly mystery - in and around and south of the streets and mountains I know so well - from the Rincon foothills of Tucson to Patagonia and Nogales, even the lonely close-to-the-border ghosts towns where I snooped when I first arrived in this city-in-the-desert. (I never realized the danger I might be in until a few years later, but that's another story!) The protagonist is okay, quite smart and real, making occasional choices that might be a bit questionable, which makes her even more believable. The plot, although interesting, is difficult to totally believe, since I don't think Ms. Black ever really gave enough information about why this family did what they did - all as adult siblings. I can understand one of them, and maybe two, but I needed more proof as to how the other two might have been motivated to participate in some of the things they took part in. All in all I enjoyed its many facets, its many personalities, and its many stops along the route!
prpltrtl946's review against another edition
4.0
Strange good mystery
These characters are so well rounded you can love them and hate the at the same time. Despicable bad guys.
These characters are so well rounded you can love them and hate the at the same time. Despicable bad guys.
More...