skylarkblue1's review against another edition
dark
emotional
mysterious
reflective
sad
tense
slow-paced
- Plot- or character-driven? A mix
- Strong character development? Yes
- Loveable characters? Yes
- Diverse cast of characters? Yes
- Flaws of characters a main focus? Yes
3.5
Oh this book was one hell of a ride. It might be slow, but it doesn't feel like it. It wasn't until I finished the book that I realised not much *actually* happens, it is mainly focused on the characters but the plot is so strong throughout and constant that it doesn't need to have the full spotlight.
The plot is quite simple, but steeped in mystery. Mysterious doors open across the world, followed by holograms touting the end of the world in 6 months - and portray themselves as humanity's saviour. Step through the doors, be saved, and integrate into their alternate universe world. Are they telling the truth?
I would say the story overall is about mental health - at least book 1 is. The main character's severe anxiety and med dependency is the constant talking point but also handled really well in my opinion and was pretty realistic. I liked how therapy was approached, it didn't demonise it or even make out like it cures all and is perfect for everyone.
The mystery is quite strong, I love how it was strung along right up until the fantastic ending. The cliffhanger is a strong one, but it's such an explosive ending that I don't really mind too much.
The sci-fi as well is pretty light, mainly just the futuristic holographic doors that introduces that side of things. It is a book about humanity and survival.
It most certainly has it's issues though. It really needed another proofreader or 2, there's a ton of very obvious and basic typos and issues throughout it - something incredibly surprising for a re-print of a 2016 book... There's also a slight under-thread of the "magical cure" trope (but this does actually play into themes even if not directly addressed imo) and one instance of outing another person without their permission is a good thing? Someone refusing to out another person without permission is portrayed as a bad thing and that was just... kinda uncomfortable honestly. The queer rep is nice, that moment was not. It's also not challenged, it happens, it's made out to be a bad thing and then the characters continue.
I would still recommend it though. This might be my lowest rated recommended book, but honestly I think the story and themes are strong enough to make it an enjoyable and gripping read over the issues with it.
The plot is quite simple, but steeped in mystery. Mysterious doors open across the world, followed by holograms touting the end of the world in 6 months - and portray themselves as humanity's saviour. Step through the doors, be saved, and integrate into their alternate universe world. Are they telling the truth?
I would say the story overall is about mental health - at least book 1 is. The main character's severe anxiety and med dependency is the constant talking point but also handled really well in my opinion and was pretty realistic. I liked how therapy was approached, it didn't demonise it or even make out like it cures all and is perfect for everyone.
The mystery is quite strong, I love how it was strung along right up until the fantastic ending. The cliffhanger is a strong one, but it's such an explosive ending that I don't really mind too much.
The sci-fi as well is pretty light, mainly just the futuristic holographic doors that introduces that side of things. It is a book about humanity and survival.
It most certainly has it's issues though. It really needed another proofreader or 2, there's a ton of very obvious and basic typos and issues throughout it - something incredibly surprising for a re-print of a 2016 book... There's also a slight under-thread of the "magical cure" trope (but this does actually play into themes even if not directly addressed imo) and one instance of outing another person without their permission is a good thing? Someone refusing to out another person without permission is portrayed as a bad thing and that was just... kinda uncomfortable honestly. The queer rep is nice, that moment was not. It's also not challenged, it happens, it's made out to be a bad thing and then the characters continue.
I would still recommend it though. This might be my lowest rated recommended book, but honestly I think the story and themes are strong enough to make it an enjoyable and gripping read over the issues with it.
Content Warnings
Graphic: Mental illness, Violence, Physical abuse, Addiction, Alcohol, Panic attacks/disorders, Outing, and Drug abuse
Moderate: Sexism, Religious bigotry, Medical content, Homophobia, Misogyny, Grief, and Injury/Injury detail
Minor: Death of parent
While not war exactly, the book covers topics around an apocalyptic scenario and the break down of society in that situation.
More...