bev_reads_mysteries's review against another edition
3.0
In The Puzzle of the Silver Persian, Stuart Palmer takes the indomitable Hildegarde Withers--schoolteacher and amateur sleuth--on a vacation to England via the S. S. American Diplomat. She's hoping to get away from crime for a while and recover from her last adventure--a rather ghastly one for her in which she was instrumental in sending a couple to the gallows. But before the passengers go ashore in England one young woman has disappeared, suicide or thrown overboard?, and the suspect in her disappearance is dead from cyanide. The police seem willing to believe that the bartender killed the girl and then himself, but Miss Withers isn't so sure. And when threatening notes begin showing up and more deaths follow, it would seem that she was right to be doubtful. It isn't until she visits the Cornwall castle home of two of her fellow passengers and understands the clue left by Tobermory, the silver Persian cat in question, that the puzzle is finally unraveled.
Miss Withers is a bit out of her element in this one. She suffers from sea sickness which throws her off her balance--and then, of course, in England she doesn't have the trust in her abilities that she enjoys from Detective Piper back home. But the Scotland Yard men soon learn that Hildegarde knows her stuff and can, as she says, smell murder, and it doesn't take her too long to find her sea legs on board ship and get her bearings in England. The humor generally found in Palmer's work is very much in evidence--I particularly like the way he works the titular feline into the story (without making things too cutesy) and he also introduces a rather depressed robin by the name of Dicon. Both will be very important to the solving of the mystery. There are plenty of clues for the observant reader to pick up in this rather fine vintage mystery. Three and a half stars.
This was first posted on my blog My Reader's Block. Please request permission before reposting. Thanks.
Miss Withers is a bit out of her element in this one. She suffers from sea sickness which throws her off her balance--and then, of course, in England she doesn't have the trust in her abilities that she enjoys from Detective Piper back home. But the Scotland Yard men soon learn that Hildegarde knows her stuff and can, as she says, smell murder, and it doesn't take her too long to find her sea legs on board ship and get her bearings in England. The humor generally found in Palmer's work is very much in evidence--I particularly like the way he works the titular feline into the story (without making things too cutesy) and he also introduces a rather depressed robin by the name of Dicon. Both will be very important to the solving of the mystery. There are plenty of clues for the observant reader to pick up in this rather fine vintage mystery. Three and a half stars.
This was first posted on my blog My Reader's Block. Please request permission before reposting. Thanks.
ssejig's review against another edition
3.0
This is the first book I've read in this series and, while I think it would have been nice to know more history on Hildegarde Withers, it wasn't absolutely necessary to understand the whole story.
Miss Withers is not enjoying her reward from the last case, a trip overseas. But she is having major seasickness and misses the excitement on board. A well-known heiress is on board and one of her tablemates plays a rather cruel trick on her. She had disappeared into a closet, supposedly with a married man, and he gifts her with a reminder of her embarrassment.
Later that night, Miss Withers is on deck, sees the girl, and when she turns around, the heiress is gone. Off the boat in the middle of the sea. But was it suicide? Or murder? The English police assume the former. There's nothing to suggest murder and it's just easier to close the case. But then the barman dies. And the rest of the people at the table that night start getting threats that arrive in black-edged (funereal) envelopes.
There's another murder before Miss Withers can figure out the solution. But she does.
An interesting story and I'm definitely interested in following more of the series.
Miss Withers is not enjoying her reward from the last case, a trip overseas. But she is having major seasickness and misses the excitement on board. A well-known heiress is on board and one of her tablemates plays a rather cruel trick on her. She had disappeared into a closet, supposedly with a married man, and he gifts her with a reminder of her embarrassment.
Later that night, Miss Withers is on deck, sees the girl, and when she turns around, the heiress is gone. Off the boat in the middle of the sea. But was it suicide? Or murder? The English police assume the former. There's nothing to suggest murder and it's just easier to close the case. But then the barman dies. And the rest of the people at the table that night start getting threats that arrive in black-edged (funereal) envelopes.
There's another murder before Miss Withers can figure out the solution. But she does.
An interesting story and I'm definitely interested in following more of the series.
More...