Reviews
A Most Imperfect Union: A Contrarian History of the United States by Lalo Alcaraz, Ilan Stavans
acinthedc's review against another edition
2.0
Stavans states the intent of this book is to tell the history of America from a different perspective. Unfortunately, this reads like a pretty straightforward history text without much of a contrarian perspective. There is a lack of cohesiveness to the text and unnecessary pop culture references. There are a number of books cited that may actually provide a more nuanced and contrarian view on US history. Overall 1.5 out of 5
martig's review against another edition
1.0
I couldn't finish reading this as closely as I wanted to originally. There are SO many interruptions from the author, with stuff that just doesn't matter. I had high hopes for this, but I ended up not liking it much at all.
nerdella_reads's review against another edition
5.0
True to his word, the author contradicts himself in several places while pontificating, but that is part of what made this a good read. Depending on your experiences and what aspect of history you are examining, your perception changes. I also lived how the art was a juxtaposition of amazing ink drawings and rough sketches.
rushfan77's review against another edition
3.0
I was expecting to read about something I had not read before but I was disappointed.
jameseckman's review
2.0
While dubbed a contrarian history of the US, you'd have to an extreme right-winger to find much wrong with this book. On the other hand, it covers 500+ years of history in a graphics format, so its pretty watered down. The illustrations are decent, but I don't feel they add much to the text. An OK read for anyone with a passing familiarity of US history and possibly a good read for those without.
More...