ladywrenalot's review against another edition
2.0
Maybe coming to this midway through a series is not the best strategy. I found it very difficult to engage with the characters. and there's the usual problem that fantasy has to feature the exploitation of women. not overly impressed.
It is also more a collection of short stories shoved into a loosely themed collection. Each section bore no relation to the others so the overall story didn't flow. Very disappointing. The author is certainly a product of his time.
It is also more a collection of short stories shoved into a loosely themed collection. Each section bore no relation to the others so the overall story didn't flow. Very disappointing. The author is certainly a product of his time.
esttorhe's review
Niece piece of middle earth narration.
Very imaginative with absorbing arguments
7/10
Very imaginative with absorbing arguments
7/10
More...