hiltzmoore's review against another edition
3.0
This was an unusual book. I usually give a lot of credit to young adult books that do not speak down/dumb down their writing simply because of a younger audience. This book was fairly well written and didn't dumb down content, but I didn't find the main characters likable, and I'm not really sure what the point of book was, exactly. It reminded me a little of Twilight in that the main character yearns for nothing for herself except being with her man. I found the book enjoyable enough, but wished for a stronger main character.
maireadingnook's review against another edition
4.0
3.5 ⭐s *sigh*
I think this would have been better from Josh's POV. Maybe then I'd understand what actually made him fall in love with Isla? I like Josh. But I feel like I still don't know who Isla even is
I think this would have been better from Josh's POV. Maybe then I'd understand what actually made him fall in love with Isla? I like Josh. But I feel like I still don't know who Isla even is
chloenm3's review against another edition
5.0
I loved this book so much!! I felt that Stephanie's writing has developed A LOT over the companion trilogy. This book was fast moving and I adored that - also Isla is my fav.
mandiluna's review against another edition
1.0
boring.
Edit 1: I feel like this review still stands. This book was just not it.
11/19/21
Literally the worst book in the trilogy. Josh and Isa argue all the time and I can’t even tell why they like each other.
The book is interesting in the “ I can’t look away from the train wreck” way
Edit 1: I feel like this review still stands. This book was just not it.
11/19/21
Literally the worst book in the trilogy. Josh and Isa argue all the time and I can’t even tell why they like each other.
The book is interesting in the “ I can’t look away from the train wreck” way
lissajean7's review against another edition
5.0
So good.
I really enjoyed this one. I adore both Josh and Isla. A lot. I wish the book came with sketches. I want to see his art. I think I like this one better than Anna's story.
I really enjoyed this one. I adore both Josh and Isla. A lot. I wish the book came with sketches. I want to see his art. I think I like this one better than Anna's story.
4lberj's review
3.0
Me atrevería a decir que, a pesar de haberle dado la misma nota que a los otros dos libros, este es mi favorito. Lo he devorado prácticamente en una tarde. Es verdad que Isla era un poco insoportable en algunos momentos, ha logrado transmitirme todas sus emociones a lo largo de la historia.
whatabouthayley's review against another edition
5.0
Definitely my favorite Stephanie Perkins novel so far!