suannelaqueur's review
2.0
Eh?... it's subject matter I always find interesting but on this one I didn't find the story engaging or the characters particularly compelling. I could take it or leave it.
askmashka's review against another edition
adventurous
inspiring
reflective
medium-paced
sssnoo's review
5.0
What a fantastic book. I never would have found this author or this book had I not joined the Goodreads 50 States Challenge and reached North Dakota. This is a true find. The book follwos a family from the end of WWI through the mid 1950’s and if you are from the midwest or central plains (I am from Iowa) you recognize the culture. The book is more than that though. The writing is lyrical and full of suprises, both in plot and style. I was taken aback by nuances in the sentances within the chapter “The Snakeman” for example (I won’t give spoilers). Their is not really one plot, one story; the book takes one direction then another and comes back full circle as it travles the decades, finally connecting all the dots. So many times I was hooked and stayed longer than I should have to finish a thread. Then the book would meander a bit with the characters as ther eader bonded more and more with their humaness. Oh I loved this book.
In some ways this book remined me of A Gentleman in Moscow. More in the way it delves into characters and personalities as they develop and grow over a lifetime; how these people influence others and also with a background storyline that comes full circle and leaves you satisfied and suprised at the end. A masterpiece.
In some ways this book remined me of A Gentleman in Moscow. More in the way it delves into characters and personalities as they develop and grow over a lifetime; how these people influence others and also with a background storyline that comes full circle and leaves you satisfied and suprised at the end. A masterpiece.
read1knit2's review
4.0
I'd only read a short story by Erdrich, before so I went in with some preconceived notions.
Erdrich based this loosely on the life of her grandparents. I read an interview where she did say that it is mostly fiction, however. The story is so complex and the characters so detailed that I found this world completely believable.
I did enjoy the first 2/3 of the book much more than the last 1/3. I think she could have ended it sooner.
Some may find it a bit slow moving, but I enjoyed the details and richness.
Highly recommended!
Erdrich based this loosely on the life of her grandparents. I read an interview where she did say that it is mostly fiction, however. The story is so complex and the characters so detailed that I found this world completely believable.
I did enjoy the first 2/3 of the book much more than the last 1/3. I think she could have ended it sooner.
Some may find it a bit slow moving, but I enjoyed the details and richness.
Highly recommended!
zoracious's review
5.0
[Review written by my younger self]
This being the fifth book I've read from the prolific Louise Erdrich, I was at first both disappointed and intrigued by her break from her normal Ojibwe dynasty that make up the residents of a fictional North Dakota town known as Argus. After the first few pages, though, I pleasantly discovered Erdrich had simply widened her character scope to welcome some interesting and likeable characters. Included in this new group is a family of German immigrants, headed by the master butcher, Fidelis, and his steadfast wife, Eva. On the other end is Delphine Watzka, a quietly determined woman who knows, with equal expertise, how to balance chairs on her stomach, how to take care of her town drunk of a father, and how to love Cyprian, a man who for his own reasons may not be as compelled to return her love. Add a few more equally memorable characters to this mix, not to mention a men's singing club, and you are left with lyrically compelling and highly memorable novel.
This is not wholly a story about World War I and World War II, but the wars push their way to the forefront as overpowering aspects of Fidelis and Cyprian's recent past, and as overwhelming aspects of the future of Fidelis and Eva's four sons. Commingled with these conflicts are also conflicts of the heart and body --- a tempered love, a fatal affliction, a desire to care as well as to destroy. Erdrich, just like Delphine with her chairs, plays these elements in a delicate balancing act that creates a sometimes calming, sometimes electrifying flow of words and images.
Rising above this flow, more strongly here than in any of her other novels, is the gift of song. Dedicating the book to "my father, who sang to me", Erdrich uses the power of a good story as a love song to the people and events that charm even the most charmless lives.
Frequent readers of Erdrich may find themselves at a loss with this new cast of characters, though I actually was glad for the change. The humor of her other novels is also present here in smaller doses, and her imagery is vivid, at times almost arresting.
As with other Erdrich novels, though, be prepared to take in many subplots that have within them a valid attraction. I find that I often develop favorite subplots or supporting characters, and sometimes have to remind myself of the others. I did not have to do so in this case, which leads me to believe this novel more compact in its presentation than previous novels. First-time readers of Erdrich need not be hindered by a lack of knowledge about Argus folklore; though the novel does lead to Erdrich's favorite literary shelter, the introduction to the town is skillfully rendered.
In the end, however, it is hard to tell if the feeling readers are left with is bittersweet. The tidal wave that is supposed to consume the main characters in the end seems closer to a shallow puddle, which may or may not be what Erdrich intended in the first place. While this hardly takes away from the enjoyment of the novel, it does leave me wanting more.
This being the fifth book I've read from the prolific Louise Erdrich, I was at first both disappointed and intrigued by her break from her normal Ojibwe dynasty that make up the residents of a fictional North Dakota town known as Argus. After the first few pages, though, I pleasantly discovered Erdrich had simply widened her character scope to welcome some interesting and likeable characters. Included in this new group is a family of German immigrants, headed by the master butcher, Fidelis, and his steadfast wife, Eva. On the other end is Delphine Watzka, a quietly determined woman who knows, with equal expertise, how to balance chairs on her stomach, how to take care of her town drunk of a father, and how to love Cyprian, a man who for his own reasons may not be as compelled to return her love. Add a few more equally memorable characters to this mix, not to mention a men's singing club, and you are left with lyrically compelling and highly memorable novel.
This is not wholly a story about World War I and World War II, but the wars push their way to the forefront as overpowering aspects of Fidelis and Cyprian's recent past, and as overwhelming aspects of the future of Fidelis and Eva's four sons. Commingled with these conflicts are also conflicts of the heart and body --- a tempered love, a fatal affliction, a desire to care as well as to destroy. Erdrich, just like Delphine with her chairs, plays these elements in a delicate balancing act that creates a sometimes calming, sometimes electrifying flow of words and images.
Rising above this flow, more strongly here than in any of her other novels, is the gift of song. Dedicating the book to "my father, who sang to me", Erdrich uses the power of a good story as a love song to the people and events that charm even the most charmless lives.
Frequent readers of Erdrich may find themselves at a loss with this new cast of characters, though I actually was glad for the change. The humor of her other novels is also present here in smaller doses, and her imagery is vivid, at times almost arresting.
As with other Erdrich novels, though, be prepared to take in many subplots that have within them a valid attraction. I find that I often develop favorite subplots or supporting characters, and sometimes have to remind myself of the others. I did not have to do so in this case, which leads me to believe this novel more compact in its presentation than previous novels. First-time readers of Erdrich need not be hindered by a lack of knowledge about Argus folklore; though the novel does lead to Erdrich's favorite literary shelter, the introduction to the town is skillfully rendered.
In the end, however, it is hard to tell if the feeling readers are left with is bittersweet. The tidal wave that is supposed to consume the main characters in the end seems closer to a shallow puddle, which may or may not be what Erdrich intended in the first place. While this hardly takes away from the enjoyment of the novel, it does leave me wanting more.
kcmc59's review
5.0
Erdrich has a gift for taking very ordinary people and make them extraordinary. The tale of this family, who find themselves on both sides of WWI, brings the hardships of immigrant families memorably to life. As a descendant of German immigrants from the Midwest, this book opened my eyes to something of what their lives must have been like.
carajago's review against another edition
4.0
This book was good. Not what I'd call a page-turner, but definitely good.
idonthavebroadband's review
emotional
reflective
relaxing
sad
medium-paced
- Plot- or character-driven? Character
- Strong character development? Yes
- Loveable characters? Yes
- Diverse cast of characters? It's complicated
- Flaws of characters a main focus? Yes
4.0
bobbo49's review
4.0
Not my favorite Erdrich book, but a well written and engaging novel nonetheless. I felt that the story jumped around a bit too much, but the characters are well developed and the complicated story does pull together in the end.